I think I would more likely choose someone that's on the chopping block. I don't think it's wise to assume what the rest of the town would do since the invest comes down to individual choice and not the majority.
Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play
- Thread starter Lab_Rat
- Start date
I think I would more likely choose someone that's on the chopping block. I don't think it's wise to assume what the rest of the town would do since the invest comes down to individual choice and not the majority.
I am guessing LG is of the same thinking as me here but if the next invest happens and actually goes to a townie an invest of Jpap would clear two people if he shows innocent. Of course it could be that a mafia gets the invest and lies about Jpap.
Hopefully my list can shed some light for you Chill before you have to take your shot. Of the people listed there I would most likely shoot Rich, Kashta, and FF. (I would also throw a couple of bullets at sam and pir's bodies for screwing the town over). However if you add in the other people my list changes a lil bit. I would say over all Rich, Kashta, then LG. Chill if you need anything else let me know and I'll answer as best I can, gotta make this shot matter otherwise we're just about bent over a barrel.
Sorry, Chill... I'm not an early riser at the best of times. From Ice's list, I'd got Rich, Kash, FF.
That being said, Rich, Jspigs and Tay are still my top suspects.
My shot would be on Rich since I"ve been suspecting him the longest, and he's the common link in those thoughts.
That being said, Rich, Jspigs and Tay are still my top suspects.
My shot would be on Rich since I"ve been suspecting him the longest, and he's the common link in those thoughts.
JB I have a question. You have me on your suspect list with Rich being a common link. I know you'll say distancing as an obvious answer but I have had Rich as my number one suspect most of this game. Do you think that my reasoning was weak? Do you really think scum would push scum as their number one suspect? I ask out of curiosity more than defending myself as I really don't care that I'm on your list.
Hopefully this happens because that would mean Chill first shot a scumbag and then I'd know another player who he should shoot.
But at the same time a mafia could try to clear themselves by clearing me...depends on what their plans are and how close to the shot they are...
Sure... why not push a teammate as your number 1... especially since you said your posts get overlooked anyway. Or something to that effect. I don't remember what your reasoning was on Rich enough to say if it was weak or not. Care to refresh my memory?
FF you're the only one left who hasn't commented on Ice's list?
You also never answered my question about why you wouldn't go after Ice if Pap showed scum.
Times ticking and if I was on as many lists as you I'd want to get my thoughts out there. Care to add some input?
You also never answered my question about why you wouldn't go after Ice if Pap showed scum.
Times ticking and if I was on as many lists as you I'd want to get my thoughts out there. Care to add some input?
Sure JB, I'll refresh your memory.
It started with this post above and then I replied:
Which you happened to agree with me here:
Then came the consider/hesitate debate which you said nearly the same thing that I did so I know we were on the same line of thought there. Did you really need to be refreshed about that when we were thinking the same things? So if I saw the same things you did and you agreed with me on them about Rich, how does his guilt if shot and killed link me to him as a team mate?
About my posts being overlooked, it just seems that way during every game I've played. I will say the same thing as a vet, sometimes even before a vet and the vet is the one to get recognized for it. It seems like people don't notice that I am there trying to help the town as well. I'm still getting brushed off as a "just a newbie" by some people and I try not to be offended by it but it feels a little degrading at times.
It started with this post above and then I replied:
Which you happened to agree with me here:
Then came the consider/hesitate debate which you said nearly the same thing that I did so I know we were on the same line of thought there. Did you really need to be refreshed about that when we were thinking the same things? So if I saw the same things you did and you agreed with me on them about Rich, how does his guilt if shot and killed link me to him as a team mate?
About my posts being overlooked, it just seems that way during every game I've played. I will say the same thing as a vet, sometimes even before a vet and the vet is the one to get recognized for it. It seems like people don't notice that I am there trying to help the town as well. I'm still getting brushed off as a "just a newbie" by some people and I try not to be offended by it but it feels a little degrading at times.
