Mafia 87: The Play, Basic Game

[Piranha86]

2-7-11 8:48
Pir asks for a replacement player.
Timing on this request was strange because Tank still had 10 minutes to jump in and bold his vote. Sure seems to me like Pir knew that wasn't going to happen.
Did Tank mention in the den that he wouldn't be around for nightfall, because I don't remember him saying that in the thread?

Name 2 relatively new players that haven't voted and show up within 10 minutes of nightfall. Because i have seen none.

I think I made a 92% on my test, not that great of an A but I'll take it!! :dance:

Good job on genetics. Does this mean you'll be able to tell what color/variety everyone's baby fish will be? :grinyes:

You don't think it could be a setup?

What !??!!..She retracted on Rich also. Come on, I even listed the post number.

Bit defensive of Rich, maybe?

Well Rich, if you were setup Zaffy's going to look guilty to me, but I don't think you were.

I VOTE TO LYNCH RICH

Sees that his team-mate is about to get lynched, decides to seal the deal so he looks un-scummy. I believe I recall someone riding my back about voting late... hmm...

well I honestly think rich is being set up and that some of the people on him are most likely scum. That was a very easy set up and a smart move by the scum team. Now i realixe if im wrong then you will all be pointing fingers at me saying that i have to be scum because im not voting rich but i honestly think he was set up. and now as LG mentioned earlier when she retracted, the scum took out a innocent and then they could get another one with rich. I still think bally is the most scummy for reason stated earlier in the thread.
i vote to lynch bally.

After 5 votes are on Rich, he posts this. He puts the little insurance policy (bolded) in there. I am kind of indecisive on whether this was defense of him or just going with is opinion. Rich isn't an idiot, his hit-scheme did have everyone scratching there heads, so I'm going to let this slide.

Not, I do agree with the rest of the statement. Rich knew he was going saying that about Zaff before going could of easily been to "cover" h really sure what you mean but "this gives Zaff a bit more of a target". Althoughim. Not sure I'm willing to think that is what happened at the moment, but YES it is possible.

I do agree with Bally looking evil, and if I HAD to vote right now that is most likely where my vote would go.
I have to wonder about Willard though, if he was on the team with Rich and with no UD's possible now...he could of been told to lay low and not post trying to hide.

Which brings me to a question for FF....how do we deal with no posting/no voting now???

Red: Not saying that he's scum for it, but this kind of thing would tend to make Zaffy look innocent. I'm just emphasizing that he should not be overlooked. We need to be hypervigilant.
Green: (To FF) I suggest what is done in Gunslinger-type games. If they don't post every 24 hours, they UD. Just my suggestion.

...

I'm thinking there is one more scum left. (.25 of 12 is 3, 2 are removed, leaving 1). Though NPR's defense-ish post about Rich raised an eyebrow, I do not think he did it to defend a dead team-mate. I do really see 2H as the final scum, the don. Especially for being so contradictory. I voted late on UN, who already had quite a few votes on him, and he did the exact same thing on Rich (!) I interpret this all as very scummy, so...

I vote to lynch 2H.

 

[Zaffy]

I'll continue on with my (now) second choice.
For everything already posted and this.



2-7-11 8:22
FF tells everyone he will not count Tanks vote unless he bolds it.



2-7-11 8:23
User asks FF if he will count the vote anyway.
FF again says no.



2-7-11 8:48
Pir asks for a replacement player.
Timing on this request was strange because Tank still had 10 minutes to jump in and bold his vote. Sure seems to me like Pir knew that wasn't going to happen.
Did Tank mention in the den that he wouldn't be around for nightfall, because I don't remember him saying that in the thread?

This is definitely something interesting to look at. Although, I would suspect that the scum team would have this conversation with the scum team in the scum den rather than out in the open. Unless FF doesn't have access to the den.

Will have to check back and see if there's anything else that links pir to rich.

 

[Zaffy]

well I honestly think rich is being set up and that some of the people on him are most likely scum. That was a very easy set up and a smart move by the scum team. Now i realixe if im wrong then you will all be pointing fingers at me saying that i have to be scum because im not voting rich but i honestly think he was set up. and now as LG mentioned earlier when she retracted, the scum took out a innocent and then they could get another one with rich. I still think bally is the most scummy for reason stated earlier in the thread.
i vote to lynch bally.

NPR in Pink! I know this was pointed out already, but it really does strike me at odd as well. It's in past tense, but rich was still alive at this point. I think the 5th vote was on so he was dead scum walking, but does this indicate that NPR had already abandoned rich?

