Mafia 93: Tank of Terror! Freshwater Version

[Lady G]

For the red, I don't think it's a huge deal but I saw it so I acknowledged it. I was hoping that others would chime in and share their thoughts and maybe start some discussions as we need more of that. With the amount of people posting reasons as to why they won't be

For the blue, yes i am suspecting UN but I found it strange that he did not even mention the nights events before jumping back on UN. Wouldn't you agree that it's unusual?

So, here you are (correct me if I'm wrong) admitting you just put something out there to see if others would chime in and back you up...is that so you could build a case on nothing but have others to call out if things go wrong?

 

[RazzleFish]

Rich has pretty much already said what (or similar to) what I am thinking after reading through, but I am going to add my thoughts on this anyway...if anyone wants to see it as "following, so be it.


I find it pretty interesting the ones on AAF...he is new and yes there are plenty of times newbs are scum, but day one is pretty harsh to be voted off, when still trying to figure the game out. I'm not saying newbs should always get a pass, but to jump on one day one, I just don't see it. I always think it best to keep a eye on them, give a little guidance, and see where it goes from there. Not everyone reads the games (fully), I know I didn't and I still don't if I'm not in them. Normally, if they get through day one nightfall and you see how it works you get a better grasp and understand it a bit more.


Lab, you know I think your awesome...but this gives me a red flag here, instead of offering any thoughts or help you just throw out there "read some old games"...really until you try it and get your feet wet, you just don't get it sometimes. It seemd someone with the towns (tanks) best interest in mind would want to help others to understand a little more.


Why? Doll your vote has me the most concerned right now. You are a true vet (been playing longer then me) so you really should understand the whole "going after a newb" no-no.



So, why is it worth pointing out that I (and Zaff) hadn't posted yet, I already said I wouldn't be around. I do like how you put "I don't know what to make of it, but thought I'd point it out"...is that to try and get someone else to "jump" on it", looking for some support to go forward with it??

Do you really think UN decided..."Hey I'm going to start to dig my pond after night one so I don't have to post"?

It's funny how you seem to "call out" UN, then turn around and question Ninja about his post toward UN.

Razz, you look to be pointing at many "nothings" here, it looks pretty much like you are just throwing things out there to see if anyone else jumps on it and backs you so you can go forward with more accusations.

So, here you are (correct me if I'm wrong) admitting you just put something out there to see if others would chime in and back you up...is that so you could build a case on nothing but have others to call out if things go wrong?

I understand you logic but allow me to explain mine. This game is very slow and with the amount of posting (or lack thereof) it is not in the towns best interest to sit back and not question things. My goal with the posts you pulled was to start people talking, whether it be about UN or anyone else. I would actually be happier with people questioning me than not questioning anyone. The only way we are going to be able to root out scum is if we question things and make note of the scummy things we see. Otherwise we may as well just throw in the towel and call it a mafia victory.

 

[RazzleFish]

Rich has pretty much already said what (or similar to) what I am thinking after reading through, but I am going to add my thoughts on this anyway...if anyone wants to see it as "following, so be it.


I find it pretty interesting the ones on AAF...he is new and yes there are plenty of times newbs are scum, but day one is pretty harsh to be voted off, when still trying to figure the game out. I'm not saying newbs should always get a pass, but to jump on one day one, I just don't see it. I always think it best to keep a eye on them, give a little guidance, and see where it goes from there. Not everyone reads the games (fully), I know I didn't and I still don't if I'm not in them. Normally, if they get through day one nightfall and you see how it works you get a better grasp and understand it a bit more.


Lab, you know I think your awesome...but this gives me a red flag here, instead of offering any thoughts or help you just throw out there "read some old games"...really until you try it and get your feet wet, you just don't get it sometimes. It seemd someone with the towns (tanks) best interest in mind would want to help others to understand a little more.


Why? Doll your vote has me the most concerned right now. You are a true vet (been playing longer then me) so you really should understand the whole "going after a newb" no-no.



So, why is it worth pointing out that I (and Zaff) hadn't posted yet, I already said I wouldn't be around. I do like how you put "I don't know what to make of it, but thought I'd point it out"...is that to try and get someone else to "jump" on it", looking for some support to go forward with it??

Do you really think UN decided..."Hey I'm going to start to dig my pond after night one so I don't have to post"?

It's funny how you seem to "call out" UN, then turn around and question Ninja about his post toward UN.

Razz, you look to be pointing at many "nothings" here, it looks pretty much like you are just throwing things out there to see if anyone else jumps on it and backs you so you can go forward with more accusations.

I forgot to answer this during the go.

I know that in this heat digging a pond would not even be considered and looking at the weather in Massachusetts for today HERE I'm not sure why anyone would just decide to dig a pond on a whim like that. If he was telling the truth I hope he has plenty of water.

 

[Lady G]

I understand you logic but allow me to explain mine. This game is very slow and with the amount of posting (or lack thereof) it is not in the towns best interest to sit back and not question things. My goal with the posts you pulled was to start people talking, whether it be about UN or anyone else. I would actually be happier with people questioning me than not questioning anyone. The only way we are going to be able to root out scum is if we question things and make note of the scummy things we see. Otherwise we may as well just throw in the towel and call it a mafia victory.

I agree we need to talk and discuss things, but to just toss things out there just for the sake of throwing it out there...just does nothing to help. Calling someone out for questioning some one you yourself are questioning, looks like you are "prepping" for if they end up innocent once lynched.
So, yes I agree we need to talk..but I also think it should be productive, not just trying to get others to jump on something that is really nothing.

I forgot to answer this during the go.

I know that in this heat digging a pond would not even be considered and looking at the weather in Massachusetts for today HERE I'm not sure why anyone would just decide to dig a pond on a whim like that. If he was telling the truth I hope he has plenty of water.

Oh, I wont deny I would never be out digging or doing anything at this time...but again, it looks like you are trying to get others to jump. Un is pretty self destructive as it is, it doesn't take much to get others to jump on him.

 

[Lady G]

I would like to here more from those who voted AAF, and those who instead of trying to guide him in anyway just questioned and kept things going on him. THAT is what I would like to hear.

Why did you vote him, what made you go after him yet not vote him?

 

[Zaffy]

I would like to here more from those who voted AAF, and those who instead of trying to guide him in anyway just questioned and kept things going on him. THAT is what I would like to hear.

Why did you vote him, what made you go after him yet not vote him?

Your posting on this topic comes across to me as if you knew (s)he would flip tank and are scolding people for voting him/her.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Your posting on this topic comes across to me as if you knew (s)he would flip tank and are scolding people for voting him/her.

If I'm reading this correctly you just called LG a tank. Which in my brain spells scum. Why would an innocent assuming your one, want to point out a tank? Writes zaffy on my people to whatch list.

 

[Zaffy]

If I'm reading this correctly you just called LG a tank. Which in my brain spells scum. Why would an innocent assuming your one, want to point out a tank? Writes zaffy on my people to whatch list.

Read it again.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Can I get on the list, is it based on anything besides his questioning you?

Rich why must you test me??? It seems your trying to make me look stupid in this post so that my previous post won't be as compeling. AKA my post against razz. Now maybe before when you shoved razz in the open and sheilded zaffy it was a act of distancing from razz. And now since I've been questioning razz your defending them. (teamate maybe). I have been questioning razz almost all game so far and you voted for me yesturday, another thing to help people get their eyes off razz. So maybe sheilding razz and zaf could spell out the scum team?

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Read it again.

And so I have and what you said was that LG is posting like she new AAF would flip tank. There for she her self is a tank