Mafia 79:Bio Badlands Game Thread.

Chill said:
Well if that's the case who do you see sitting back? Who's the hidden mastermind here?
Click to expand...


Current post counts

Razzlefish - DEAD, evil (who cares)
User_Name - 34
Jpappy - 31
Johnlarson - 29
Chill - 28
Lady G - 26 (out of play for D2)
Rich311k - 23
Sploke - 14
2Hobbies - 13
Ballyhoo - 10 (stated at game start that posting would be limited)


Soooo...that really isn't much help I guess. My gut feeling toward answering that question was Chill, Rich, 2H but the postcounts don't necessarily support that.
 
jpappy789 said:
I think it is a forgone conclusion that LG should reveal the investigations they have received, which when she comes back should be a total of 2 players. I'm hoping (and assuming) they didn't investigate Razz N1 so that would be 3 of 9 players left, including LG herself, that we can either clear or go after depending on the results.

I was wondering if it would be wise for her to take that a step further and reveal her teammate. That would be 4/9 PLUS it would take two nights for the evils to hit them both and since one would still be alive after the first night that would be another investigation. Likely 5/8 of the players known (8 because of hit but not lynch since thats up in the air). At that point we might not even need to get to that point.

Of course, the vials come into the picture as does Dr. Genes serum which is completely unknown. I remember being a BE and getting turned by the serum and winning it for the evils. We can only hope that players who are known do not get turned (or any other innocents for that matter) and that the serum does something else. The same can be said for the dreaded blue mist.

Thoughts? I'm not completely sold on the second part (revealing the other BE) because it always hurts to have targets on players backs. It's sort of a short term gain knowing a bunch of people's roles early before they have a chance to become turned, hoping that we can cross people off lists and finish off the scum before they can turn it around on us. I'm trying to weight the potential outcomes with the potential consequences.
Click to expand...

If that is the course of action (reveal investigation results, reveal identity of second bioengineer), why wait until tomorrow? G's partner should have the same information she does.

I guess it depends on the results of the investigation. If the investigation came back with a positive ID on an evil, then we lose the other bioengineer but nail an evil tonight. Although then next nightfall G would be on the chopping block, and we would not get the results of the third investigation.

If G does not reveal her partner, she can give us the results of D1 and D2 investigations, she gets killed (again) on D3 (assuming the evils cannot whack her tonight) and her partner is able to provide the results of the third investigation.
 
jpappy789 said:
......

Thoughts? I'm not completely sold on the second part (revealing the other BE) because it always hurts to have targets on players backs. It's sort of a short term gain knowing a bunch of people's roles early before they have a chance to become turned, hoping that we can cross people off lists and finish off the scum before they can turn it around on us. I'm trying to weight the potential outcomes with the potential consequences.
Click to expand...

I trimmed the quote for space reasons.
I think the other BE should remain hidden, that way there is some security if something goes wrong. Better safe than sorry I feel.

I have a full day today, class 9a-7p and driving ~ an hr to pick up the start of my RCS colony as soon as class is over.. I'll pop in when I get the time. I also found a free fire damaged 1975 VW Beetle that Dan and I are hoping to get *fingers crossed for epic drag car*
 
Well we obvioulsy need to see what she comes back with first. She should have two results if they're both scum then this is likely over.

Downside on revealing - they hit G first night and the reveal the second and then there's no more investigations.


Downside on not revealing - we accidentaly lynch the BE, that could be avoided while G is alive as she can always reveal if it looks like that's going to happen. So no bad consquence while she's still alive.

So downside after G's gone - accidental lynching of the BE, false role claim from scum, or town doesn't listen to BE as we don't know they're the BE.

By night three investigations are suspect anyway as vials may have come in to play.

I'm inclined to say no to revealing the other BE unles they're looking likely for the lynch.
 
Sploke said:
If that is the course of action (reveal investigation results, reveal identity of second bioengineer), why wait until tomorrow? G's partner should have the same information she does.

I guess it depends on the results of the investigation. If the investigation came back with a positive ID on an evil, then we lose the other bioengineer but nail an evil tonight. Although then next nightfall G would be on the chopping block, and we would not get the results of the third investigation.

If G does not reveal her partner, she can give us the results of D1 and D2 investigations, she gets killed (again) on D3 (assuming the evils cannot whack her tonight) and her partner is able to provide the results of the third investigation.
Click to expand...

Because I'm not entirely sold on the idea that the partner should be revealed in the first place and at this point they have only one result. Not to mention how do we trust the person?
 
Sploke said:
Current post counts

Razzlefish - DEAD, evil (who cares)
User_Name - 34
Jpappy - 31
Johnlarson - 29
Chill - 28
Lady G - 26 (out of play for D2)
Rich311k - 23
Sploke - 14
2Hobbies - 13
Ballyhoo - 10 (stated at game start that posting would be limited)


Soooo...that really isn't much help I guess. My gut feeling toward answering that question was Chill, Rich, 2H but the postcounts don't necessarily support that.
Click to expand...

So at this point you have UN as a suspect...who's left?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom