Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[Haydn24]

Did you mean to say you thought at the time they were over reacting or do you really still think they were over reacting?

I thought they over reacted at the time.

 

[Haydn24]

Ok there wasn't a question here, but why would you expect to see a scumbag drowning when scum get shot?

Because that was how the first death was...

 

[Haydn24]

And this is doing what exactly to help anyone besides the maifa???

Because Tay and rich kept implying I was scum no matter what so I tried some sarcasm.

 

[Haydn24]

I must have missed that post. In that case I would investigate jpappy so we can know if he is scum and get a better idea of whether or not Ice is in fact innocent.

I will have to look back at chill's questions.

My top suspect at the moment is JB. Other players have done a better job explaining why he seems scummy than I could. Also another reason why
I suspect him is that he not only had me as a suspect but tried to use every sentence of mine as a reason to shoot me and make it seem like I am mafia. I think that he was trying to prevent people from suspecting him by getting them to suspect me instead.

Wow, wanna jump on the train a bit more?

 

[Haydn24]

No Chill, I don't think taking the shot just because others may be bored is the thing to do. I agree the more info we get the better before the shot is taken.

JB hasn't responded to many posts yet, Hay really hasn't said much today so far, I would like to see some responses before you shot personally.

I'm still wanting to know from Hay, Dag and FF how Kashs team would benefit from her trying to take Rich down.

LG, for one. I explained this at least 3 times. Read back when I first posted the theory. Around page 90

 

[Haydn24]

Okay everyone if you were going to take 4 shots at lightning speed who would you shoot? Please list them in the order you would shoot them.

Rich
LG
JB
FF

 

[Haydn24]

It may be a while, so... don't hold your breath.

Unless he's scum. He he he

 

[Haydn24]

You would shoot Kash, but you think Rich is ALL OVER scummy? Her mistake was pretty big (especially for Kash with her spreadsheets), but if you think someone is all over scummy...shouldn't you shoot them?
You also state, you do not have 2 other names, yet Rich is who you would shoot if she came up mafia or innocent...sounds like another name to me

Just pulled this one out. LG is referring to JS saying rich is all over scum. Two things I found interesting is:
1) immediately after LG questioned him he backpedaled and almost said he didn't suspect rich anymore. Scared much?
2) The fact that LG stood up quite sternly for rich. Why would she try protect him if she doesn't know his identity.

Just a thought and something to think about chill.

 

[Chill]

I've been playing my cards pretty close to my chest because I can guage people's recations better when they don't know what to say to agree with me. I'm not sure how I will continue to play this. If I take the shot and I miss I'm not leaviing much for the next slinger, but if I put all my thoughts out there it takes away my edge if my shot is true and I'm still the slinger tomorrow. Thoughts?

 

[Taysius]

I've been playing my cards pretty close to my chest because I can guage people's recations better when they don't know what to say to agree with me. I'm not sure how I will continue to play this. If I take the shot and I miss I'm not leaviing much for the next slinger, but if I put all my thoughts out there it takes away my edge if my shot is true and I'm still the slinger tomorrow. Thoughts?

Before you take your shot I would at least throw some of your feelings on the matter out on the table. I know for one that I would appreciate any information possible if I happened to become the next slinger. I'm sure there are others that would agree. If you are extremely confident in your shot and are willing to take that chance to keep things to yourself, then go for it. I just hope you're right.