Mafia #74...ACville Penitentiary!

FYI LG

rich311k said:
I have no idea what scum would think. Maybe my votes and thoughts were way off base?

I will be back later hopefully early evening. Just in case Kathy decides we need to do something else, I vote to shank dd.

I do not get her thoughts or strange ideas last evening. She has not provided much of use and seems to be acting in a scummy manner.

I will get on if I get access to computer.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
Vote count:

DD-(1)-Pap"1101"

Night fall tonight at 9pm central
Click to expand...
 
TwoHobbies said:
I like your list Ice, as long as I can add you to it that is.

I'd like to come at the game from a different angle. The thing that bothered me the most about last night (other than losing JM) was the beat down of RB.

Why RB...he wasn't really playing. They had to call in two names.

Lets go back to night one. JB already admitted to someone before nightfall (forgive me for not looking up the thread) that he would get back Labby first chance next game he was evil. We know they beat LR on day one, but who would have been there next biggest threat.

My list would have been Ice, Jpap, JM, Rich. On night two the town/cell block took JM off the list, but how the H--- does RB make it on. I'll tell you what I think....two of those three are snitches.

So Ice am I to believe your not a threat to the snitches, or do you think you won two coin flips?

I understand Jpap isn't around so I won't bother to ask him. (seems a little convenient) I also took note that he did make it on to vote so he won't UD.

And Rich why do you think RB was more of a threat to the snitches than you are.
Click to expand...

I don't expect to be cleared in anyones eyes by far. I can only hope I was investigated and that at least 3 of you know I am cleared of all wrong doing.
My list is a process of elimination. I could be wrong about Jpap and it could be Bally. Like I said I can't find any reason to clear those 3.

As for not being hit I think there are 3possible reasons. 1st they need to send in 2 names, that gives me 50/50 chance of surviving.2nd I haven't exactly been spot on this game so I'm really not a threat and am helping not hurting them.3rd I think if the team is DD and Bally that they thought they had RB pegged as spy.

I have a friend coming by this afternoon so I'll be scarce but will be around tonight.

I also vote to shank DD she has by far been acting the strangest of the 3.
 
Why do you think DD is innocent? Was it her vote for Rich for calling you Al? Was it her vote for Pir because he was active to hide his role as evil because he was evil and laying low last game.
Is it her list where she says the scum team is me RB and JB then she drops JB?Is it because she thinks Tay is protecting Rich?

I'd suspect you for protecting DD but man that would be a great distancing job by you and JB.
 
IceH2O said:
I'm pulling Jpaps last list again, the one he had before he reached and voted Noods last night.

Judging by how hard JB went after UN 2H and JM and that mafia almost always name one of their own I feel good about a Jpap DD team.



Here is DDs list:



Non committal on UN and 2H. New JM was innocent so defended him. Tay is protecting Rich, which clears Rich IMO.

The team of me JB and RB got turned into me and RB, who we know was innocent.
JB was dropped from that team.



Yeah I feel pretty good about Jpap and DD, the only one I can't actually clear yet is Bally.
Click to expand...


Please do not clear Rich on my account. I don't know if he's innocent or scum. I just really felt that DD had a bogus reason for voting him. I wasn't really defending him, just questioning her methods. Which she didn't like very much.

Kind of the same thing with Bally. I don't know if she's scum or not. I felt the reasons that JM and RB were going after her were pretty lame. More of defending her intelligence than defending her because I think she's innocent. Definitely thinking twice about her now that RB is dead.
 
Right now I would be pretty comfortable voting for DD. Whatever that was last night, it wasn't helpful to the town.

Something that could have been helpful would be her backing up RB's claim that Bally was coming on and off the thread. Since they are both mods, they would have both seen. Anyone have any thoughts on that?

Going to keep my vote for now since I will be around. I don't want anyone to get too comfortable with all the votes on DD.
 
I went back and checked 2H's posts. I see what you guys are saying.
 
Taysius said:
Right now I would be pretty comfortable voting for DD. Whatever that was last night, it wasn't helpful to the town.

Something that could have been helpful would be her backing up RB's claim that Bally was coming on and off the thread. Since they are both mods, they would have both seen. Anyone have any thoughts on that?

Going to keep my vote for now since I will be around. I don't want anyone to get too comfortable with all the votes on DD.
Click to expand...

Bally has been visible as far as I've seen. Mods can see through the invisible setting, but Bally said that she was checking the thread from her phone as she's on a road trip. It's perfectly reasonable that a person would appear to be going on and off the thread in that situation.

I sometimes check the thread while I'm at work. If something happens and somebody needs me then I quickly shut it off and attend whatever is going on. That would give me the same appearance of gong on and off the thread.

It's possible that she's going back and fourth between the game thread and scum chat, but there are too many other perfectly valid reasons that she could appear to be going off and on for me to use this as an argument for her being scum.

Personally, I don't see being invisible or visible as a scum tell.
 
Zaffy said:
Personally, I don't see being invisible or visible as a scum tell.
Click to expand...


Since Bally has never played before I'd like to know who told her to go invisible. She was visible during the 1st day. I saw her post yesterday and she wasn't visible. It could be the phone doesn't show her visible. I check from my phone sometimes from work but I'm not logged in and it shows me as guest.

I'm not saying its a scum tell but I'm not going to just totally dismiss it.
 
So how about a breakdown of everyones supects?

Why or why not you think they are or aren't scum?

You've got mine.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom