Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters

So Kash I'm inclined to believe you but being me I can never quite believe anything or anybody (my father used to call be a doubting Thomas).

What did you see from Labby that led you to use the vial on her?

LOL.. good question.

It wasn't really much at all. I didn't believe she was being straight with us based on some of her posts. On the surface, they appeared to be a simple and consistent responses.... no big deal. But they set off warning bells for me and I spent some time trying to reconcile the gut feeling this gave me. It really wasn't so much what she even said... just that nagging feeling you get sometimes when someone is scum and you can't quite put your finger on why.

I waited several hours (I think)... hard to remember the time sequence now. It isn't something easy to explain. I just sensed something wasn't right. Eventually... I just couldn't shake the gut feeling I had and sent in my PM to dose her about an hour before nightfall.

I didn't actually know. There certainly wasn't conclusive anything, really. I knew that. Still, I went with it.
 
Wow, you guys have been posting a virtual post-fest. I'll go through those later when I get back.
 
Hey everyone, just got home from the snow, a long day. all i can say is wow. I currently beleive kash, that was a bold move and i beleive it has helped the town greatly at this point in time. Im still thinking about it though.

Bally - please tell me, if you are innocent, why are you sacrificing yourself. Dont let this game get you down. The first time i played i did the exact same, except i was evil. lol. Mafia is about mental strength and ingenuity - not making things difficult (unless of course your scum). If you are innocent, get out here and help the town, even if it looks like your going to get lynched. If you dont, my vote will be on you. You still have time to win me over.

Im not sure what went on with razz, i will re read and post if i dont fall asleep.
 
Kash do you believe UN??
Why did you protect yourself?

UN: If I had a better read on who hangs out in the scumden, I'd be able to answer that as 100% yes or no. So I will say yes... but make it more like an 80% yes with about 20% doubt factored in.

Self-protection: It occurred to me as I read it from the mod during nightfall, the scum team reaction would be.... who would've hit Labby out of nowhere like that? (Imagined swear words omitted.. lol.)

Looking at it that way names like JB or Kashta seemed kind of obvious. So I realized... ah crap, that dose probably had my name written all over it. They're bound to suspect me as the doctor who injected her. (JB's status at the time still unknown... to me anyway.) Figured I'd just tipped them off by dosing her like that. So yes, there was no doubt I'd be on their short list then. I don't imagine it took them more than half an hour or so to pick me as their next target.

Also... I learned something else about my role that wasn't stated in the rules, specifically. (Had to PM the mod to ask this.) If I get turned before I could use the 2nd dose... the evils would also get that along with me on their side. Basically, I'd just switch from being an innocent doctor working for the town to being an evil doctor working against them. My power to protect won't go with me, of course... but as an evil and being loyal to their team if I'm turned, I'd have to inject an innocent with my 2nd dose.

As my loyalty rests with the current team I'm on at any given time... really, I'm bound by that. So knowing all this meant I need to do the best I can to prevent the evils from turning me, nullifying the protection I give, AND getting their hands on Dose #2.

Imagine a nightfall with a town lynch maybe killing an innocent >> no protection on anyone >> an evil doctor dosing an innocent >> an evil hit killing/turning another innocent >> etc... Yikes! That would be devastating to the team I'm on now.

Then User Name came along...

The evils would naturally assume the doctor would protect him, just in case he was telling the truth. That meant I would leave myself vulnerable... so my turn/death would have been a sure thing in their minds. They didn't expect me to protect myself. Probably had no reason to even wonder whether or not I would at that point.

I didn't assume the scum would know as much about what my powers could do for them as I'd figured out and verified already. But they surely know killing or turning me would negate protection against their hit and prevent me from dosing them if I didn't use the 2nd one yet... if nothing else. Since they know User's role (presumably accurate), I'm the only thing (possibly) standing in their way to take him out whenever they choose.

It just makes more sense for them to kill/turn the doctor first... which they need to do anyway.... THEN go after User and whoever else they pick, one nightfall after another.

I protected myself because I guessed they were already onto me (which they were) and figured I was a better target for them.
 
NP, or piglet which ever you prefer, you have been on the thread and hopefully learning.

Seeing how everyone posts and asks and answers questions, what is your impression of Razz and Bally.

I ask you specifically because I have not noticed you answering too many questions that were put to the town. As long as you are in the game when someone ask the town a question that does include you.

Take your time and think it over and give us a response that shows you can post more mature like you said you could.


on Bally I see them as a innocent. Bally just seem desperate and in need of encouragement right now as for Razz im not sure I will go back and read some of her earlier post.
 
on Bally I see them as a innocent. Bally just seem desperate and in need of encouragement right now as for Razz im not sure I will go back and read some of her earlier post.

Razz is a he ;) lol!

Could you also back up why you thinkbally is innocent? Many people think otherwise
 
Razz-if u go to pg5 then pg6 you notice Razz leaves and pappy shows
if u go to 64 then 65 you notice pappy shows and Razz leaves just seems to coincidental.

Bally-I never suspected him before and I saw no reason to change that. Just think he needs some help and encouraging comments.
 
going to go see if it happens anywhere else
 
AquariaCentral.com