Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

Enjoy your holidays everyone! I also won't be back again till the thread re-opens on monday, so cya then!
 
On night 2 I sent my pm in right before nightfall after I had voted. So yes when I sent the pm in I believed him to be evil.
I was talking about when you voted Pap to avoid a UD, not night two. Although, the fact you voted him when you thought you would be changing him to innocent is kinda odd to me? If you were just going to vote the person you nipped, didn't that kinda waste the nip if they did get lynched, how exactly would that work...they would be lynched and shown to be what ever they were, then be turned after they were dead???

Anyway...hope everyone has a wonderful (scum free) Christmas!!!
:hearts:
 
Hope everyone had a Merry Christmas! I'm not going to be around much today either. I'm going to visit my 96yr old Grandmother today. I should be on before nightfall though.

I wish I had more time but just in case I vote to lynch FF. His game seems off this time around. I don't know if it's because he is changing his game as he says or if he's scum trying to lay low and not get lynched. I'm guessing the latter. He is my gut vote right now and my non-UD vote for now just in case I'm not back. I am planning to be back but plans don't always work out.
 
Final vote count:
UN (0)- Ice (#162)
Dun (6)- FF (#176), Ice (#238), UN (#280), LG (#300), Dawg (#304), Pappy (#321)
FF (0) - Dun (#223)
Bally (3) - Wiz (#232), Rich (#240), AAF (#243)
Pappy (2) - Dun (#285), Bally (#375)
AAF (1) - Kash (#368)

Everyone has voted.
I was talking about when you voted Pap to avoid a UD, not night two. Although, the fact you voted him when you thought you would be changing him to innocent is kinda odd to me? If you were just going to vote the person you nipped, didn't that kinda waste the nip if they did get lynched, how exactly would that work...they would be lynched and shown to be what ever they were, then be turned after they were dead???

Anyway...hope everyone has a wonderful (scum free) Christmas!!!
:hearts:

You seem to be answering your question in asking me. I ONLY voted pap to avoid a UD, last nightfall.
On night 2 I sent in the pm minutes before nightfall, not before I voted him. Also as you can see, Pap had votes on D2 but was not up for the lynch.
 
Hope everyone had a Merry Christmas! I'm not going to be around much today either. I'm going to visit my 96yr old Grandmother today. I should be on before nightfall though.

I wish I had more time but just in case I vote to lynch FF. His game seems off this time around. I don't know if it's because he is changing his game as he says or if he's scum trying to lay low and not get lynched. I'm guessing the latter. He is my gut vote right now and my non-UD vote for now just in case I'm not back. I am planning to be back but plans don't always work out.

I love how whenever I play well I get lynched for it, but when I play crappy I also get lynched for it :) I can understand thinking my game play is different, it is, and I intend it to remain that way. Everyone needs to get past their newb days eventually, and I'm really hoping this is the part where I manage that. However, I can assure you, I am innocent. Now. for when you get back, I am you GUT vote... even after everything that has happened in the game so far, you're voting based on your gut?

You seem to be answering your question in asking me. I ONLY voted pap to avoid a UD, last nightfall.
On night 2 I sent in the pm minutes before nightfall, not before I voted him. Also as you can see, Pap had votes on D2 but was not up for the lynch.

So, lemmi get ur timing here. You voted him, which means you thought he was evil. Then you decided, seeing he wasn't going to be lynched, to nip him as well? I can actually see how that would work in ur mind. Either way, one less evil if your right(evil lynched/evil nipped), one less townie if ur wrong (a townie lynched/a townie nipped). Looking at it, it makes perfect sense.
 
You seem to be answering your question in asking me. I ONLY voted pap to avoid a UD, last nightfall.
On night 2 I sent in the pm minutes before nightfall, not before I voted him. Also as you can see, Pap had votes on D2 but was not up for the lynch.
OK, Bally I'm not going to keep this going here it will only cause a distraction which we do not need that this time. It is something for me to keep thinking about though. Yes, Pap only had a couple votes on D2, and I can see if you really thought him to be evil using your nip on him at that time. I also realize your vote to Pap N3 was to avoid UD...but I don't get why you would pick someone that in your mind at that time should of ben innocent.
 
Well, for now and to avoid UD tonight (goin to Philly for the day) I vote to lynch DirtyDawg. Mostly OMGUS, but he does have a strange feel about him. I don't trust him in the least.
 
Well, I have to say...if we are going to believe Bally at this point, and I am willing to right now because she really has given us no reason not to and without someone else coming out and saying they were actually Jack (which I do NOT want them to) I would say Pap is evil right now. I say this because I do not think Pap was evil in the beginning of the game. He has done nothing to cause anyone to look at him (which he does easily when evil) and his vote for Kash really does nothing to make me feel better about him, simply because I know he will vote (as would anyone) a team mate if he needs to. IF Bally is telling the truth she is obviously innocent and could not of been a nip victim, so for him to pick her over Kash would of been silly as she would of shown innocent putting him yet again on a innocent (for the third nightfall in a row). So for this reason I am really thinking Pap is evil.

I vote to lynch Pap
 
AquariaCentral.com