Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

[Zaffy]

Every time I try to read the thread today something comes up and I've been interrupted, I think I have some time finally.

 

[Chill]

I'm not so sure a scum FF would have moved


Good points Ninja


Ok Chill, this post is bothering me...would it of mattered to you which person Pir voted? Also if you didn't see enough to vote either...why would you vote to maintain the tie?

Well I'm glad I'm bothering you cause the only time I don't is when you're scum. I seen reasons to vote for either of them. Being FF and noob the reasons were not conclusive. Either or both could have been scum I was more content with a coin flip then a guess.

 

[jpappy789]

Dude now you are putting less words in my mouth I said maybe he had a suspicion of dd and maybe not...I havent so much scrapped my last theory but have thought about how I said it.

Well, he voted DD so if he is innocent then I would have to say that your thoughts are correct. If he is scum then there is no suspicion involved. I fail to see why this "maybe/maybe not" needs to even be stated and why Dawg's vote meant enough to be specifically called out. What do you think of the other votes on DD?

You still have yet to say how DD hypothetically saved Spencer by voting for him. Her vote made it a 50% chance he would have been lynched. Any other vote and it would be less than that.

 

[Chill]

Wait, are you saying you had your posts before nightfall already typed up from earlier? How much earlier?

no when I typed the DD votes I also typed the retractions

 

[Madcrawdad]

That's hardly a grenade. It's more like a NERF dart.

Grenade or NERF dart, who cares? The point is that you threw it. Doesn't make sense seeing that Wiz has been giving you warm fuzzies inside.

The object of the game is for the town to work together, and apparently you've been liking what you've been seeing from Wiz. So why lob that NERF dart his way? If you're town and feeling good about him, wouldn't you want others to feel the same way too?

I mean it's fine if you were asking a question for further clarification, but you tossed something at him that he couldn't defend against. Kind of a weird way to show your blossoming trust for him.

 

[Rbishop]

Posts were typed copy and paste and hit enter a race to the wire

must be too late for me..what did you mean?

 

[allaboutfish]

i dont like how MC has be repeatively asked why he though that DD was trying to save spencer. makes me think hes just trying to get her lynched for some reason.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

If Pir had voted I would have maintained the tie. I didn't move cause I had no stronger feel for either of the two on the block.

so basically what your saying is that you had no real person in mind you just though the easiest place to hide was DD.

what I'm also seeing chill is that you really weren't posting alot before you were just laying low. If memory serves wiz called you innocent because there were no post of your that weren't wish wash gibberish. Now that people have started questioning you a little you are right in there making yourself heard. Seems a little suspicious to me. Seems like you were trying to lay low until others started noticing so you have to be right in front so no one notices your extended absences with little posting in between. Take the post i quoted above that was your only post for a while even though you had a number a questions to answer. But now your answering them all in a hurry. I'll be watching you and maybe even voting you.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

i dont like how MC has be repeatively asked why he though that DD was trying to save spencer. makes me think hes just trying to get her lynched for some reason.

I'm sorry what in the heck does this mean? who's he? and are you saying you think it's scummy that this "HE" is asking some questions? I'm very confused?

 

[Dangerdoll]

and who said DD had common sense?

:swear:

Listen dawg voted DD maybe cause he was onto something or maybe just as a waste vote I don't really see the way he did yesterday. Of course maybe DD was undecided where to cast the vote, we also don't know what chills roll is and seems kind of weird he voted DD and was the last to vote.

Yes but she was one of the last to vote and really did so without much conviction at all. I think it would of looked a lot worse for her in my eyes if she would of cast a vote for FF. .

I stated earlier in the day why I had been suspicious of Spence. To say I voted without conviction is incorrect. When looking at the votes, I was really in between FF or Spence and went with who I thought was more likely mafia. There were still 2 more votes to go when I voted. It ended in a tie because Chill didn't vote in the running. Either Chill wanted the tie or he was afraid he would be suspected either way he went. There were only 2 votes on me so he chose the safe way to keep out of the light, bottom line.

If you wanted to vote and not stand out as a lone vote, DD was the logical choice, she was out there and had some votes. Voting her instead of being the kill vote on the who played worse tie was a perfect place to hide and of course today you can say "see I knew FF was just being FF", same would apply to Spence, assuming he is a townie as well.

I understand the worry since the quiet would mean a happy mafia team but Wiz that was pretty over the top alarmism, it is day one and the odds are stacked completely against us.

this is not specific to only Rich because it's been mentioned a few times. My thoughts on "quiet would mean a happy mafia", is that this may be exactly what they are depending on us to think. I would think that if Spence is mafia and he was on the line (a tie) with FF, the mafia could afford to sit and say nothing. They had a 50% chance on not losing him. If they did lose him, it's the new guy.... no one would look to what he said as having much girth because he is just a noob. I think that anyone dismissing Spence because they believe the mafia was happy that there were 2 townies on the block is foolish.