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Really...I've been copying alot, wasn't aware of that can you show me where all this has happened?

okay i know there is more than this im just to lazy to find the rest.

Yeah Rich...what Zaff said

yeah asking the same question as someone else. sound familiar.

Well, looking through one more time and with what I have to go on at this point....UN, I know many games you do this whole "scum den" thing, and most the time you get lynched for it, most the time you are innocent. The thing is, it's something very hard to let go...maybe you felt if you didn't say it ppl would jump on you IDK, but at this point it is the scummiest thing I have. Yes, others have said things that kinda make me wonder...but this whole scum den thing (even though you do it all the time) is the one thing that stands out the most. I can't not react to it, and just let it slide because you could very well be scum it is something that just causes to much confusion in the game and if a innocent...that is not something you should be doing. Yep, it get's ppl talking, but it makes it hard to focus on others when you do this.

I vote to lynch UN

way to jump on the UN train for one reason that everyone else is using.

Ok, even though I am glad you kept your vote there...if this is what you thought was happening...why did you leave your vote on him?


Then you post this...now you had JUST said you thought Rich was being set up, you may not of used the words...but it surely was implied. So how can you turn around and say you don't know WHO is being set up?

again you copied a question. also you agreed with almost everything i said when i was arguing with 2H , bally, and UN. so yeah.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

NPR in Pink! I know this was pointed out already, but it really does strike me at odd as well. It's in past tense, but rich was still alive at this point. I think the 5th vote was on so he was dead scum walking, but does this indicate that NPR had already abandoned rich?

i use the past tense saying he "was set up. and he was set up before i said this in other word in the past, so when talking about past events you use past tense.

 

[Zaffy]

i use the past tense saying he "was set up. and he was set up before i said this in other word in the past, so when talking about past events you use past tense.

As it's happening shouldn't you say, "I think he is being set up."

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

As it's happening shouldn't you say, "I think he is being set up."

what was happening was us arguing about weather it was a set up or not. he was set up when the hit happened then it was pure discussion. so the set up was in the past and the argument was in the now.

 

[Lady G]

Name 2 relatively new players that haven't voted and show up within 10 minutes of nightfall. Because i have seen none.

Good job on genetics. Does this mean you'll be able to tell what color/variety everyone's baby fish will be? :grinyes:

Bit defensive of Rich, maybe?

Sees that his team-mate is about to get lynched, decides to seal the deal so he looks un-scummy. I believe I recall someone riding my back about voting late... hmm...

After 5 votes are on Rich, he posts this. He puts the little insurance policy (bolded) in there. I am kind of indecisive on whether this was defense of him or just going with is opinion. Rich isn't an idiot, his hit-scheme did have everyone scratching there heads, so I'm going to let this slide.

Red: Not saying that he's scum for it, but this kind of thing would tend to make Zaffy look innocent. I'm just emphasizing that he should not be overlooked. We need to be hypervigilant.
Green: (To FF) I suggest what is done in Gunslinger-type games. If they don't post every 24 hours, they UD. Just my suggestion.

...

I'm thinking there is one more scum left. (.25 of 12 is 3, 2 are removed, leaving 1). Though NPR's defense-ish post about Rich raised an eyebrow, I do not think he did it to defend a dead team-mate. I do really see 2H as the final scum, the don. Especially for being so contradictory. I voted late on UN, who already had quite a few votes on him, and he did the exact same thing on Rich (!) I interpret this all as very scummy, so...

I vote to lynch 2H.

First off, Tank did vote...he just forgot to bold it, kinda different then not voting. If Tank knew what time nightfall was, he easily could of shown before nightfall, saw the posts and fixed it. Why would you think just because he is a "newer" player he wouldn't show up for nightfall? The way you asked if there could be a replacement for him, it really was like you knew he wasn't going to be around.

Not sure that was really "defensive" of Rich...he was pretty much telling Bally I had retracted my vote on Rich also, in the post with the vote counts it only showed my retraction of you..it had me still on Rich. Even though he had put the post number in the first post and had she actually looked at the post she would of seen that.

 

[Lady G]

okay i know there is more than this im just to lazy to find the rest.



yeah asking the same question as someone else. sound familiar.



way to jump on the UN train for one reason that everyone else is using.



again you copied a question. also you agreed with almost everything i said when i was arguing with 2H , bally, and UN. so yeah.

Yep, joking at the beginning of the game

I was the first vote I believe on Un...not exactly JUMPING on there.

I didn't copy your question dear, there is a big difference in what you are trying to act like happened and what did happen .

 

[Lady G]

I really wish we knew if Willard is still playing or if he decided to quit