Mafia #89 Trouble in Kindergarten

[Dangerdoll]

ah nevermind, I just read the 1st thread. If it were 4, we'd be gone.... got it, sorry

 

[IceH2O]

To be honest, I didn't know what the vote count was. I wasn't sure where to place my vote. The issue I had with Noods vote was that she pulled it from pir to not waste it then placed it where it would not affect the lynch one way or the other. I asked her opinion why it was different as she was the one to say she didn't want to waste her vote.

Then I had to ask repeatedly what made the difference in her mind to get an answer.

To be honest, I didn't know what the vote count was. I wasn't sure where to place my vote. The issue I had with Noods vote was that she pulled it from pir to not waste it then placed it where it would not affect the lynch one way or the other. I asked her opinion why it was different as she was the one to say she didn't want to waste her vote.

Then I had to ask repeatedly what made the difference in her mind to get an answer.

I think this is accurate vote count let me know if not.

ICE- Rich 181
NOODS- Ice 188, Kashta 234
RICH- JB 203
Noods- 217
NO ONE- FF 204

fixed


So Wiz and DD are the only non voters

you posted one at 630 I fixed it at 730 and it was right above DDs posts.


Ok so I hate this game because I couldn't sleep last night thinking about it.

I vote to lynch Wiz


The explanation above with vote count was the icing on the cake and helped verify my thoughts after the wasted vote, to much agreeing with me and this is what really got me after thinking.Maybe Wiz would like to explain.....(Though he will say he didn't know what the count was) Why didn't you vote Noods when her wasted vote was so glaring to you? Especially when it was a tie at the time you placed it?

My 2nd suspect is Kash I don't have time right now to go thru the posts and pull

3rd suspect I can't narrow down. I think FF but obviously I have no proof and don't know if they would throw a no vote out, I'd think at least a made up case and vote but maybe not if in a hurry and just a post and run.

After the way Kash went after Rich even after the explanation has me leaning him innocent. DD I feel is innocent and JB is the one I'm most unsure of.

so in order I'd say
Wiz
Kash
FF/JB
Rich
DD
Ice

 

[jbradt]

I asked for her explanation to see if she'd pull the posts I thought she would and she did. At the time of the posts I wasn't sure of Wiz but after his single vote after he attacked Noods for the same a day earlier I'm less sure. I also get real uneasy when it appears someone agrees with me so early in a game and has my back.
You guys then adding in the comments above make it more uneasy. If you were truly looking for scum why didn't you take notice, you guys are accomplished players that I wouldn't expect not to also question this.

I have to hit the bed,way later then I usually go to bed but I look forward to answers for my next vote.

I'm not sure what you're looking for in terms of a response here Ice. You seem to be saying that I'm suspect because I didn't call you out for something I didn't think was happening. There's a good reason I didn't call you out... I didn't think it was happening. I haven't had a lot to go on this game, so I've been spending a lot of time watching people's interactions and seeing how things play out. Sorry if that's not accomplished enough for you.

I don't have a lot of time atm, but I'll be around later to do some digging and see what I can see.

 

[IceH2O]

I'm not sure what you're looking for in terms of a response here Ice. You seem to be saying that I'm suspect because I didn't call you out for something I didn't think was happening. There's a good reason I didn't call you out... I didn't think it was happening. I haven't had a lot to go on this game, so I've been spending a lot of time watching people's interactions and seeing how things play out. Sorry if that's not accomplished enough for you.

I don't have a lot of time atm, but I'll be around later to do some digging and see what I can see.

I was in a rush this morning. I meant to post to disregard that post you quoted. After laying in bed and thinking about it I decided it didn't make as much sense as I thought and didn't fit in with what I now see.

 

[IceH2O]

I'll pull the Kash posts later, just got home to try and catch up but see a lot of the kids decided to sleep in today. Wish my mommy would let me do that.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Ok, so I had this big ****in post, but my god **** comp decided to dump the whole **** thing... I'll try to rebuild the post, but I can garentee it's gonna be a piece of **** now... And NO, I am NOT having a good week.

