Wow! OK...I can understand the retractions from 2H obviously but another train so quick?
I know this comment is now being questioned, but I can see why Dawg made it at the time it was posted. It did seem like a quick shunt of votes to Bally, but turns out they were well deserved votes.
Makes sense to me, Noods. Your team got caught off guard by 2H's surprise role claim and deciding to nail Wizard. With no time to deliberate and knowing she'd flip scum, her voting you is supposed to clear you.
Bad luck for your team... a wonderful development for the town, IMO.
I'm finding myself in agreement with Kash here. Noods' play has struck me as scummy from the start, but like Bally, it's primarily a gut feeling. Her original reaction to Kash seemed like a scummy Noods reaction, not an innocent Noods reaction. Nothing concrete, just a feeling, but I'm leaning Noods as scum.
LG and Noods. Before I went back and read, it was just gut feeling, but looking at how LG did not move to prevent a possible coin flip situation with 2H possibly getting the lynch, I'm happy to call her scum now. At this point, I think that is where my vote will land. Now I don't see a connection with her and Wiz or Bally, so I'm thinking she's likely CIA scum.
Zaffy is giving me a scummy vibe as well. Not enough that I'm going to vote for him yet. He garnered my original vote because of that scummy feeling, dropping his vote and running, and the fact that no one was voting Bally (my greatest scum feeling) and numbers wise there was a better chance to lynch Zaffy and get 2H out of the noose. That is also why I said if anyone felt how I felt about Bally, I would gladly change to her.
I'm not talking about the people on 2H. Apparently they weren't around. What I'm wondering is why all the other supposed innocents who were on before nightfall were OK with 2H being tied for the lynch vote. I wasn't OK with it even being close so I moved my vote to Bally. There were other ways to save 2H then to wait and see if people moved their votes off. I took that opportunity and ended up lynching another scum. I understand it doesn't totally clear me because of the CIA team but I would say the move to save 2H does help me. If I was CIA I would have let 2H hang or at least the possibility of hanging in a 3 way tie.
This post makes sense to me. If Dawg hadn't moved, not only would it not have been close, it would have been a coin flip. How anyone can claim to be pro-town while letting a known PR risk a coin flip by not moving their vote escapes me. Totally makes sense for scum not to move and hope that the coin flip did not go the town's way.
That would be an excelent excuse for an evil. "I moved to safe the important guy" just sounds like something an evil would do, predicting that someone else would try it, but wanting to be first. Once you had done it, no one else could for the same reason.
Yes, it could be an excellent excuse for an evil. But if you look at how the votes fell, and that Bally could have moved to save herself and get 2H lynched if she'd realized it makes me lean Dawg towards the innocent side.
I've been trying. just having trouble getting a grasp on what's going on. last night i got caught up in other things.
one thing that caught my eye is rich. I'm on my phone so i cant multi quote, but his comments about bally rub me as a little fluffy and slightly contradrictory. he deferred to LR stating that she started the case against bally. but he was the first to actually vote her. i know lr talked about bally, but i dont like how he made it seem like her followed her lead.
Posted on mobile.aquariacentral.com
Or do you not like it that Rich agreed with me that Bally seemed scummy? I explained my reasons for not voting for her initially, didn't want to waste a vote on a gut feeling if no one else felt how I felt. Not to mention, I did not want to waste a vote when a known townie PR was up for the lynch.
You know Dawg, yes it was a wonderful thing you did...and I am glad you did it, but the way you keep bringing it up, really makes one stop and wonder, it's like you are trying to keep it out there to prove you are innocent and don't want anyone to forget it.
I can think of a very good reason for a evil to do it....so they can do exactly what you are doing now, throwing it out there over and over to try and "clear" yourself because you did it.
That's the ONLY reason I can think an evil would do it. But that reason does not override the idea that if Dawg had not moved (like you did not move) then 2H's fate would have been left up to the coin, or he would have been lynched had Bally saved herself. Any evil would have wanted 2H gone.
You quoted Zaffy's post and directed the post to Pappy? Can you explain?
Trying to catch up after being away most of the day and am not too happy with all of the fluffy BS that is STILL going on!! :swear:
Besides Piglet and Tigger's crap, I'm not seeing much fluffy. Is the real reason for that angry smiley because the scum lost 2 last night?
I will say yes, Dawg gives me a bad vibe. I know he moved his vote to Bally and "saved" 2H...but he was the last to move and sealed the deal, that could easily been to clear himself, it was obvious Bally was going, if he hadn't moved I'm sure someone would of once the vote count was posted and everyone realized there was still a tie. Not sure if he is FBI, but it would be a good move to make it look as though he isn't if he is.
Sorry, from the way things went down, I doubt anyone else would have moved. Dawg made his move very close to nightfall to make sure 2H had a fighting chance if Bally moved.
My vote didn't seal any deal except for the fact that Bally didn't realize she could potentially save herself. I can understand her teammates not trying to save her and outing themselves but she really had nothing to lose. Again it was only 1 vote...not a landslide.
Again, I agree with this. It makes sense.
Lets see, several ppl voted in a row to Bally.....you, yourself said there was a train building on her. It looked to me she was going for sure, and I'd bet anything her and Wizard were sure she was going also. Granted there ended up only being a 1 vote difference between them, but most games what happened would be considered a train.
It was a quick shift in votes, not a landslide train. People moved to save a known townie PR. There was not much time. You act like it was a bad thing that people voted for Bally, makes me wonder why...
