Mafia 87: The Play, Basic Game

[Zaffy]

g/o Off topic, but I wanted to share.

I had a terrible genetics class. On our 2nd of 4 exams the prof decided he wanted to "try something new." The average among all of his classes on the exam ended up being somewhere around 25% (it was multiple choice, 5 answers, so a drunk monkey would be expected to score 20%). It was an awful experience, I remember when I turned in my test and I was walking out the door there was a girl just sitting at her desk crying. Luckily he curved the scores, I had the 2nd highest grade at something like 45%. It was terrible.

So, really, great work on the A!! I mean it

g/o

 

[Willard2.0]

Who voted a known innocent off? I did not climb on the UN train. I imagine most of the scum did though.

Come on now Rich, you don't have everyones respect here as a great Mafia player by jumping on things like that. It's for things like the hit on Hayden!

2H, You act like you know for a fact that Rich planned the hit on Hay. Why is this?

Well Rich, if you were setup Zaffy's going to look guilty to me, but I don't think you were.

I VOTE TO LYNCH RICH

2H put the final nail in Rich's coffin so to speak. It seems like the perfect place to hide, Rich knows he is getting lynched, so he gets 2H to place the kill vote, and just like that, 2H is on everyone's good side.

4 minutes after LG gets hit by the vigilante, you post:

Good job town, I'm thrilled to see that went our way.

Then as people started picking up on that, you realized that you had to post something to cover for it. You posted this before you even tried to explain yourself for the post.

Ahhh crap, and just when I was feeling good about today.

We'll still bring this one home for you G.

Personally if I was scum and screwed up like that, I would be defending my post immediately, not waiting at all.

okay if you did think this then tell me "what went the towns way that you were glad about"?

I don't think you ever answered that, unless I missed it, in which case, could you please point it out.

Until you point out where you answered NPR's question, I vote to lynch TwoHobbies

 

[Fishfriend1]

Vote Count:

2H- 2 - Willard, Pir
Bally- 1 - Ninja

6 people left, 4 needed for lynch. PMs as required. Nightfall will occur when all PMs are in and votes needed have been met.

 

[TwoHobbies]

Hey Willard, it's great to see you playing, we were a little concerned when you hadn't posted. I'm going to answer Pir, and Ninja questiond first. Then I will answer yours.

 

[TwoHobbies]

Pir:
This is my first post yesterday morning. This was around 10 am.

So, it looks like I logged off a little early last night, and missed the hit.

Based on the rules and the order of nightfall, I thought the hit came after the lynch. Ah well.... it is a FF game. Expect the unusual.

So at 10:30 FF tells everyone the evils can hit whenever they want and it will go though as soon as he see's it. At 10:40 Rich votes Haydn, and twenty minutes later the scum hit Haydn.

That changes my top three.

Rich: Either someone wanted to set you up, or you wanted to say "why would I hit my vote" I'll place the lynch vote if you get one more.

At this time Rich had three votes on him. I said right away I would cast the 5th and LYNCHING vote as soon as someone placed a forth vote on him. While I was posting that G posted her retract on Rich.

I'm sorry but right now I'm NOT real comfortable with my vote after this happened, the more I think about it I really am not sure right now.

I RETRACT MY VOTE OF RICH

There's just to many things going through my mind right now and I'm almost willing to say I think Rich and Zaff are both innocent, I know what I am so.... This would of been way to easy for the evils to make one of us look bad. I KNOW if I were evil I would of loved this and did the same thing.
Then again, if I were evil and I was in the situation Rich is in....I would of done just what happened and put my vote in then the hit.

I JUST DON"T KNOW RIGHT NOW!

After I read that post I posted this one.

That's the innocent G I know and love. :nilly:

Now I not going to get into how/why, but at this point I was convinced G was innocent!

This Pir makes what you call a late vote on Rich by me, not late. As a matter of fact I think it makes your vote the last.

 

[TwoHobbies]

okay if you did think this then tell me "what went the towns way that you were glad about"?

Ninja: Are you serious? Rich being scum of course.
Please look back at my post to Pir. G gave me enough to believe she was innocent.

 

[TwoHobbies]

2H, You act like you know for a fact that Rich planned the hit on Hay. Why is this?




2H put the final nail in Rich's coffin so to speak. It seems like the perfect place to hide, Rich knows he is getting lynched, so he gets 2H to place the kill vote, and just like that, 2H is on everyone's good side.

4 minutes after LG gets hit by the vigilante, you post:


Then as people started picking up on that, you realized that you had to post something to cover for it. You posted this before you even tried to explain yourself for the post.


Personally if I was scum and screwed up like that, I would be defending my post immediately, not waiting at all.

I don't think you ever answered that, unless I missed it, in which case, could you please point it out.

Until you point out where you answered NPR's question, I vote to lynch TwoHobbies

This was my post after casting the 5th vote on Rich, but before nightfall. I think you can clearly see I wasn't sure that Rich would turn up scum, but I was as comfterable as I get.

Well I'm going to go hit "happy hour"

Guess I'll just cross my fingers and hope that Zaffy isn't playing us, while we wait for FF to call night fall.

Hopefully you can see that this is just not true if you read my answer to Pir a couple of posts ago.

I also hope I answered this one for you with my post to NPR.

 

[TwoHobbies]

Now I'll give my take on last night. I know I have been after Pir all game, but know I need to switch gears. I'm not saying Pir isn't scum but the clues seem to point differently this morning.
First off Rich's post which I didn't like from day one. At the time NPR was getting some questions from many.

I do not see much to go on here. Not unusual for a day one.

NPR - you are playing extremely well. I think UN is just doing his day one get into the mix thing, never have figured out why he does this.

Right now Hay has be concerned, he has said little and what he has says not conform tom his usual play.

Then yesterday before nightfall this post. He just couldn't bring himself to cast a vote on Rich.

well I honestly think rich is being set up and that some of the people on him are most likely scum. That was a very easy set up and a smart move by the scum team. Now i realixe if im wrong then you will all be pointing fingers at me saying that i have to be scum because im not voting rich but i honestly think he was set up. and now as LG mentioned earlier when she retracted, the scum took out a innocent and then they could get another one with rich. I still think bally is the most scummy for reason stated earlier in the thread.

Then right after the vigilante hit G we get this post. Maybe I'm reading something into it that isn't there but he almost seems pleased.

sorry to see you leave LG. to the vigilante. it's okay we all make mistakes.

Note to the vigilante: You were not in risk of being lynched and the town had numbers. What were you thinking?

woops take LG out of that list

And once again, he seems almost giddy.

If there are two scum left I still think it's likely NPR & PIR, but if we are down to one I believe we are looking for Ninja.

Now Ninja, I know I've been saying you haven't been playing a good game, but I'm here this morning saying I was wrong. I really believe you were playing a poor innocent game, but that's because your not innocent. You have actually played a very good scum game.

 

[TwoHobbies]

Whoops....forgot to vote.

I VOTE TO LYNCH NPR

 

[Fishfriend1]

Vote Count:

2H- 2 - Willard, Pir
Bally- 1 - Ninja
Ninja- 1 - 2H

6 people left, 4 needed for lynch. PMs as required. Nightfall will occur when all PMs are in and votes needed have been met.