 

[Zaffy]

"FishFriend, come to my desk."

Mr. Zaffy reaches into his desk an pulls out some laundry detergent and a funnel. Fishfriend walks to the front of the room where Mr. Zaffy is filling out Hockey playoff brackets under assumed names. Mr. Zaffy takes Fishfriend by the hair and forces his head back, then he jams the funnel into Fishfriends mouth and begins to pour the detergent down.

"Maybe that will clean up your mouth. I won't tolerate potty mouths in my classroom, now get back to your desk and sew more logos, I have to get this shipment downtown before the weekend."


Sorry you're having a bad week.

 

[Fishfriend1]

First off, I am not having a good ****in week, so don't expect any miracles or niceties. Second off, I had a big post I had been working on from 7:40 am to 3:30pm, but it was lost to the ****** mac, so what your about to read is everything I was able to remember from that post. No promises. Third off, I'm sorry for not being here. JRP and other schoolwork, plus no wireless and a work-buisy mom = little time for mafia. Tack on a bad week and you have a deadly mixture. I'll try to stay in the game, but I can't say I'll be able to. So deal with it, Ice the almighty, cause "Slushie" ain't in the mood for stupid *** comments like this next one:

If you know you aren't going to be able to participate as much as you'd like then you'd think you'd use the little time more wisely to help root out the bad.

I'm actually tired of excuses, from everyone, just post when you can and make them count. I really don't need a life story. I'm not letting excuses bother me into not voting you as the excuse now becomes a perfect place to hide and place a vote more strategically.

I wish there were more to go on as most of the reasoning was weak even for day 1.

Noods, what makes you think a bully would be on UN? A tie equals no lynch there were plenty of single votes and if anyone had a good reason to be voted off it was the guy sitting on the UD even after being called on it?

Thought 1: Jerk. Thought 2: Get over it. Thought 3: Better make thoughts one and two less aggressive, or I'll get yelled at.

Not hardly, but you were the only one bally poked at. Seems kind of odd that she "almost" got your "knee jerk" vote but then she was hit.

Does seem odd. Someone to watch, I guess... seems odd you would say that so... vaguely, though.

Noods, about your so-called feeling. What was that exactly? Why do you direct our attention to those who voted UN?

You think it's that unlikely that a few innocents might vote off a fellow innocent by mistake on the first day? Personally, I don't find that unusual in these games.

Do you think Username said something that made the scum think he was a good guess as a possible PR?

Wouldn't it actually be easier for the scum to sit back, do nothing, not stir things up, and spread out their own votes to not call attention to themselves instead of "at least one" of them making a move against UN in particular? The town as a whole turned out to be short-sided by spreading our votes around the way we did.

Why, Rich? This post is a lot like what Noods said that I've just questioned. You really think this would help the town nail one of the scum?

Rich made this post.

JB quoted Rich and posted this.

JB, why did you prune off the last sentence from Rich's post when you quoted it? It's not a long post.

Wasn't your vote a singleton vote too at the time you placed it, Wizard? (Yes.)

Didn't you make it sound somewhat random at that time so you wouldn't UD if you couldn't get back before nightfall? (Yes again.)

So just because 2 others voted with you to lynch an innocent after you posted that vote AND you didn't post again before night.... how are you in any position to question others about singleton votes? For all you knew until after night was over, your vote may have still been a single one too. Everyone here except DD and Ice fall into the same category of placing a single vote so pursing that line of thought doesn't narrow anything down for us...... does it?

Kashta attacks Wiz, JB, Rich, and Noods, all in one block of posts. Doesn't vote any of them, doesn't decide who she thinks is evilest, just muddies the water with opinions and questions. Could be digging, could be more sinister.

This actually makes a lot of sense. The thing that takes me back about it is that you were one of those people, Ice. Could also be a really sly way of saying "see, I can't be evil."

