Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

[Lab_Rat]

LMAO!!!


Ok, I see what you were saying


Not really shocked, but it gives me that feeling I can't shake, and makes you go up quite a bit on the scum scale.


Really? I believe it has happened.


Agreed


Chill, now your offering too?

As for the case on MC...yeah, I can see what others are seeing but I'm not so sure it shows him as scum at this point. I have seen him do the same things as innocent, and I really can't remember how he played as scum tbh. Personally, I am not ready to vote him.

Wizard, I really can see voting yet something is bugging me about the quick jump (or what seems like a jump) on to him.

Chill, again I can see what others think they are seeing, but I'm not sure I "feel" it at this point.

Doll...not seeing it.

The one who has me most concerned right now would be Labby. It hasn't been anything big..but a few posts really stuck out when I read them, especially the one she questioned MC for his vote on her. The wording just made me think "or you could of told him to throw a vote on you just in case".

For now,,,I VOTE TO LYNCH LABBY

Actually this entire post makes me think we've got Chill, MC, and LG on the scum team.

 

[user_name]

I'm stuck between Chill and Wiz, my gut is telling me that MC is a bad choice. Plus, I don't like voting someone who hasn't defended themselves. I retract my previous vote to lynch MC, and vote to lynch Chill.

 

[Lady G]

Really? Afraid to make a kill vote or tie something up?

Sounds like maybe you know innocents are up for the lynch?

Actually this entire post makes me think we've got Chill, MC, and LG on the scum team.

..not at all Labby

 

[mostlycichlids]

I have been at work all day, what a long day... I have thought about my vote on DD and really you guys have convinced me that my vote for DD was illogical esp jpapp. I guess I ahve some sort of concern for her because of previous games which is really stupid. Anyway, chill has raised a lot of suspicion for me in the last 24 hours and the thing that sticks out to me is how he was content with having a coin toss especially when one who was lynched was an innocent. I RETRACT MY VOTE ON DD and VOTE TO LYNCH CHILL.

 

[user_name]

I retract my previous vote, and vote to lynch MC

 

[Zaffy]

Vote count for reference, pay attention to MC, Dawg and DD's votes...ie, none are on FF.





MC's post after nightfall, apparently frustrated because the scum "convinced everyone FF was scum"... never mind the fact that we had a tie.



Now after all that we have MC voting for DD and wanting to hear more from Dawg. Neither voted FF and in fact DD voted with MC on spencer.



MC's explanation is that DD voted spencer to somehow save spencer (if anyone can tell me how that works, please do explain) and that Dawg then voted DD to look innocent.

Yeah. I get the numbers game thing. I also get that it was D1 and you were almost yelling from the rooftops "FF and Spencer are innocent!". Your sense of urgency would make more sense in LYLO than on D1.

What does it means "LYLO?"

Listen dawg voted DD maybe cause he was onto something or maybe just as a waste vote I don't really see the way he did yesterday. Of course maybe DD was undecided where to cast the vote, we also don't know what chills roll is and seems kind of weird he voted DD and was the last to vote.

Yes but she was one of the last to vote and really did so without much conviction at all. I think it would of looked a lot worse for her in my eyes if she would of cast a vote for FF. .

Reading through MC's posts gives me the feeling that he's more interested in building a case because of a narrow concept, rather than the overall picture of what someone is doing.

I think an innocent would try to prove they are innocent by not moving a vote like that. I guess a mafia could just as well do the same thing but I'm not sure FF would. I think if FF was scum or a PR he would have moved his vote JMHO.

I had a feeling the scum were comfortable because there was not much vote moving going on. People just piled on the 2 top nominees. If one or both of them were scum I think the votes would have been more spread around.


Good points JPap




Obviously your opinions differ from mine but I still am entitled to my own opinion

The whole town, scum and townies were piled onto 3 people for night 1, in a 21 person game. All 3 of them were perfectly fine places to hide. I don't see how anyone can really form an argument that one was better than the other. At least without other evidence to support it.

LG, papp always plays his roles good either mafia, PR or townie, is he always someone to watch yes but I never said he wasn't innocent but he hasnt said anything to make me think otherwise. Why would you come in with limited computer time and ask me this of all things? Has papp said anything to make you lean towards mafia, am I missing something please let me know?

I guess it don't really make sense why she would and I guess that she could of placed a vote somewhere else. But what if chill or our UD would of came in and placed a vote on FF then DD would not of looked too guilty at all as others placed a vote on Spence.

I would also like to know?

Are you saying you helped lynch an innocent really?

Dawg (481) Wizard (600) Chill (733) DD (645) Ok, so wizard, chill and dawg voted to lynch DD in the first night. Today has turned up some suspicion on wizard and chill, we will get to that later. Look at the final votes on DD minus dawgs vote, Wizzards vote was late and then chill was last to cast a vote. Neither of them had much to say about DD beforehand. Those votes to me were safety votes, dawg may also of been playing safe.

I am not going to repeat myself over and over again.

How is it scummy please elaborate?

I can't understand how it was better to hide on FF than DD or Spencer, all 3 were perfectly good suspects for a day 1, and that shows because everyone was on them.

No I am not saying who didn't vote FF were scum. I am saying that FF was innocent and now we know that we have to work together to find mafia and sometimes the best place to start is look at who did not vote for the one who was lynched and who cast somewhat random votes near night end.

I posted this a few posts back. "I guess it don't really make sense why she would and I guess that she could of placed a vote somewhere else. But what if chill or our UD would of came in and placed a vote on FF then DD would not of looked too guilty at all as others placed a vote on Spence."

What is special about the votes near nightdfall? I saw people trying not to break the tie, you see people trying hide. I'm of the opinion that if you see something scummy, then vote for them.

Which is why,

I vote to lynch MC

You are the only one to quote me from yesterday and not throw me on the BBQ........ you must be scum.

:grinyes:

Must be! But, honestly, when you have 16 out of 21 people voting on 2 suspects, and everyone seems fine with it, you have to wonder a little.

The more I sit here and think about it I'm wondering if MC WAS throwing names out there to see where people would vote. He placed his vote on DD to see if others would jump on. After all he could always move his vote if he needed to. DD was in the running last night and he may have seen her as an easy target to jump on early. Right now I see MC as looking the most like scum so I will place my vote.

I vote to lynch MC

It just doesn't make sense, I get the feeling that MC just wanted to make a case for the sake of making a case, and grabbed onto the idea of late voters just because it sounds insidious.

 

[rich311k]

I vote to lynch the Wiz. Blew the trumpet way to many times last night.

 

[allaboutfish]

i think its weird that all the votes on DD yesterday have totally been dropped and now no one suspects her. not say shes mafia or anything but why the total change of heart everybody?

 

[allaboutfish]

I retract my previous vote, and vote to lynch MC

a little wishy washy? make up your mind and state a reason for the switch. or did the scum team tell you to switch?

 

[user_name]

I switched because I wasn't satisfied with MC's reasoning for voting. Plus, the fact that they posted and voted last minute, and then signed off is scummy as hell. It sound's to me like they were content with the vote, and left. I also have nothing but a gut feeling on Chill, him and Wiz are both suspect, Wiz seems "off" but not scummy.