Science

and perhaps if people would have said user name not un I would not have miscontrued it as being a remark aimed at me
Now you are just digging yourself into a silly hole. It is a rather common way to reply. Name, abbreviated name, nickname, real name; all are used very commonly in replies around here and other forums. What exacted did you think "UN" meant?

I would agree about wiki as it is a site that saddly allows anyone to modify, which for the most part can be non verifiable. Though there is a huge difference between that and things like the youtube vid's I have posted.
Like others said, it isn't Youtube in general that is the issue. But...I don't get your logic here. Youtube is not a perfect source, for the same exact reason as Wikipedia. With Wikipedia anyone can post or edit the content (unless the content has been locked). That is why people don't trust it as a source. The same exact thing applies to Youtube. Anyone can post or edit the content. Granted it is a bit more work then editing a Wiki, but with the right skills and tools even your documentary could be edited to say the complete opposite of what it was meant too. People won't know for sure so they'll instantly discount Youtube as a source.

Youtube isn't a bad method for presenting data or spreading information. Just as Wikipedia isn't a bad method for presenting data or spreading information. It just isn't a good source for backing up a debate.


And even discounting all of that. A documentary is not a scientific source or even a good basis for a debate to begin with. It is a piece of media, built on an opinion, designed to present that opinion. "Documentary" is simply a genre, not a measure of reliability of the information presented. The creator of the documentary is not required to present both sides, fairly or otherwise, or even use the truth. They can use editing or false information just like any other person.




And lastly, calm down a little. Take a deep breath. Maybe stab a voodoo doll a little (I suggest a Rbishop voodoo doll for this purpose). Then reply. Nothing destroys an argument faster then looking like you are freaking out or getting angry (especially on the internet, where those are seen as major weaknesses and will be exploited in the future whenever needed, once discovered).
 
Last edited:
Thread of the Year

Congratulations to all who made it happen!
ya know, we've had some doosies (purple string anyone?). i wasn't to sure about that at first glance.

but alas...
Maybe stab a voodoo doll a little (I suggest a Rbishop voodoo doll for this purpose).
now it's official meesa thinks.
 
and perhaps if people would have said user name not un I would not have miscontrued it as being a remark aimed at me
UN = user_name makes sense.
UN = chefjamesscott does not make sense.


If you want the opinion of a real professor, I happen to be in the position to give it to you. In fact, I am a professor. My students know not to use Youtube or Wikipedia as a reference. I have no problem if they go to the reference section at Wikipedia and find a peer-reviewed manuscript that way, but they best not cite Wikipedia if they want to receive credit.
 
theWAREHOUSE_comic_625_wallpaper.jpg

UN = user_name makes sense.
UN = chefjamesscott does not make sense.


If you want the opinion of a real professor, I happen to be in the position to give it to you. In fact, I am a professor. My students know not to use Youtube or Wikipedia as a reference. I have no problem if they go to the reference section at Wikipedia and find a peer-reviewed manuscript that way, but they best not cite Wikipedia if they want to receive credit.

When one of my students is at an impasse, I suggest this to them.

theWAREHOUSE_comic_625_wallpaper.jpg
 
I looked it up on wikipedia, and as it turns out, wikipedia is a reliable source. You guys are all wrong.
 
Science says that adults are more mature then children. I believed that until I saw an adult (prob in his 60s) riding a supermarket cart across the lot and laughing the who way. Science hath failed me!
 
Science says that adults are more mature then children. I believed that until I saw an adult (prob in his 60s) riding a supermarket cart across the lot and laughing the who way. Science hath failed me!
Science has proven males have arrested development somewhere in their teenage to early 20s years. Therefore, the adult male you saw was acting just like a teenager, proving science to be correct once again.
 
AquariaCentral.com