Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

[Kashta]

Day 2 - Vote Count

1 DD - MC (783)

No vote: Everyone else.



With roughly 25 and a 1/2 hours to go.

 

[Chill]

It's not splitting hairs. You named people as "leaning innocent" immediately after one nightfall. I repeat, one nightfall. The only conceivable reason for Chill was that he voted DD with you despite having no reason to, as he has pretty much said himself.

There is no reason to try to cross people off the list yet. You've played enough games to know that anyone is suspect at this point in the game.

I don't try to understand what may be going on behind the scenes. I don't think FF is immune from the scum team throwing him under the bus. It's nice to look back and say you were right but FF screwed up big time and unfortunately he constituted much of the D1 talk.



Was there any reason you chose DD as the placeholder vote?

Yes she had two votes and if scum wanted to move they might see someone with three votes as a "reasonable" excuse to move off an innocent

 

[jpappy789]

Yes she had two votes and if scum wanted to move they might see someone with three votes as a "reasonable" excuse to move off an innocent

So essentially you thought you were going to trap scum with less than 20 minutes left?

Why would scum switch at that point when there had been no switching for the majority of the day beforehand? Do you think one more vote mattered?

 

[rich311k]

Just curious Rich...why do you think looking at Spence would be a waste of time?

Because wasting a day looking at someone playing his first time will get us no where, badger him enough and he will look scummy. I am sorry I got involved in it on day one.

 

[Lab_Rat]

So with you, Wiz and MC showing up recently, would you say that you're coordinating?

I would say my arrival was coordinated with the end of the early NFL games. Maybe they got back from the sports bar at that time too.

Labby, if you were getting strong townie vibes from Wiz, why did you lob this grenade (below) at him after nightfall? Seriously. You're not asking him for information or any clarification to help further make up your mind, you simply tossed some scum on him. Right?

If you're not seeing Wiz as anything but helpful townie at that point, why shove him out there with that?

That's hardly a grenade. It's more like a NERF dart.

I need to re-read the days events, then I'll be back with more thoughts.

 

[Chill]

So essentially you thought you were going to trap scum with less than 20 minutes left?

Why would scum switch at that point when there had been no switching for the majority of the day beforehand? Do you think one more vote mattered?

No no delusions of trapping scum before nightfall just looking for information for the days to follow.

 

[Chill]

FF and Spence were tied, so they where both innocent and the scum where happy or Spence was scum and the mafia did not think moving to save him was worth the risk. Right now I do think we should look elsewhere as concentrating on Spence is sort of a waste of time.

I do not see the DD thing but subtle hints are all we have to go on right now. I find Noods being the hit interesting as I think other players would have been a more likely choice.

I also find the choice of hit interesting.

 

[jpappy789]

No no delusions of trapping scum before nightfall just looking for information for the days to follow.

So why would your vote on DD convince anyone to switch, especially that late in the game?

I also find the choice of hit interesting.

Anything more than that?

I'm not sure what the point of bringing up the hit is...last game we chose Zaffy randomly and got lucky. Nothing to say that didn't happen again, unless you think Noods ruffled any feathers yesterday...which I certainly do not see.

 

[Chill]

I wasn't going to do this, let all of my suspicions be known at once that is, but since JP kind of forced my hand by asking me directly let me answer you with no.

There is nothing in your previous posts that I can use to lean you innocent. You have not posted much of anything other than your one liners.

I was leaning you innocent with reservations meaning I would keep an eye on you to see if your play picked up to categorize you later. It is my own way of trying to narrow down the number of people to look at till I can get some kind of read.

It is hard enough to get a read on some of you but when looking at 20?

I would be interested to see if you do decide to actually help the town though.

Hard to tell who's helping at this stage. I helped lynch an innocent last night I tend to play my cards fairly close to avoid that kinda ****.

 

[Chill]

Has it occurred to you that if he was scum the vets in the scum den might have helped him straighten out his story enough to keep him off the chopping block? We do have players that will coach a newb and help him to post in a way that would prevent situations like last night.

While it is true, and we won't know until his role is revealed, that he could indeed still be scum. I am basing my thoughts on the number of times in the past that we have had similar setups for the lynch and a quite thread.

Most of the time that has been that we were doing the scums job for them and putting 2 of our own up for the lynch.

We really won't know how quiet the scum were until we know your role. What concerns me the most about your gut feeling is that you were suddenly so certain that we had two innocents that you offered yourself up for a run off tonight if one turned scum. I had doubts but it could have went either way I wouldn't be offering myself up for a lynch in that situation.