Mafia 92: Night of the living Mafia... the play

[jm1212]

opcorn:

 

[IceH2O]

I decided to look at Kash, Not much Day 1 except for her weak reason on voting 2H who we now know to be innocent.
Most of Day 2 was questioning DD and Wiz (lightly) and hard charging JM who turned out to be innocent. I'm not pulling all those posts.

You got me curious. What "few things," Wizard? And what did you decide when you went back to check out my posts? I don't remember seeing you mention it.

Think this might be the only questioning of wiz.

yes, I do see that my suspect of Day 1 is on the chopping block.... but Kash.... if I vote him, will I be burying my vote again?? sheesh.

DD votes Kash while her day 1 suspect(JM) is on the block,safely ahead. Is she hiding her vote on a team mate?



I didn't pull posts from Wiz and hopefully I can later as I need to go now but I'm starting to wonder along with Dawg if Wiz doesn't know how many there are. He had a list I need to go back and find that looked real non committal but it could be just because it was an early list.

 

[IceH2O]

Red - See, Ice, that's the concern I have. Yes, C-Note is an obvious (almost too obvious) choice. But the fact that you cannot even imagine any other possibility than erratic play must always equal scum is just weird... especially for you.

What about this possibility: That C-Note came into this using an alias because they're not real good at this. Maybe it's a townie with a history of getting themselves killed Day 1 because they post scummy things when they're innocent? Maybe they hoped we wouldn't react the same way this time if we don't know who they are? Then that person still drew the same attention, like normal, so they disappeared when the pressure got strong?

I'm not saying that's the case here, but it's a possibility I would expect Ice to at least consider....... not just declare absolutely that someone has to be scum when we don't even know who they are.

Blue - No doubt that you will, but good for which team? ... townies, zombies, scum?

Did you slip Kash? Only innocents get Zombie Hits.

You want me to be more like me.I'm so sure of this I'm putting myself in the lead.

I retract my vote on DD and vote to lynch Kash.

 

[Kashta]

Cute one, Ice. It's not slip but looks like one, so vote me. I'm out of this anyway after nightfall thanks to JM.

 

[the wizard]

Right now DD, C-note, and Ice are my main suspects. I've listed a lot of my reasoning for DD being scum previously, and C-note totally disappearing is not pro-town. Ice still bugs me from day 1, where he listed Razz as a distant third, and how he was so sure Mad was scum. I also don't like how Tank has disappeared.

Kash is giving me townie vibes, though I could be wrong. I don't see Noods as scum. Pappy seems to be working for the town, as does Doom. I can't tell with Wiz, Rich, or Dawg.

Here's the vote count from last nightfall. Known innocents in blue.

Several loner votes. We're down to 12 players, so if 25% of the original list was made into scum, there are 4 scum remaining. I'd bet one scum was on JM. With the way the hours before last nightfall went, I wouldn't be surprised if the rest were spread out to not garner attention. No need for several of the scum team to jump on JM and bring scrutiny to themselves.

First let me say I think this is a first. I find it hard to believe that you and I are somewhat in agreement.

You can't tell if I am working for the town? If you have doubts then ask questions. You haven't questioned me about anything.

I will check back in in a bit I'm doing a head job on a mini van and need to have it done tonight. (Need to put a misting system in the garage) I will however continue to check the game and will be here at night fall.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Cute one, Ice. It's not slip but looks like one, so vote me. I'm out of this anyway after nightfall thanks to JM.

So you know that Ice will get a zombie hit if lynched? That means you know he is innocent, right? How is that not a slip? Can you explain what you meant?

 

[Lab_Rat]

First let me say I think this is a first. I find it hard to believe that you and I are somewhat in agreement.

You can't tell if I am working for the town? If you have doubts then ask questions. You haven't questioned me about anything.

I will check back in in a bit I'm doing a head job on a mini van and need to have it done tonight. (Need to put a misting system in the garage) I will however continue to check the game and will be here at night fall.

You seem to be pro-town, but I can't bring myself to trust you...of course I can't trust anyone and the non-slip slip of Kash's that Ice pointed out really has me wondering about her.

 

[Kashta]

Nothing there, Ice. Appreciate the effort, though.

I decided to look at Kash, Not much Day 1 except for her weak reason on voting 2H who we now know to be innocent.
Most of Day 2 was questioning DD and Wiz (lightly) and hard charging JM who turned out to be innocent. I'm not pulling all those posts.




Think this might be the only questioning of wiz.





DD votes Kash while her day 1 suspect(JM) is on the block,safely ahead. Is she hiding her vote on a team mate?



I didn't pull posts from Wiz and hopefully I can later as I need to go now but I'm starting to wonder along with Dawg if Wiz doesn't know how many there are. He had a list I need to go back and find that looked real non committal but it could be just because it was an early list.

Day 1 I had nothing to go on and couldn't be here to find anything beyond what I'd already posted before going to work. Yes I questioned DD; her play this game is scummy. Nothing anti-town about probing that. I haven't questioned Wizard, in particular, because I haven't seen anything suspicious about him yet.... same is true for others. And JM's game speaks for itself. I've voted my strongest suspect each time.

 

[rich311k]

That is an interesting question Kash, I would also like to know how you are so positive Ice would be a Zombie?

 

[Kashta]

So you know that Ice will get a zombie hit if lynched? That means you know he is innocent, right? How is that not a slip? Can you explain what you meant?

Thanks for at least asking what I meant instead of just blasting me, Lab.

I don't for a moment think Ice is innocent. I've made that clear enough. But yes, I might be wrong about him, DD, whomever else..... nothing is a sure thing here, we all know that with little evidence to go on.

What I meant was it didn't surprise me that Ice would say something about the zombie shot, implying his innocence.

I phrased it way I did because I've been thinking about asking DD and Ice to tell us who they intend to shoot if we're wrong about either of them. Both were split for the vote thus far.

I didn't ask them that question, though, because I'm not sure it would help us learn anything useful. It might also divert the town into discussing possible zombie targets and I'd rather we not help them by doing their thinking for them.

I agree it looks like I slipped, so I don't mind taking the lynch over it. You all decide for yourselves.