Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

[jbradt]

Just wondering about something here JB, with all the stuff going on about JM saying he hasn't seen "joke votes" before, I have to ask. Have you really never seen the "joke votes" go toward the Mod before?
As far as him fooling everyone but Kash last game, that's not entirely true either, I pretty much figured he was...just got a bit side tracked being wrong on others, but he pretty much stood out to me most the game.

I can honestly say that I don't recall ever seeing a vote for the mod bolded like we've seen in this game. It may have happened, but I don't remember it, and I'm not going back through every game I've played to see if it's happened.

You may have had JM pegged last game, LG. If that's the case, you fooled me as much as he fooled most of the town. :nilly: I guess I'll just never figure you out, G.

 

[jpappy789]

I see what you're saying, Pappy. I guess what I was trying to say is that I see why people are grilling the dude, he's said some iffy stuff. What I don't see, and what really gives me a sphincter reaction is how quickly everyone seems to be ready to condemn him. I would never rule anyone out as a later possibility... especially on day 1.

I also said I wouldn't be voting for you tonight, Pappy. Is that suspicious as well?

Well, I'm not at all surprised that people jumped since it was a very questionable post to begin with. I understand hesitation about voting but saying that you will absolutely not be voting for someone leaves no room for change. And I am talking about today's game day only, since there is still plenty of time to vote. What if nothing better comes up?

I suppose it is also somewhat suspicious that you are already ruling me out as a D1 vote. I was focusing more on the Jm part given the context though.

 

[Lady G]

I can honestly say that I don't recall ever seeing a vote for the mod bolded like we've seen in this game. It may have happened, but I don't remember it, and I'm not going back through every game I've played to see if it's happened.

You may have had JM pegged last game, LG. If that's the case, you fooled me as much as he fooled most of the town. :nilly: I guess I'll just never figure you out, G.

Well, it's happened and it's happened quite a bit. May not always be bolded but still even in bold really doesn't seem much of a big deal IMO?

I decided to look back to last game's day one also....since you were saying the last few have started pretty intense (or whatever your word was)...really seemed pretty laid back and silly to start out, not as much as the votes, but it was pretty lighthearted bantering, role playing and messin with FF for quite some time.

Naw, I doubt you'll have much luck in figuring me out...I still have a hard time with that one.

 

[jbradt]

Well, I'm not at all surprised that people jumped since it was a very questionable post to begin with. I understand hesitation about voting but saying that you will absolutely not be voting for someone leaves no room for change. And I am talking about today's game day only, since there is still plenty of time to vote. What if nothing better comes up?

I suppose it is also somewhat suspicious that you are already ruling me out as a D1 vote. I was focusing more on the Jm part given the context though.

So, let me ask you this, Pappy... in my ruling you out as a day 1 vote, am I sparing an innocent or a wolf?

 

[Lady G]

I see what you're saying, Pappy. I guess what I was trying to say is that I see why people are grilling the dude, he's said some iffy stuff. What I don't see, and what really gives me a sphincter reaction is how quickly everyone seems to be ready to condemn him. I would never rule anyone out as a later possibility... especially on day 1.

I also said I wouldn't be voting for you tonight, Pappy. Is that suspicious as well?

Personally, my biggest problem with his posts about it is, not that he said it but the fact he flat out denies it happens when it is a very common thing on day one.

 

[jpappy789]

So, let me ask you this, Pappy... in my ruling you out as a day 1 vote, am I sparing an innocent or a wolf?

I don't see the point of even answering this question.

Would doing so mean anything to anyone in the game? No.

 

[Lady G]

So, let me ask you this, Pappy... in my ruling you out as a day 1 vote, am I sparing an innocent or a wolf?

:thud:I love these questions....yes, Pap if you are WW please confess now.

 

[jpappy789]

AAaaaarRRrrrrOOOooOOOOO!

I mean...no, I am not a werewolf.

 

[jbradt]

Well, it's happened and it's happened quite a bit. May not always be bolded but still even in bold really doesn't seem much of a big deal IMO?

I decided to look back to last game's day one also....since you were saying the last few have started pretty intense (or whatever your word was)...really seemed pretty laid back and silly to start out, not as much as the votes, but it was pretty lighthearted bantering, role playing and messin with FF for quite some time.

Naw, I doubt you'll have much luck in figuring me out...I still have a hard time with that one.

LOL... first things first: I gave up trying to figure out women probably around the time FF was born. :lol2: don't get me wrong... I <3 you all to bits, but figure out? That's just funny.

Basically, my stance on day 1 (at least when I'm a townie) is to give people the benefit of the doubt. When I ask questions, I wait for responses and try to think logically as opposed to jumping on the first thing that seems the slightest bit scummy.

I also didn't think the joke votes were a big deal. I still don't. This is the first day 1 in a long time that I've actually enjoyed being a part of because of all the screwing around and light-heartedness. But this isn't really about how we feel about it. The question is did JM see it as a big deal. I think it safe to say he did. Would a wolf think it was a big deal? I don't think so. Wouldn't the wolves want the meaningless banter to go on as long as possible?

I really don't want to talk about JM anymore. I think we have our minds made up and will see the outcome at nightfall. At this point, I'm starting to feel like I'm being forced to defend him when all I was trying to say in the beginning was that I don't have enough to vote him night 1. It also feels like we're spending so much time on this that we're losing the forest for the tree.

 

[jbradt]

AAaaaarRRrrrrOOOooOOOOO!

I mean...no, I am not a werewolf.

Thanks. So, if you're not a WW, then by ruling you out as an option; I've spared a townie night one. One step closer to the goal of lynching a WW. It seems this would strike you as solid reasoning rather than suspicious.

When the odds are in favor of lynching a townie, why are you so against ruling people out? It seems to me that process of elimination is as good a method as any... and better than some.