Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[Lady G]

It was just a theory. Calm your farm. Lol. But you getting all defensive about it makes me think it might be plausible.. And if she was 95% certain she was going to die, why would she still try get chill to change to you? The more logical approach would be to distance fellow mafia. Eg. You.

Of course it is possible, but I'm sorry if there was even a 5% chance of her getting the win....I whole heartedly believe she would of gone there. Also, once she was shot, well it would draw more attention to Rich

To refresh your memory, here is where the 5% thing came from.

 

[Lady G]

There was nothing super incriminating in JBs post, but that doesn't change your reaction. You seemed way to defensive at the time, and your insistence that you weren't is not helping.

To ensure no confusion in this, here are my answers to Chills 3 questions. Im pretty sure i answered them already, but to be safe, here:

1)Could be both, but im partial to the set up one.

2)Dag... i think Dag is helpful and innocent, but thats just me. He hasn't yet done anything i can consider scummy yet.

3)Probably, seeing as i think Rich is scum, and we know Kashta is scum.



You seem dead set on having Rich be innocent. Why so certain dag is wrong?

So why are you so certain Dag is innocent?

I think LG might be an honorary member of the team again. I think it is more likely that FF or JB is in her spot on the official scum team.

LMAO, you sure like throwing my name around dontcha.

No, but it is interesting. I don't bother focusing on the obvious stuff, i was looking for the less obvious.

Well, i thought i had. So deal with it.

Look Below for a min...



You say that you think Rich is innocent. Where have you once said out loud since Kashta died that Rich was possibly evil? Where?

FF, I don't get what you are trying to say here, the last sentance? You show Paps post of if I, Tay or Rich are mafia he gives up...you respond with that?

 

[Taysius]

Since there isn't a whole lot to talk about, let's say that Chill shoots JB and he's scum. Lab flips her coin and a player gets to investigate. Who would you suggest that person investigate? Do people still think that Pap should be investigated? Or should they investigate Rich to see if it was distancing or not? Heck, I guess there could be people that think I should be investigated.

We can only hope that the investigation falls into the hands of an innocent.

The same question should go for if JB happens to be innocent, but I highly doubt that is the case. Just throwing it out there for good measure.

 

[jpappy789]

No, but it is interesting. I don't bother focusing on the obvious stuff, i was looking for the less obvious.

Well, i thought i had. So deal with it.

Look Below for a min...



You say that you think Rich is innocent. Where have you once said out loud since Kashta died that Rich was possibly evil? Where?

FF, do you bother to read posts?

Rich is a 6 on my list. How does that indicate that I've cleared him in any way? I asked where I was dead set on him being innocent and you come up with a joke post saying that if he is scum I give up. I have Rich leaning innocent. Leaning. L-E-A-N-I-N-G.

You jumped on me because I defended myself against a post that was horse manure. It's as simple as that. You ignored what was actually said by JB and my rebuttals and went with the whole "defensiveness" angle that is a cop out to actually reading and analyzing the points we made. To me it looks like you were just looking for an excuse to go after me and back up a teammate who is not around to speak for himself. Nice try.

 

[Lady G]

Hay, FF and Dag...I'm still waiting for some one to show me HOW if Rich is mafia, she would of been setting her team up for the win. Can all of you give me your reason for thinking that and how it would work please. How exactly would her team of benefited?

 

[jpappy789]

Since there isn't a whole lot to talk about, let's say that Chill shoots JB and he's scum. Lab flips her coin and a player gets to investigate. Who would you suggest that person investigate? Do people still think that Pap should be investigated? Or should they investigate Rich to see if it was distancing or not? Heck, I guess there could be people that think I should be investigated.

We can only hope that the investigation falls into the hands of an innocent.

The same question should go for if JB happens to be innocent, but I highly doubt that is the case. Just throwing it out there for good measure.

At this point I'm most unsure about Dag, Js, and Hay. JB I am pretty sure on and FF continues to creep up my list as he posts.

I would probably investigate Js just to make sure he could be crossed off my list since I would feel comfortable with the remaining four being mafia.

I totally understand if people want to investigate me though.

 

[jpappy789]

At this point I'm most unsure about Dag, Js, and Hay. JB I am pretty sure on and FF continues to creep up my list as he posts.

I would probably investigate Js just to make sure he could be crossed off my list since I would feel comfortable with the remaining four being mafia.

I totally understand if people want to investigate me though.

I included JB and FF here...I dont want to confuse anyone.

 

[jpappy789]

Hopefully Chill shoots scum and then if anyone not largely trusted by the town comes out with a mafia investigation we have the wiggle room to shoot that person if they lie.

 

[Lady G]

Since there isn't a whole lot to talk about, let's say that Chill shoots JB and he's scum. Lab flips her coin and a player gets to investigate. Who would you suggest that person investigate? Do people still think that Pap should be investigated? Or should they investigate Rich to see if it was distancing or not? Heck, I guess there could be people that think I should be investigated.

We can only hope that the investigation falls into the hands of an innocent.

The same question should go for if JB happens to be innocent, but I highly doubt that is the case. Just throwing it out there for good measure.

Well Tay, I'm not sure what Chill shooting JB has to do with the invest really, but I will say either Rich or Pap would be a good choice. Personally, I would most likely still invest Pap because it would help clear a lingering doubt I can't help but have.

Not sure but this question seems a little odd to me?

 

[Taysius]

Well Tay, I'm not sure what Chill shooting JB has to do with the invest really, but I will say either Rich or Pap would be a good choice. Personally, I would most likely still invest Pap because it would help clear a lingering doubt I can't help but have.

Not sure but this question seems a little odd to me?

I'm just a little bored at the moment and there isn't a whole lot going on so I thought I'd ask.

If he shot JB then there wouldn't be a need to investigate him. He can shoot anyone but that's my top choice and seems to be at the top of a few lists so that's why.

Of course the question could be opened to if Chill shoots scum who would you pick to investigate and then of course anyone, including JB could be an option.