Mafia #74...ACville Penitentiary!

She was visible in the start of the game and seemed to go invisible at least by last night. I saw this myself and I believe Ice did as well.

She mentioned that she didn't realize she was invisible, and that's something that doesn't make sense to me. Noods brought up that it might be because she's on her phone, but I'm honestly not sure what to think of it. I have no way of telling if it's possible.

My issue isn't so much that she's gone invisible and is checking the thread. Its a pretty stupid thing to pick on people about, IMO. Its more that she hasn't contributed a whole lot to help the town but has been around enough to defend herself. Also that RB brought it up among other things about her and now he is dead. He didn't seem to be that strong of a player for the town, so why him? Was he on to something or was it a set up to frame Bally?
 
IceH2O said:
Since Bally has never played before I'd like to know who told her to go invisible. She was visible during the 1st day. I saw her post yesterday and she wasn't visible. It could be the phone doesn't show her visible. I check from my phone sometimes from work but I'm not logged in and it shows me as guest.

I'm not saying its a scum tell but I'm not going to just totally dismiss it.
Click to expand...


Going to throw in here that no one ever told me to go invisible last game. I picked up on it myself that it was the thing to do.

For her to be able to post she has to be logged in, right? So she wouldn't show as a guest. Wouldn't the settings for showing her online be under her forum settings and not her phone? The more I think about it, the more I don't like the whole " I didn't realize I was invisible."
 
I just tested it. I logged off and cleared my cookies on this comp. loaded the page as a guest and verified that my name wasn't viewing the thread. I loaded it up on my phone and hit refresh. My name showed up.

So, viewing from the phone does show.
 
Not looking good Bally, want to snitch on the rest of your team?

What are your thoughts on the remaining players Bally?
 
IceH2O said:
So how about a breakdown of everyones supects?

Why or why not you think they are or aren't scum?

You've got mine.
Click to expand...

Rich - Typical quiet self. I can't read him. The Al thing didn't bother me a bit. Some people don't adapt to calling people by their screen names. I saw it all the time when I played WoW.

Zaff - Seems quieter than the last game played where he was innocent. Hasn't contributed a whole lot of helpful information. I'm sort of leaning him scummy but I just don't know.

User - Same playstyle as the last time. Sporadic and frustrating to the town. I think he talks big to fit in with the crowd as a kid, but not so much as a snitch.

Ice - Seems helpful to the town. I feel like I can trust him, but he could be fooling me too. Doesn't say a ton, but when he speaks it makes sense to me.

Chill - Would like to see more from him. His call on JB last night tells me he is innocent though.

Bally - Need to see more, but I am getting suspicious. I don't like the catching on too quick case because I feel it's insulting. Maybe she didn't like it either and got back at RB for it. I really don't know.

Pap - I have no idea. I'm not convinced either way but I'm going to trust in you guys and your observations of him for now and place him on the scummy side. When I get less lazy tonight I will go through and read a bit more of his posts more thoroughly. Then I can make my own observation.

Noods - JB's vote last night tells me she is innocent since he locked in on her.

2H - Saw something about JB. I don't think he would have brought it up like that if they were on the same team.

Doll - Can we say Scummy McScumpants the 2nd? I've already explained my thoughts on her a few times. She is my strongest suspect right now.
 
Zaffy said:
I just tested it. I logged off and cleared my cookies on this comp. loaded the page as a guest and verified that my name wasn't viewing the thread. I loaded it up on my phone and hit refresh. My name showed up.

So, viewing from the phone does show.
Click to expand...

Thanks Zaff, that right there was pretty dang helpful. Thank you. My outlook on you just leaned more innocent. :)
 
Taysius said:
Please do not clear Rich on my account. I don't know if he's innocent or scum. I just really felt that DD had a bogus reason for voting him. I wasn't really defending him, just questioning her methods. Which she didn't like very much.

Kind of the same thing with Bally. I don't know if she's scum or not. I felt the reasons that JM and RB were going after her were pretty lame. More of defending her intelligence than defending her because I think she's innocent. Definitely thinking twice about her now that RB is dead.
Click to expand...

Was reading through todays posts again and I want to clarify this.

I'm not saying Rich is cleared because Tay defended Rich. I'm saying it because DD pointed at Tay for defending Rich.I guess I really shouldn't use that to clear Rich as it could be to setup Tay if Rich was lynched and shown scum but makes me feel better about Tay.
 
I'm not trying to clear DD. I can easily see the case for her. I just want to look at all options.
I certainly didn't agree with her reasoning for voting Rich. He has called me Al before in this game.
 
I haven't been able to really read the thread very well.

I think the case against DD is strongest. Her arguments seem too contrived. I don't buy for a minute that she seriously believes Rich is scum. Unless that is, that she knows for sure.

The fact that Jpap and JB voted together twice is interesting, but I think they're both better players than to be so obvious.

Ice, I think he's been helping the town. I think noods is right that he hasn't been his regular self, but I think he's doing more than she's giving credit for. I don't get the vibe that he has any agenda against anyone though, I lean him innocent.

2H I lean innocent. Like Ice said, it's the best distance job ever if he's scum.

Bally, I don't know what RB saw against her, as he refused to back up his thoughts. I could see where the scum team may have been spooked by him causing them to choose him as a hit candidate.

Tay I think is asking good questions and being very pro-town.

UN i still don't trust. He was way too squirrelly for me on N1. Nothing stands out lately, maybe his team has him finally shutting up?

I wish I had a better case on someone else because I hate such a pile up, but I vote to shank DD. I can't see passed her weak arguments.
 
you guys are making it hard for me to place an OMGUS vote.... as far as Icebeing so helpful for the town, can someone point me to those posts where he is so helpful? All ive seen is him make a bunch of accusing posts on innocents.... was there a time Ice suspected jb before things were getting close to night in hopes of distancing tactics?

Posted on mobile.aquariacentral.com
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom