the copy paste thing. it still doesnt clear him bc that could be just an explenation he knew would get people off of him. hes definently still my biggest suspect.
Mafia 103...the play
- Thread starter Lady G
- Start date
the copy paste thing. it still doesnt clear him bc that could be just an explenation he knew would get people off of him. hes definently still my biggest suspect.
I'm not sure I would agree that every vote of yours has been a gut feel RB, you were a more investigative player back in earlier games. That being said, it still doesn't make me any more comfortable for you to admit that you are going to be voting that way. It's a nice plan for mafia since it gives them an excuse to not spend time digging for a reason to vote.
Not sure I understand how that post of Lab's was a WIFOM post. RL aside though it did seem strange she posted that and disappeared...especially considering how much activity has resulted from Neph's responses.
Men's tennis. Love the sport and might as well assume I could be on the ATP tour as well, which would be sweet!
I don't like how AAF latched on to Neph so quickly with a vote...especially since using the term "screams scum" is such a strong way to categorize someone at this stage in the game. There are also a couple subsequent posts of his that are alarming because of how hard he is pressing Neph.
When was Lab in the spotlight though? Obviously she wouldn't work to put herself there...
Realistically, out of all the things that happened on D1 how could you not rate your last minute random vote as one of the scummiest things? Yes, it may not have been such a big deal in the grand scheme of the game, but considering your reaction and OMGUS-like vote on Lab it doesn't exactly look great for you...
I also am not comfortable with you basing Lab's entire game play on one game...especially when the dynamics are drastically different. Most vet players are so good because they don't change styles from game to game, and they play that way regardless of their role.
Sorry, I worked this afternoon/evening. It was my last full day though (I have to go in tomorrow morning for a few hours) so I will be around more consistently now.
This pretty much puts you to the top of my list AAF...I don't like extreme backtracking.
i wouldnt call that extreme backtracking. i said less sure not im totaly not sure about him anymore.
cool that you like tennis. i actually play on my high school team.
You said that Neph's late vote "screams scum" but your reason for not being as sure is because he explained away his copy/paste post issue. It seems to me that regardless of whether or not Neph did get that post from the scum den that you should be pretty sure that he is scum because of his late vote.
Up until post #165 you were still grilling Neph and then a couple people point out how hard you are pressing for Neph and you take a noticeable step back. Pretty extreme IMO given the circumstances.
i dont think i was "drilling" him. i dont drill. i push maybe but i dont drill.
You're starting to get into semantics here...either way, the backtracking was noticeable.
she wasn't. I just think she's good at saying something that makes others wonder. Even better if she's on a team the way her post didn't seem like too big a deal and then how I ended up really getting questioned it started to seem a little suspicious
Yeah it came together too well for me to feel like it was just a knee jerk OMGUS vote, especially since it's as early as it is in the game.
And yeah, you're right. After my posts I really did try to step up and say that I may be way off base specifically because I've only played one game. I guess we shall see.
On another note I wonder if the doc or investigator are good enough to act on the info they're given without giving themselves away. I like the semi complicated setup of this game (as opposed to the zero communication of the last game). Knowing there are people plotting against me outside the game makes it that much more interesting.
Ha I just realized I actually did type that sentence correctly so this post wasn't needed. You get my point though.
Sorry I missed some of the most active hours. Was one of those long days today (yeah you know those). The weekend is here though and it seems pap is outta work. I'm interested in seeing more of you pap. You always blindside with your reasoning. Always very well done
It should be slightly concerning if it is "coming together" this early in the game. You will end up being wrong more times than not...
Don't take this as me saying you shouldn't come up with theories though because you should. The problem is that you seem almost too sure when it comes to Lab and you're basing this off of playing one game with her. She's a crafty player, no doubt, as evidenced by last game...but you have focused a lot of time explaining why you think she is scum (fairly understandable with all the defensive posts) and mentioned only a few names in passing as to who you think her teammates might be. I would hope that you intend to branch out a bit more on your suspicions if they are well placed.
I will certainly have more time to be around, but it is still the weekend so don't expect that I will be here a whole lot more the next couple of days. I'm not sure exactly what you are getting at though with your description of my gameplay there...thanks?
