Mafia 96 Who Are You? Game Thread
- Thread starter the wizard
- Start date
I finally had some time to get caught up.
Here's my take on Ice at this point. I don't think Ice is playing square with the town. But, it's Ice. He never plays square with the town. I believe fully he's playing some kind of game, but his games when innocent can benefit the town. I understand the suspicion against him and have gone back and forth on it a few times. But I don't have enough evidence to put a vote there.
Dag... what you said to me (I don't know why you pulled my question post instead of your answer...) was that other than your argument condemning Ice for changing his strategy, your case on him was gut feeling. I can see the basis of Dag's case, but it also seems to me that Dag isn't allowing for flexibility. Again, I don't have enough evidence of motive to have a good opinion on whether it's an error in judgment or a manipulation.
AAF... still think he's as scummy as it comes and unless UN joins the game again, I don't think anything will happen to change it before nightfall.
Labby... is this more along the lines of what you were hoping for from me? :rofl: I can't say that Labby's struck me as particularly evil... yet.
Zaffy... I get that people are busy, and as much as I think he should be kept on the front of the town's collective consciousness, I haven't seen any reason to get out the torches and pitchforks yet.
DD... no clue
FF... lynched early on. left a pile of scum under the gallows.
Chill... I don't really know. I always want to suspect him, but he hasn't yet really raised an eyebrow.
I guess that's about where I'm at for now.
Here's my take on Ice at this point. I don't think Ice is playing square with the town. But, it's Ice. He never plays square with the town. I believe fully he's playing some kind of game, but his games when innocent can benefit the town. I understand the suspicion against him and have gone back and forth on it a few times. But I don't have enough evidence to put a vote there.
Dag... what you said to me (I don't know why you pulled my question post instead of your answer...) was that other than your argument condemning Ice for changing his strategy, your case on him was gut feeling. I can see the basis of Dag's case, but it also seems to me that Dag isn't allowing for flexibility. Again, I don't have enough evidence of motive to have a good opinion on whether it's an error in judgment or a manipulation.
AAF... still think he's as scummy as it comes and unless UN joins the game again, I don't think anything will happen to change it before nightfall.
Labby... is this more along the lines of what you were hoping for from me? :rofl: I can't say that Labby's struck me as particularly evil... yet.
Zaffy... I get that people are busy, and as much as I think he should be kept on the front of the town's collective consciousness, I haven't seen any reason to get out the torches and pitchforks yet.
DD... no clue
FF... lynched early on. left a pile of scum under the gallows.
Chill... I don't really know. I always want to suspect him, but he hasn't yet really raised an eyebrow.
I guess that's about where I'm at for now.
sorry folks no access all day - no way to get caught up right now
hopefully I will get back before night but can't be sure
left last night doubting Ice
I vote to lynch Ice
hopefully I will get back before night but can't be sure
left last night doubting Ice
I vote to lynch Ice
VOTE COUNT
4) AAF – JB(873), JP(903), Ice(926), Zaffy(987),
6) Ice – Dag(884), LG(977), Dunn(982), kashta(997), AAF(1000), Chill(1015),
1) DD – LR(959),
1) Zaffy – Rich(976),
No votes –DD,
Night fall in about 4 1/2 hours. PM's as needed.
4) AAF – JB(873), JP(903), Ice(926), Zaffy(987),
6) Ice – Dag(884), LG(977), Dunn(982), kashta(997), AAF(1000), Chill(1015),
1) DD – LR(959),
1) Zaffy – Rich(976),
No votes –DD,
Night fall in about 4 1/2 hours. PM's as needed.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
thanks Labby, I appreciate that.
thoughts are on Ice and Dag. I know they are going back at each other but the point Dag said about Ice getting nervous kinda nudges my thoughts. My opinion of Ice in these games is that he has never ever been nervous at questioning or voting on him. It's what makes him a vital Mafia player. He knows the rules and plays them accordingly with the strategy of always keeping his cool, no matter what. To say that he got nervous just rings an alarm in my head.
thanks, will check after this post. I wanted to get my thoughts down first. I will respond to it after this. I do want to say that I didn't think I was reacting strongly about anyone and I don't think LBF is a new player. I could have sworn he's been in these games before.
sorry.... I vote to lynch AAF (which may change at this point.)
not sure why this would be notable and not sure why you are calling me a noob. I am far from it in fact.
funny how you actually say anyone is being contradictory and then using that as a voting reason. Kinda like the pot calling the kettle black.
self preservation... like when you voted for an obvious UD for the simple fact that you didn't want to vote anyone.
VOTE COUNT
5) AAF – JB(873), JP(903), Ice(926), Zaffy(987), DD(1019),
6) Ice – Dag(884), LG(977), Dunn(982), kashta(997), AAF(1000), Chill(1015),
1) DD – LR(959),
1) Zaffy – Rich(976),
All have voted. No UD’s.
5) AAF – JB(873), JP(903), Ice(926), Zaffy(987), DD(1019),
6) Ice – Dag(884), LG(977), Dunn(982), kashta(997), AAF(1000), Chill(1015),
1) DD – LR(959),
1) Zaffy – Rich(976),
All have voted. No UD’s.
