Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

IceH2O said:
Where did he say no doubt in his mind? I have JM as a high on the list suspect but when players put words in others mouth like that it bothers me. I'm not moving though because FF did the same thing and looked what happened, not that I'm calling Rich an FF.

But all you're doing in rehashing what others have said and followed the crowd today. Do you not have any of your own suspects? Day 1 was the only day I saw you out on your own Day 2 you grilled FF after others already were and jumped in late with a vote. Now PP has players eyes and again you fall in line.
Reading further along I see you finally went after someone not previously looked at by anyone. Shame its not accurate. But I'll get to that later.

Ugh UDs suck! Hope all goes well.

I agree with the fluff and disappearing act. She used a RL excuse but that doesn't always fly in these games and I take them with a grain of salt.

But you can't say anything about following, you have been doing the same.

PMSL, these games wouldn't be fun without DD.

Day 1 Razz voted PP so I don't know where Bally is getting her info.

If Razz had gone anywhere else but FF it might have looked suspicious especially when she claimed she hadn't read the prior days events except to see FF in the lead. A late vote not jumping on someone turning up innocent is pretty scummy too. As a jock it was a safer place to hide for Razz especially since it wasn't the kill vote.

Again you're wrong she voted PP.

Explain to me who you voted for each day and why?
JB because you think he was hiding in plain sight.
late on FF because???? Why did it take so long to place your vote there again??

Back to Day 1 if PP turns up innocent tonight you are going to be my next vote. You conveniently were able to keep out of the UN/PP vote and placed a vote on the innocent hit as a hiding spot IMO.
Click to expand...
so I am guessing you won't be giving a reason either (along with everyone else)... really, I did try to read more closely to figure it out but the posts going back and forth so much, but the 4th or 5th one, I'm kinda like "bzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz".... but I did really try my best!

Ballyhoo said:
Jm- he is erratic, inconsistent and generally vague and confusing
PP- seems as if he slipped up at some point in the beginning and was told to hush, or he was just going along with day 1 banter and joking around and enjoying role playing. I can't rule him one way or another.
RB and DD- very quite but from playing the last game with them they seem to be more active at night. I'd like to see more from them
Razz- I don't feel as uneasy with razz as I did before, I realized my mistake and then how little sense my post made. ( Razz I'm sorry for calling you a girl )

I'm having a hard time getting a read on
Tay
Chill
Ice
Noods and Mav
Click to expand...
really, Bally, that's quite interesting.... so when did you start playing mafia anyway... you know, where you played with me in the game with you..... last game I was in was almost a full month before you even registered for the site.... so wherre are you getting this advice from.... didn't your teammates proffread your notes before you went and pasted it here?
 
I thought you were in the last one i played
if you find it really that scummy go ahead and lynch me for it.
The last game I played my teammates DID proof read my posts....no such luck this time
 
Phew, the drive from San Antonio, TX to Princeton, NJ is a long one, glad I'm at the end. Now I'll have the time and internet service to really go through things.


jm1212 said:
And yes you did totally dodge my question in the beginning. You tried to be sly and try to answer my question with your own.

So according to you, I shouldn't call out something that looks suspicious to me? I thought I was supposed to ask questions about what I thought was odd? Didn't you just try to tell me you thought LG's behavior was scummy so you asked questions and ultimately voted for her because of it? Yes, you did. But now that I'm questioning you, you're getting all ruffled up about just simply explaining your vote and answering some of my questions. If they really were stupid and meaningless like you are trying to sell, then they should have been easy to answer without a single second thought. That's why I think you have something to hide after all.
Click to expand...

Just wanted to address this again. I think you're referring to me answering your "what if LG is innocent? with a question. It didn't seem like a legit question as there is no way to really answer it. Seemed rhetorical. I have no problem being questioned, but once I answer said question I do not feel the need to answer it ten more times.

Zaffy said:
picard-facepalm.jpg
Click to expand...

What's that for? You're the one who asked...

noodles62 said:
Still digging but this really stuck out to me now that we know LG was innocent. I need to keep digging and see if I'm on the right track about Labby......
Click to expand...

Wrong track, but I'd like to see your reasoning...me pointing out that LG tends to think scum are innocent is why you're saying I'm scum? She went after me pretty hard.

jm1212 said:
Razz did not vote for me on day one. He 'spent Day 1 gilling PP' and then voted him.
Click to expand...

How do you gill someone? Does it hurt?
 
Lab_Rat said:
Phew, the drive from San Antonio, TX to Princeton, NJ is a long one, glad I'm at the end. Now I'll have the time and internet service to really go through things.




Just wanted to address this again. I think you're referring to me answering your "what if LG is innocent? with a question. It didn't seem like a legit question as there is no way to really answer it. Seemed rhetorical. I have no problem being questioned, but once I answer said question I do not feel the need to answer it ten more times.



What's that for? You're the one who asked...



Wrong track, but I'd like to see your reasoning...me pointing out that LG tends to think scum are innocent is why you're saying I'm scum? She went after me pretty hard.



How do you gill someone? Does it hurt?
Click to expand...
woops, drilling :rolleyes:
 
Lab_Rat said:
Wrong track, but I'd like to see your reasoning...me pointing out that LG tends to think scum are innocent is why you're saying I'm scum? She went after me pretty hard.
Click to expand...

Checking in really quick. mom in law is here for dinner/the evening again......

Labby, If you care to note my vote for you was prior to pulling the quotes about LG reading scum wrong. After I pulled those, I am not so sure anymore. I got interrupted at work too often today to maintain a good train of thought. My vote is likely to change but no need to retract it until I know where I want it....

Hopefully later tonite I can go back and look into a few others and see where my thoughts/suspicions are. .....more later.
 
noodles62 said:
Checking in really quick. mom in law is here for dinner/the evening again......

Labby, If you care to note my vote for you was prior to pulling the quotes about LG reading scum wrong. After I pulled those, I am not so sure anymore. I got interrupted at work too often today to maintain a good train of thought. My vote is likely to change but no need to retract it until I know where I want it....

Hopefully later tonite I can go back and look into a few others and see where my thoughts/suspicions are. .....more later.
Click to expand...

I read your vote on me, with a statement about reasoning why to follow, then you pulled what I said about LG picking scum for innocents. That is what I thought your reason for voting me was. What is your reason for voting me?

Also, did Zaffy make tonight nightfall or tomorrow?
 
Zaffy said:
Player list: (14)]

Next nightfall will be Saturday, August 7th, at 6pm pacific. Unless everyone want's it tomorrow instead.
Click to expand...

YOU SKIMMED YOU MUST BE JOCK AND SCUM AND EVIL OH AND A JOCK TOO!!!
:eek3: :rolleyes:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom