It came across my mind but not enough to make me vote for her.
Oh, that went right over my head! But it makes a little more sense now... LOL
Mafia 94: When Gingers Attack; the play
- Thread starter jbradt
- Start date
It came across my mind but not enough to make me vote for her.
Oh, that went right over my head! But it makes a little more sense now... LOL
It was the change in her play that caught my attention. Like I said, I've never seen her call Wiz by his real name in a game before so it made me do a double take. Then I got to thinking, maybe she used his name in the scum den and meant to post that to Plant in their den. Of course the more I thought about it the more plausible it became in my mind. I did think of them as a package deal, did you read my earlier explanation on why I chose Plant over Kash? Right now idk what to think, but I'm not thinking omg Kash is scum like I was thinking before.
I do think 2H has a good point, if scum had been on the block (esp if that scum was Jessica Rabbit) it makes sense they would have used the vial. No mention of any extra happenings during nightfall, so I'm going to assume they did not use the vial.
Now I don't understand DD's vote on me. From what I can tell, she's voting for me because I didn't get her joke. DD, was there more to your vote than that? With as close and active as things were pre-nightfall, why place a lone vote on me?
I did read your post on why you ultimately chose Plant. I was just curious as to what your current thoughts on Kash were now that Plant flipped innocent.
And 2H's point make sense, granted there may be a time later in the game where mafia might put the vial to better use...but to me, gaining another player/getting rid of a townie early seems like a safer strategy. My point is that for him to say that he is going to focus on those with single votes and no votes is trivial. Only Kash and Pir received multiple votes last night other than a dead Plant (and not counting himself, of course). That would leave 10 players...how could that be focusing on anybody?
first off, that night fall sucked.
Sorry to see you go Zaff and Plant.
It has been an extremely long day. Ended up working on 2 vehicles after I got off work. So combined with the heat I am a little brain dead right now. I have skimmed through but cannot put two coherent thoughts together right now. Think I will go to bed and try to get through a little and post something in the morning.
The one thing that sticks in my head though, is how everyone keeps saying that Pir is playing like he normally does.
Let me ask this, how long has he been playing? How long before someone states that he has enough experience and it is time he upped his game? I have let AAF slide on some of his posts because I know this is only his second game.
I will not let someone who has played as many games as Pir slide.
Step up your game Pir You know how it is played by now. let's see something.
Sorry to see you go Zaff and Plant.
It has been an extremely long day. Ended up working on 2 vehicles after I got off work. So combined with the heat I am a little brain dead right now. I have skimmed through but cannot put two coherent thoughts together right now. Think I will go to bed and try to get through a little and post something in the morning.
The one thing that sticks in my head though, is how everyone keeps saying that Pir is playing like he normally does.
Let me ask this, how long has he been playing? How long before someone states that he has enough experience and it is time he upped his game? I have let AAF slide on some of his posts because I know this is only his second game.
I will not let someone who has played as many games as Pir slide.
Step up your game Pir You know how it is played by now. let's see something.
Just trying to clear the cobwebs from my head this morning and this is the first thing that caught my eye.
It seems to me 2H that you think like a few others, however, you don't seem to get your thoughts out there. As in the second post you were thinking the same thoughts on Chill as Kashta the night before and she beat you to the punch.
In the first post you were hoping someone would have remembered Plants playing style. I wonder if you are just trying to get by with trying to look helpful without sticking your neck out.
Did LG catch you at trying to subtly spread a little confusion when you posted about how many Gingers there are?
It is hard to slip when you just post that you agree with what others have posted.
It seems to me 2H that you think like a few others, however, you don't seem to get your thoughts out there. As in the second post you were thinking the same thoughts on Chill as Kashta the night before and she beat you to the punch.
In the first post you were hoping someone would have remembered Plants playing style. I wonder if you are just trying to get by with trying to look helpful without sticking your neck out.
Did LG catch you at trying to subtly spread a little confusion when you posted about how many Gingers there are?
It is hard to slip when you just post that you agree with what others have posted.
THank you for your answer Lab, I know you haven't played with Plant before but she is a very valuable innocent also. No, I do not think it was a stupid way of thinking though, as I agree with your thoughts on Kash (being important for the town when innocent). At least now I understand where you were coming from with your choice.
As for who would find Zaff a threat...you actually come to mind, you two seem to call each other out quite a bit in these games.
Not sure I buy the whole "they would of used their syrum if they were on the chopping block"...
Although, yes I'm sure they would love a turn...I could see them waiting to try and find a PR to take out.
Still getting caught up here:
I stopped posting Tues night around 9ish and had that thought after. By the time I logged on Wed morning Kash had already commented on it.
Yes I said "likely", Is the number of Gingers really that important? How about you tell me exactly how many to you there are?
:lol:
2H, if you had these thoughts on Chill last night...why wait for someone else to post about it before commenting?
Well, it ended up they didn't take anything...but left a beer can in her bathroom trash, which is how she knew someone had been in the house. She doesn't drink beer and no one had been over...really creepy!
Even after seeing in the rules and JB confirming all roles were in the rules you still say "likely"?
Ok, you have a list but don't want to share...I love these kind of posts (j/k) why even bring it up?
How does "saying" you have a list make it a "not out of the blue" vote? You couldn't just say why you were voting?
I stopped posting Tues night around 9ish and had that thought after. By the time I logged on Wed morning Kash had already commented on it.
Yes I said "likely", Is the number of Gingers really that important? How about you tell me exactly how many to you there are?
No G, I was re-hashing an earlier post were she stated I hadn't posted, but missed that Wiz hadn't either. I believe Zaffy and others commented on it. I'm surprised you missed all those posts.
Funny that you would say that here, because back in post 253 you corrected Wiz about her, pappy, and I.
