Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[maverickbr77]

Ice the "slip" just pushed me over the edge I know you like fishing so it is possible that is all it is but it would have been called scummy from anyone else I can't pass it over just because you may be fishing. Your gameplay thus far feels odd to me. The entire S4S theory is very left field way more likely he is an overacting noob just like we saw from PP last game.

 

[IceH2O]

Lab you need to post your theory then. It does us no good if we lynched an innocent player. If the theory is plausible you might get players off you and onto better suspects.

I don't see how waiting benefits you or us.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Um, okay Lab. :huh: Maybe I'm way off; maybe I'm not. It wouldn't be the first time either way.

I'll look careful at anything you have to tell us, if you decide to... Other than that, all I can do is go by what you've shown us in the thread.

I wouldn't expect any different.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice the "slip" just pushed me over the edge I know you like fishing so it is possible that is all it is but it would have been called scummy from anyone else I can't pass it over just because you may be fishing. Your gameplay thus far feels odd to me. The entire S4S theory is very left field way more likely he is an overacting noob just like we saw from PP last game.

Think what you like Mav. You've been on my mafia team before and know thats not how I play.
Salt could be just as you say. I admit I could be wrong but again I'd rather be wrong then lose our Vig.

 

[user_name]

Sympathy is not my intent. My intent is to leave the how and why about my theory for the town to use after I'm dead.

I hope the ghost chat is in this game. I want to laugh at players behind their back.

jez, it's like they are suicidal.....
So i ask myself who would their deaths help?

Guess I should also cover if Salt and or Lab are mafia.

I think with the votes so close if either is mafia you could probably write the players on them off as innocent.

The answer: The mafia. The mafia would benefit from the ability to hide their votes within the voting of lab or ice. I wouldn't put it past a good team to do something like this, where they sacrifice themself for the great good of the den. Plus, it will help seed out the snitches if the don ordered them to do so.

 

[RazzleFish]

Alright well I am back sooner than expected. Lab, what is the point in waiting until just before nightfall to tell us something important? Wouldn't it be better to tell us now so that we can think it over and possibly ask questions?

 

[user_name]

I retract my previos vote to lynch S4S and vote to lynch ice, his last few post have really been giving me the goose bumps.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Lab you need to post your theory then. It does us no good if we lynched an innocent player. If the theory is plausible you might get players off you and onto better suspects.

I don't see how waiting benefits you or us.

At this point it probably doesn't make a difference but I really need to wait until right before nightfall in case it might.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Haha, and so the mind games begin, what DID my team tell me? Or did they say anything at all? All I know, is the someone might need to get a new User_Name... (Insert Evil Laugh HERE) MUAhahaha.

GOtta go to work, might not be home before nightfall. I VOTE TO LYNCH user_name. I will explain later, but im already late.

With all that I have read, I still find this to be the most scummy in the days events.

I was just pulling your leg...I know you're joking because I 'know' you if you know what I'm saying

this perked my ears up a bit.... what is the intent of this, jm?

If you were an innocent townie wouldn't you know that innocents didn't get a PM

wow... Ice's post was even obvious to me... and I don't get a lot of stuff a lot of the time...

That's a slip-and-a-half. Only PR's and mafia got PM's.

another explanation...

Why are you protecting Ice? His game play has seemed off to me and now he posts something that could have been a slip and you push it off as Ice being strategic?

After that slip from Ice,I retract my vote on LG and vote to lynch Ice.


I think that's probably the best reason to vote him.

I highly doubt that he meant that to put me in a trap or whatever.

omg with the series of these two, I almost PMSL... I can't believe that someone actually said they highly doubted that Ice meant to put him in a trap... gah... I know you are new, Pir... but come on, this is not your first game.

I am in a struggle as to who to vote for here. I was completely set on Salt from the beginning just because the tone he came out of the gates with, and then all the back and forth with "stop in, I'm a noob", and "hey, I've read other games to see how people are" bs... it makes me wonder if Pap did hand pick these roles and throw in the dice for an all noob scum team...

my first choice was salt, so there goes my vote... I vote to lynch Salt

 

[the wizard]

Lab, if you have something that would be helpful to the town, I don't see why you would hold back. Are you waiting in hopes to cause more confusion when/if vote switches start flying?
Are you not one that gave Salt a hard time about not making his "list" known?

LG is right here Labby, many times you have stated that holding back isn't pro town.

And you did get on salt for the very same thing you are now doing. As stated in my vote his unwillingness to help the town got him my vote.