Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

[allaboutfish]

bally did you skim the rules? even i knew that was the scums hit. scum are usually the ones that just skim over the rules.

 

[dundadundun]

Ok, now I'm confused (imagine that lol) what are you sorry to here? Then the vote for Pap, because he "pushed" you to vote for the person you thought was evil, I also questioned you on why you wouldn't want to vote the person you felt strongest about...so (not that I want you to vote me) but, why did Pap get your vote instead of me? Since night one you voted someone you didn't actually see has mafia, night two you think someone is mafia but don't want to vote them, are you voting Pap because you do think he is mafia, or more because he annoyed you by questioning you about why you didn't want to place a vote on the person you say you are sure is mafia?


Thanks, that is what I thought you meant...but wanted to be sure.

i believe his push is to put me in the spotlight. it worked well.

That is funny. Jpap forced you to vote for someone you think is scum? Why would need to be forced to vote for your suspect?

I'm happy with my vote as is.

Still would like to see Kashs response to the post of contradiction in which 2 of the 3 people she named as possible votes had reasons posted by her on why she didn't vote them. Its post 180 in case you need the help to look back.

force? not likely. push the issue... yes.
your vote on me is probably the best for you at this time anyway. maybe not likely for your team, though. depends on how many we started out on each team.

 

[dundadundun]

So do you think I'm scum or...?



So you assumed that no one else knew either?

absolutely!

I don't think this will be a surprise but I vote to lynch Dun just to many questionable things going on there with him.

knew that was coming. does bring up the question whether you and pap are both scum outwardly communicating in the thread or whether his logic seems undeniable. i imagine after i'm lynched, the townies are going to have to look long and hard at you two.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Busy day today so not much time to post. After reviewing today's posts I would have to still agree with my suspicions from last night on Dun. He has not done much today to change my mind either. I do think Wiz seems scummy as well but Dun is definitely top of my list. Dun's posts from today as well as Wiz's lack of participation as of late lead me to my vote...I vote to lynch Dun

 

[dirtydawg10]

absolutely!

knew that was coming. does bring up the question whether you and pap are both scum outwardly communicating in the thread or whether his logic seems undeniable. i imagine after i'm lynched, the townies are going to have to look long and hard at you two.

If scum can communicate outside of the thread why would they do it in the thread? And even if they did you think they would do it on purpose?

 

[dundadundun]

If scum can communicate outside of the thread why would they do it in the thread? And even if they did you think they would do it on purpose?

definitely... how else would you lead innocents to lynch their own? plus... those two can pull it off, so why not? if i'm right (which i'm not sure of, but definitely have a suspicion) they're doing a fantastic job of it right now. two townies gone tonight folks... just you watch.

 

[Ballyhoo]

Yeah, not buying it...why would it matter if more was to come? The scum hit is first so had there been a second one it just would have confirmed that DD was the scum hit anyways.

If you read the post of mine you quoted you would see I mentioned Lab's write up which clearly references the scum team...why would you need to check the rule anyways?

And it still doesn't make sense why you singled out Rich when he was just the first one to state pretty much the obvious.

Because I read the post then though "oh hey wtf is the order of events" *clicks to first page of thread and reads order of events* * clicks last page of thread and sees game on post* *thinks "oh that makes sense, then wow Rich got there really quickly"*

The post never said one way or another, it can only be assumed.

 

[Lady G]

absolutely!

knew that was coming. does bring up the question whether you and pap are both scum outwardly communicating in the thread or whether his logic seems undeniable. i imagine after i'm lynched, the townies are going to have to look long and hard at you two.

Dun, Paps "logic" really has nothing to do with my vote, yes he seems to be thinking the same lines as I on your posts, but he has nothing to do with it. The fact you our right said you think FF is scum, but didn't want to vote him unless you HAVE to really started the red flags for me, your posts after did nothing to reassure me, add the nail in the coffin on 2H in there, and the fact you voted UN while seeming to make a case for FF then later saying how you are always the first to jump on people for voting FF, yet you were throwing his name out there kinda like "bait", just to many things are not adding up for me.

Could you please answer me what your thoughts on Kash are at this point? You seem to be basing your thoughts on FF on the fact he is playing different, does Kash seem to be playing the same to you?

 

[dirtydawg10]

definitely... how else would you lead innocents to lynch their own? plus... those two can pull it off, so why not? if i'm right (which i'm not sure of, but definitely have a suspicion) they're doing a fantastic job of it right now. two townies gone tonight folks... just you watch.

Innocents always lynch their own in this game, even without coaxing. Your posts have incriminated yourself more so than anything else I see. I agree JPap and LG are good players which is another reason they would not openly communicate in the thread.

So let's assume you are innocent and correct about JPap and/or LG who else do you see on their team? Who do you see as most likely innocent?

 

[Lady G]

Dun, Paps "logic" really has nothing to do with my vote, yes he seems to be thinking the same lines as I on your posts, but he has nothing to do with it. The fact you our right said you think FF is scum, but didn't want to vote him unless you HAVE to really started the red flags for me, your posts after did nothing to reassure me, add the nail in the coffin on 2H in there, and the fact you voted UN while seeming to make a case for FF then later saying how you are always the first to jump on people for voting FF, yet you were throwing his name out there kinda like "bait", just to many things are not adding up for me.

Could you please answer me what your thoughts on Kash are at this point? You seem to be basing your thoughts on FF on the fact he is playing different, does Kash seem to be playing the same to you?

Our right=OUT right