Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

Fishfriend1 said:
No, but there is a limit... You have posted almost nothing of value this entire game, and that is concerning. Even now, day 3, you have made little imput. Just how busy are you?



I think that UN is playing a well balanced and well thought out game. I dunno, gut feeling more so then anything else, which is why it's not actually a reason to vote her. Those were, I think, in the "idle thought" section of the post, so there isn't anything backing them up except sudden thoughts on it (and sometimes that do prove correct). So, you don't have anything to say about Dawg? Interesting...
Click to expand...

Not sure why I would need to comment on Dawg. I do agree he isn't very talkative so there's nothing wrong with that assessment. I'll take that further and state that I am a little weary about what seems to be his fixation on Wiz. I don't see him (Wiz) as scum at the moment, not to say I think he is innocent. But Dawg's always been hard to read. What I did want to know is how you came to those conclusions on UN and LG.

Your thoughts on me are very flawed. It's also interesting that you try to call me out for placing a gut feel vote on 2H (which is incorrect) and then turn around and say you have a gut feel that UN is playing a good game. But you also think UN is scum...how does that work?

Other than that your list is basically blanket statements about how people are playing. AAF is quiet. Bally has said some weird things, etc. etc. Has nothing recently peaked your interest? What about Kash's posts where you said that you were tempted to vote her? That's a pretty strong statement. But not only is she not on your list but she isn't even mentioned in that post. That's an inconsistency that really sticks out to me...

I honestly can't discern from your "list" if there is anyone you even seriously suspect so...If you had to vote for one person now who would it be?

And just so you don't have to remind me I'd put say my list looks something like this:

Bally
FF
AAF
Kash

I'm sure I've posted reasons at sometime or another but I can summarize if anyone would like...
 
allaboutfish said:
so to help everybody out, and bc im really not going to be able to figure out which of these are scum here is my naughty/ nice list.
ice
rich
kashta
bally
ice turned out to be rudolf so either kash, rich, or bally is definently scum. telling yall this will probably get me hit, but yall townies can do more with it than i can.
i really hope this helps.
Click to expand...

Not really.

You've crossed one off the list and now the scum can cross you off the list for any remaining PR, if you are telling the truth...:wall:
 
Hmmm...it is interesting that FF is acusing others of not being helpful in the game and being quiet. Pot meet kettle.

Everyone pretty much started off quiet in this game. Game play has just started picking up a bit today actually. I'm thinking the time of year has a lot to do with it.
 
allaboutfish said:
what?
Click to expand...

Scum know that you aren't a PR now. When the game can end by killing just one person you made it easier for them because they can cross your name off their list...
 
Lady G said:
Well, that nightfall sucked!
Sorry, Dun...I just couldn't get past the whole not wanted to vote the person you felt mafia unless you HAD to.
Ice, sorry to see you go!


UN, what are you trying to say here? Do you think the evil would vote side by side?


I like how you are trying to make it look like I was the only one questioning him and turn the whole thing on me. Yep, I questioned him ALOT I can't help that I feel not wanting to vote the person you feel the scummiest as a scummy move. As far as "following" Pap around, see it how you want I made all posts and all thoughts on my own regardless of what anyone else said, obviously Pap felt the same as I.


Again, you are trying to make it look as thought I was the only one questioning him..nice diversion there Wizard. I did not spend the morning "hammering" him about his vote switch to save himself, I brought it up YES, I said why it can be looked at as a scum move, others commented what their thoughts were on it and that was that. It wasn't what caused suspicions of him, but yes..it did add to it.
I love when people what to say "this is just what you did when we played evil together" wanting to "plant that seed" in others minds..whatever, I question people and when I think they are scum I continue to question them rather I'm evil or innocent.

Since you brought up my question to Dun about his thoughts on Kash, what are yours at this point?
Click to expand...

I am here and will answer this post in parts. I will start with the easiest and move on to the most time consuming.

How do I feel about Kashta? Kashta hasn't posted enough for me to think one way or another about her role. This is a tough question for me to answer as I have first hand knowledge about how hectic it is here and what is going on. I think I would prefer to defer to Kashta to answer any questions you have for her rather than make answers or excuses for her.
 
jpappy789 said:
Scum know that you aren't a PR now. When the game can end by killing just one person you made it easier for them because they can cross your name off their list...
Click to expand...
oh.... dang it why didnt i think of that!!!!! i was just hoping itd help bc theres no way i can figure out which is scum and which isnt.
 
Wow, not much has happened since I was gone...going to be on and off between getting kids ready for bed and stuff .

Fishfriend1 said:
Okay, I sorta remade my former post, I dunno if I forgot something or not though...

My List of Scum after Rereading:

AAf -Has glided through the game completely.
Pappy - Pappy voted 2H out of a gut feeling. Was this gut feeling that UN was his teammate? (as in, was he just protecting a teammate)
UN - If the above is correct, then UN is evil too.
Bally - She has said some... curious things. Not enough to vote, but enough to perk my interest.

Random Thoughts:

Dawg seems to have been quiet.

LG is playing to townie, it's kinda creepy.

UN has been playing a good game. Whether that makes him evil or good at mafia, IDK.

Love how the mod has more posts then all but 3 players, 1 of whom is dead....


Questions:

Rich, back to day 1, you recreated the 3-way tie between Un, Dun, and 2H. Why was this?

If everyone had to post a scum list right now, who would be on it, why, and in what order?
Click to expand...

FF, I believe Pap had a "reason" for his vote it wasn't a gut thing...I'll have to look back to be completely sure on that but I am pretty sure it was because of 2H saying Rich is unlynchable...which yes, was weak..but for day 1 what can you expect.
So, you have thoughts or a question to everyone except for Kash or Wizard....interesting, do you have no thoughts at all for those two?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom