Mafia 96 Who Are You? Game Thread

[jpappy789]

last time im going to explain the vote switch. i got on the computer, looked at the new posts and saw the mafia thread clicked on it, realized it was night, and put a quick vote in without looking at anything(totally random), then i went back and read and saw the vote list and i didnt want to vote on someone and lynch them for no reason so i switched to someone with no votes that way i wasnt lynching anybody i had barely andy suspicions about. im leaning towards zaffy too. i dont like how he posted how he agreed with everything and then left and we havent seen him since, and he hasnt done anything to help. i vote to lynch zaffy. i should be on alot tomorrow and over the weekend, way more than ive been able to get on.

You are still forgetting about the part where you went back and found a reason to vote for FF after the fact. That's the part that makes no sense in this time line.

 

[allaboutfish]

You are still forgetting about the part where you went back and found a reason to vote for FF after the fact. That's the part that makes no sense in this time line.

i thought i would be questioned for not having a reason.

 

[jpappy789]

i thought i would be questioned for not having a reason.

So instead of saying it was a random, UD-saving vote like you have been saying you basically fabricated a reason?

 

[IceH2O]

the more the vote is spread out, the easier it is for a communicating team to throw 2 votes and take the swing. are we sure the communicating team at this point is townie friendly? (if there is one as of yet)

Later in the game this would be true, but at this point no boss will likely investigate someone on the block in risk of being lynched. That will help us narrow down who might have been investigated in the early part of the game. On day 1 half the town had votes on them and it stayed close so I'd assume most/none of them were investigated plus 2 UDs means that more then likely only 2 of 7 players were investigated. We're not as spread out this day so the chances are less that we'd be able to narrow it down. Unless others want to vote MC, which is risky due to the chance of a UD. Though at this point might be worth it in case he decides to play as he has been.

 

[dundadundun]

That would make more sense if the communicating team knew who the opposite team members were. That could very easily back fire in their favor.

but this is day two, so they could easily have 2 votes and know one name between the don and one scum player.

 

[IceH2O]

i thought i would be questioned for not having a reason.

so its better to have a reasonable reason and switch to someone you have no clue about?

 

[IceH2O]

but this is day two, so they could easily have 2 votes and know one name between the don and one scum player.

If the don found a team mate they wouldn't know if anyone else was innocent or scum.

 

[allaboutfish]

So instead of saying it was a random, UD-saving vote like you have been saying you basically fabricated a reason?

i admitt i was thinking right. i was kind of thinking it was later in the game but knew it was the beggining. kind of an inpulse i guess.

 

[jpappy789]

but this is day two, so they could easily have 2 votes and know one name between the don and one scum player.

If they have a communicator with them they don't know anyone else

 

[allaboutfish]

so its better to have a reasonable reason and switch to someone you have no clue about?

when its the beggining, you dont have enough to go on and you dont feel comfortable lynching him especially when he gets lynched first almost every game bc hes an easy target. just bc mafia cant communicate doesnt mean they cant think a like. i switched to spence just bc he had no one on him thats the only reason.