Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

I vote to lynch Bally

I've suspected her to be scum more than Kash but you better bet that if I'm wrong Kash will be next. I am also fairly confident that FF is scum but we might as well make use of the extra info we have...

Hopefully though we lynch the correct one tonight and end up with two known innocents. I trust AAF at this point, however misguided his actions may have been. I do think I posted what the innocent elf roles were but it would be beyond me why the scum team would attempt to have AAF be the one to false RC.
 
jpappy789 said:
I removed quotes not posted towards me...

I wasn't going to go out of my way to agree with something as trivial (relatively speaking) as Dawg wasn't being very active. It didn't concern me that you said it so I did not comment on it. Simple as that.

The whole "coached" bit is so overused on certain players that it's become an easy way to point suspicion on to someone without needing to grab any posts or do any actual analysis.

No, I never included UN as a player I was going to vote for D1. FF that is a total lie. I was between Dun and 2H and for the bazillionth time I had legitimate reasons for both. The only gut feel was that I just felt 2H's comment was scummier than what Dun did. How is that scummy? Should we examine your D1 vote?

So you didn't want to restate your thoughts on Kash? Do you actually think she is scum or not? I don't understand how you can make an actual list but then leave someone out who earlier you said you could vote for on the spot...

I'm not saying you need to know someone is scum. But other than your supposed case on me your only other suspicions are general statements about game play. Concrete evidence would be some actual posts.

I can't really analyze a vote thrown out there to avoid UD. I'm more interested in how she came about her D1 vote and what she said when questioned.

What's your point FF? I picked 2H because I felt he was scummier than Dun...should I not be voting for who I think is scummiest?
Click to expand...

Well, in other games choosing to ignore a thought about one person while saying stuff about others could show a link between two players.

Well, the coached argument always seems to be valid against me, so why can't I use it myself?

Feel free to examine my day 1 vote. If I recall, I voted UN because he's UN and needed a vote. And because I wasn't gonna be very active that day.

No, but if you and UN were evil your motivation for "scummy" may have been a little biased.

Now, I work from 5 to 9 tonight, so I won't be back by nightfall. As you said, all I currently have a my general statements, my "case" against you, and that diddy with Kashta. Since I don't think Bally is evil, and my "case" against you isn't very good, I vote to lynch Kashta, as she has been more focused on defending herself then any other aspect of the game as far as I see it. I may or may not be back again, I need to get ready for work and catch the bus.
 
i vote to lynch bally for causing confusion and changing her story so much. this is subject to change if i see anything else from kash.
 
Fishfriend1 said:
Well, in other games choosing to ignore a thought about one person while saying stuff about others could show a link between two players.

Well, the coached argument always seems to be valid against me, so why can't I use it myself?

Feel free to examine my day 1 vote. If I recall, I voted UN because he's UN and needed a vote. And because I wasn't gonna be very active that day.

No, but if you and UN were evil your motivation for "scummy" may have been a little biased.

Now, I work from 5 to 9 tonight, so I won't be back by nightfall. As you said, all I currently have a my general statements, my "case" against you, and that diddy with Kashta. Since I don't think Bally is evil, and my "case" against you isn't very good, I vote to lynch Kashta, as she has been more focused on defending herself then any other aspect of the game as far as I see it. I may or may not be back again, I need to get ready for work and catch the bus.
Click to expand...

And you chose to ignore Wiz and Kash in your post. What does that have to say?

Your suspicion of me is all circumstantial. You're assuming I picked 2H over Dun because I wanted to protect UN. I knew Kash had tied it up but that was irrelevant. I picked out the two things that were scummy, and mind you those were suspicions that had more basis than most votes thrown out there. It was between 2H and Dun...UN had nothing to do with it...just because I happened to tie it up between him and 2H means nothing.

Interesting that you are jumping to Kash now when she didn't even make your scum list before. Did you decide she was worth letting go when AAF posted the list?
 
We know there are at least 2 evil right....so if we mess up and take a innocent tonight and they use their hit, we HAVE to get a evil next nightfall or we are screwed!! Especially, since we have no idea if Jack guessed right...why oh why did you have to use your shot already Jack :cry:

AFF, are you saying if Kash posts again she get's your vote?
 
jpappy789 said:
And you chose to ignore Wiz and Kash in your post. What does that have to say?

Your suspicion of me is all circumstantial. You're assuming I picked 2H over Dun because I wanted to protect UN. I knew Kash had tied it up but that was irrelevant. I picked out the two things that were scummy, and mind you those were suspicions that had more basis than most votes thrown out there. It was between 2H and Dun...UN had nothing to do with it...just because I happened to tie it up between him and 2H means nothing.

Interesting that you are jumping to Kash now when she didn't even make your scum list before. Did you decide she was worth letting go when AAF posted the list?
Click to expand...

Pap, if you really believe this (that FF is "letting a team mate go") why is your vote on Bally?
 
I believe that Lg and Pap are scum. I will not be on until after nightfall, so until then... I vote to lynch LG
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom