Mafia 94: When Gingers Attack; the play

TwoHobbies said:
Your right Jpap. I made that post after quickly looking at nightfall, and being very surprised that the cartoon syrum wasn't used. After looking over nightfall this morning I'm thinking everyone up was innocent. That makes this the list

Razzlefish
Dangerdoll
Allaboutfish
Jpappy
Lady G
Rich 311k
Wizzard

From that list I'm going to remove Allaboutfish, and Rich. AAF I'll still give more time, and Rich because If I'm right there would be no reason to risk a late vote move like he did.
Click to expand...

...and if you're wrong Rich could have been moving his vote to save Kash and/or Pir.
 
the wizard said:
It seems to me 2H that you think like a few others, however, you don't seem to get your thoughts out there. As in the second post you were thinking the same thoughts on Chill as Kashta the night before and she beat you to the punch.

In the first post you were hoping someone would have remembered Plants playing style. I wonder if you are just trying to get by with trying to look helpful without sticking your neck out.

Did LG catch you at trying to subtly spread a little confusion when you posted about how many Gingers there are?

It is hard to slip when you just post that you agree with what others have posted.
Click to expand...

Hopefully what I posted today answers you concerns.

I really think you and G are making a mountain out of nothing. Is this subject getting us anywhere? 3, 4 who cares...oh yea, you and G do!
 
RazzleFish said:
And what exactly made you come to this conclusion?

It's a pretty bold statement to make early in Day 2...
Click to expand...

The syrum not being used. Suppose you give me your thoughts on why you think it wasn't used.

Bold Statment !?!?!? I'm posting what I'm thinking. Is your real problem that you are on the list?
 
dirtydawg10 said:
I went back to look at the voting close to night...


JPap with the first vote on Plant for "low post" theory which turns out was not exactly Plant's theory. This was determined prior to nightfall. At least by me anyway. Then 2H followed up shortly after JPap with another vote on Plant.




Then LG "lynches" 2H and comes back 1/2hr later to change her wording to "genetically test". I point this out because no one else voted in between LG's 2 posts. It made me wonder if someone told her she needed to reword her vote.


This change in vote from Chill caused a 3 way tie between Pir, Plant & Kash. Good strategy usually to see where votes fall when players are tied up for the lynch (Gen. test)


Rich puts Plant in the lead by one vote.


Razz ties it up between Plant and Pir.

I wanted to get this out for everyone to look at and comment on.




2H so you have 8 people on your innocent list already? Sounds like you have this all figured out...but I highly doubt you are right.
Click to expand...

Good catch

Yes I keep a list and move people back and forth as the game goes on. Not saying I'm right, or have anything figured out. Just sharring my thoughts, while listening to all others.
 
TwoHobbies said:
The syrum not being used. Suppose you give me your thoughts on why you think it wasn't used.

Bold Statment !?!?!? I'm posting what I'm thinking. Is your real problem that you are on the list?
Click to expand...

Who's to say that the gingers are waiting to use the syrum on a townie PR? Why waste the syrum on Day 1 when there is not a very big chance of hitting a PR when they could wait and have a better guess later on? They also have investigations so they could be waiting for those results before using it.

I feel that saying everyone up for a test last night was innocent is a bold statement. I have no problem at all being on your list. IMO it's a weak case and with so many people on the list, I would actually have a problem not being on the list.
 
dirtydawg10 said:
...and if you're wrong Rich could have been moving his vote to save Kash and/or Pir.
Click to expand...

True, but then why not use the syrum. I can see them saving it to go after another PR, but not if they had any chance of losing a player on a late vote switch.

dirtydawg10 said:
So 2H...out of the 5 you now have on your list which 3 are your most likely scum and why?
Click to expand...

Lets just call it a top 5 for now.
 
dirtydawg10 said:
I went back to look at the voting close to night...


JPap with the first vote on Plant for "low post" theory which turns out was not exactly Plant's theory. This was determined prior to nightfall. At least by me anyway. Then 2H followed up shortly after JPap with another vote on Plant.




Then LG "lynches" 2H and comes back 1/2hr later to change her wording to "genetically test". I point this out because no one else voted in between LG's 2 posts. It made me wonder if someone told her she needed to reword her vote.


This change in vote from Chill caused a 3 way tie between Pir, Plant & Kash. Good strategy usually to see where votes fall when players are tied up for the lynch (Gen. test)


Rich puts Plant in the lead by one vote.


Razz ties it up between Plant and Pir.

I wanted to get this out for everyone to look at and comment on.




2H so you have 8 people on your innocent list already? Sounds like you have this all figured out...but I highly doubt you are right.
Click to expand...

That is a good point.

So what do you think about the votes after Ice. From that post you only tell what happened but what do/did you make of Rich's vote, my vote and any other votes that you left out? Speaking of, what made you pick out some votes and not others? Seems odd that you would leave out votes...
 
^To make that question easier to understand, I meant, what made you pull Pappy's vote (which was so long before night) and then skip over some of the other votes in between?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom