Mafia 81: The Bloody Coup

[jpappy789]

Once again seemed blatantly obvious

Man Pap when your game is off, it's WAY OFF.

Nothing new there...I've gone through plenty of games when innocent and not been on the right track at all...bound to happen when you play plenty of games.

See my latest post though. I do see that as the best option we have at this point.

We certainly can wait but just keep in mind that more likely than not you are gone tonight and then all it takes is some luck on the side of the scum to end the game. We need to get the info out there asap otherwise by the time we do it may be useless.

 

[IceH2O]

Was ab;e to come home for lunch....

My thoughts on the seance.
It can be used anytime after night 4. It doesn't have to be used tonight if the town can agree on the next target.
Lab only had one invest, likely hood is that that info is now old and useless.
If the town can not agree on a target, you need to find something out about the remaining CIA.
Remember you are asking this question of Kash, Lab, and Zaffy. Any info you receive from them will be excellent.

The seance happens after tonights night fall per random draw.

Are there any parameters on this question? Can we just ask them who they think the CIA team is? or to name their top 4 suspects? If Labby had investigated any scum they would certainly be on the list.

No parameters at all, you could ask for a suspect list, an order of suspects, just 1 suspect etc...

 

[dirtydawg10]

My thoughts on the seance.
It can be used anytime after night 4. It doesn't have to be used tonight if the town can agree on the next target.
Lab only had one invest, likely hood is that that info is now old and useless.
If the town can not agree on a target, you need to find something out about the remaining CIA.
Remember you are asking this question of Kash, Lab, and Zaffy. Any info you receive from them will be excellent.

Good point 2H.

Are there any parameters on this question? Can we just ask them who they think the CIA team is? or to name their top 4 suspects? If Labby had investigated any scum they would certainly be on the list.

I was thinking of a similar type of question about top 3 or 4 suspects.

I do respect the players in the ghost chat but at the same time I don't want the list to be taken as total truth based on the chance that Lab actually investigated one of the people on it.

I would almost rather either get complete proof in asking Lab and risk getting nothing in return instead of asking for opinions based on the same proof we have in front of us. The only conclusive result is the one Ice gave to Lab.

What about just asking Lab to reveal her result no matter what? Their isn't any risk in putting a target on any innocents back. The only PR left is known and the CIA can shoot whomever they want freely. The only issue would be if she chose someone now dead.

I am not a fan of asking who the dead think are scum unless it was confirmed by Ice through Lab's investigation. At this point it basically just serves as a list from another player. Just because we can trust them doesn't mean they are going to be correct.

Just my $0.02

It is strange how when you are lynched or hit and taken out of a mafia game how much easier it is to figure out who's who when you don't have to post. Sometimes it becomes blatantly obvious actually. I think a list of suspects could be helpful. I need to think about this a bit more.

 

[TwoHobbies]

The seance happens after tonights night fall per random draw.





No parameters at all, you could ask for a suspect list, an order of suspects, just 1 suspect etc...

Ok, thanks Ice

Tonight after nightfall.
I'd say we keep it simple, "A suspect list."
Let them decide how many they feel comfortable giving us.

 

[Piranha86]

While I agree we need to find the CIA is there some reason you don't want us to look at the FBI's posts.

I'm saying we shouldn't focus on who the FBI was being nice too, they're gone and they probabbly don't know who the other ppl are. But yeah, go ahead and look.

I vote we ask the dead chat about a list.

FF, you're posting so much BS, and there really isn't many other people I s uspect, so I vote to lynch FF.

I don't have a read on anyone, and I probably can't be on tonight, so I don't want to UD>

 

[Fishfriend1]

I'm saying we shouldn't focus on who the FBI was being nice too, they're gone and they probabbly don't know who the other ppl are. But yeah, go ahead and look.

I vote we ask the dead chat about a list.

FF, you're posting so much BS, and there really isn't many other people I s uspect, so I vote to lynch FF.

I don't have a read on anyone, and I probably can't be on tonight, so I don't want to UD>

wow... so much BS you say? Well, it only looks like a lot because no one else was posting. And how have you helped us today? Still no list? Its day 4, most people have a list by now.

 

[TwoHobbies]

I Vote to Lynch Jpappy

I would also like to request the remaining towns people to join me. We need to come together as a group and vote. If we don't the CIA will control the lynch. The numbers are 5, 4. We do not have a vote to spare.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I Vote to Lynch Jpappy

I would also like to request the remaining towns people to join me. We need to come together as a group and vote. If we don't the CIA will control the lynch. The numbers are 5, 4. We do not have a vote to spare.

Well, im not really seeing you argument against him, and we have basically 1 shot at this. We lose, they will outnumber us, and then they could dance in the middle of the thread and we couldn't do dip**** to stop them. So, unless you have a reason i can see for voting him, my vote will stay on DD.

to be completely honest, i don't even remember you entire argument. Just looked over the last 2 pages to see if i could find it, your argument seems to be that pappy is off his game. Is that it? Im not entirely willing to vote anyone on that small of a reason, even if it's what the BG and pres want. Sorry, but AFAIK your just 2 townies that can talk now.

 

[jpappy789]

I'm saying we shouldn't focus on who the FBI was being nice too, they're gone and they probabbly don't know who the other ppl are. But yeah, go ahead and look.

I vote we ask the dead chat about a list.

FF, you're posting so much BS, and there really isn't many other people I s uspect, so I vote to lynch FF.

I don't have a read on anyone, and I probably can't be on tonight, so I don't want to UD>

Wow. You STILL ignore me when I even pulled all the posts for you...

I Vote to Lynch Jpappy

I would also like to request the remaining towns people to join me. We need to come together as a group and vote. If we don't the CIA will control the lynch. The numbers are 5, 4. We do not have a vote to spare.

2H you've been wrong on me since the beginning and taken my posts and not exactly read through them the right way. I don't know how else to spell it out to you this time.

 

[jpappy789]

Good point 2H.


I was thinking of a similar type of question about top 3 or 4 suspects.


It is strange how when you are lynched or hit and taken out of a mafia game how much easier it is to figure out who's who when you don't have to post. Sometimes it becomes blatantly obvious actually. I think a list of suspects could be helpful. I need to think about this a bit more.

Ok, thanks Ice

Tonight after nightfall.
I'd say we keep it simple, "A suspect list."
Let them decide how many they feel comfortable giving us.

It's a majority "vote" anyways so I guess my $.02 wont end up meaning much. A suspect list from dead players doesn't get us any further IMO and could end up hurting the town in the long run when the worst that could happen with directly asking Lab for her result would be that it is worthless. I still think you guys are putting too much stock into trusting players who have just as much chance of seeing something wrong or right as the opposite as the rest of us. Dead eyes or not, you cannot say that a dead player has a better chance of picking off the evils.

I've seen dead players nail scum (ie. Hay a couple games back) but at the same time seen the dead chat be not so on top of who is scum. That same game it took quite a few tries for even the experienced players in chat to start getting even close to the team before Hay nailed it.

All I'm saying is that it has the potential for turning into a game of "So and so was on the list so that's where I'm voting".

But who am I to say anything...I'm the one with an off game...