Not sure what to think at the moment.

I sort of see this. And Ice would be good enough to pull it off, too. I think I'll keep watch on you, Ice.

Uhoh... someone got grounded again.

This is almost enough to make me change my vote.

Screw you. I wasn't going to play that day, so I voted no one. Next time, I'll just quit.

Noods you've been on and off, I guess, and so far you addressed other posts. Still want your answer to this question if you don't mind.

Tentative: I vote to lynch Noods.

Will see what she has to say once she finishes getting caught up before deciding whether to leave this vote on her or go elsewhere.

Why tentative? You made a case against her, did you know she was innocent before you voted her? I see no other reason for a "tentative" vote on Noods there.

ok, I think I will keep my vote where it is. I had some thoughts on moving it to Ice or Noods but my gut is still saying Wiz.... btw, wiz, would you care to show how many times I've used gut too?

I feel like Ice is being protective over Wiz without trying to be obvious and it seems like he is trying to push the heat off of him,

With Noods, I feel like your whole game is unfocused, might be because of home stuff, maybe just a ruse... I dunno but it's something to watch, just not something to vote on because I am unsure about it.

Here's my Wiz quotes with thoughts:

Do you honestly think that I would put myself out like that with posting she "almost" got my vote... and then taking her out from behind the scenes?...

so using the word "sketch" means someone is "nervous"... ok....

how ironic is it that my pointing out that your first post after last night's recess call was also that something bothered me about your post... hence, a gut feeling...

my vote stays for now.

Always peaks my interest when someone says they can't be evil because evil wouldn't do that. Just a lousy argument and will always get my attention and add them to my scumdar.

Can you explain how you've come to this conclusion?

I was finishing up billing and dinner stuff, Wiz... I am going to gather what brought me to my thoughts on Ice, and then I will get to your question (that was not sarcastic) <--that in parens might have been though

Took her a very long time to get to an answer for the question. I've done that before, usually when evil. Make a case against someone, but with nothing to back it, then have to find something to back it. Or just fail epicly and give up and say that I was wrong. Still, makes me think.

Yeah, sorry... missed that part. I'm really not comfortable with the tie or the fact that no one sees fit to break it. I retract my vote on Rich and vote to lynch Noodles.

I am torn. I like my case on Ice but it does have holes. I also see the points about Noods. I do not want a tie either. Nothing happening does not help anything.

I withdraw my vote on Ice and Vote to lynch Noods.

Ice has been around all day and trying to get things uncovered I do not see that in Noods at all.

This may be stupid, but I have to say this looks almost planned. And if someone calls them on it, they can just say "Would mafia really be that obvious?" and deflect attention that way...

SO, all in all, my list would be:

DD: for defending herself badly and because of the Ice comment and the time it took to lay down an answer.

Kashta: For her "digging" that never really went anywhere, and for the "tentative" vote on noods after creating an argument for voting her.

Ice: For being an ***.

Wiz: Seems a little off to me, but it's been a while since I played with him so it could just be me.

And that's all I have to say right now.

 

[rich311k]

Mellow out FF, it is just a game.

JB I do not remember one constructive post from you. Just a few about how you had nothing to go on and a lot of jokes. Not seeing much of a town feel from you.

I also think Kashta and Wiz have not added much to the game mostly some post that were supposed to be serious but said little. We had Wiz's tiff with DD. I do not see that anything was proved there.

 

[jbradt]

Mellow out FF, it is just a game.

JB I do not remember one constructive post from you. Just a few about how you had nothing to go on and a lot of jokes. Not seeing much of a town feel from you.

I also think Kashta and Wiz have not added much to the game mostly some post that were supposed to be serious but said little. We had Wiz's tiff with DD. I do not see that anything was proved there.

I could say the same for you, Rich. Don't worry. When work slows down a little later I'll have time to go back through. It's starting to feel like there's more to go on, so I'll be doing the usual JB thing. You'll have plenty to work with. :thumbsup: