Mafia 104 - Dawg the Bounty Hunter - The Play

[jpappy789]

the pir/kash thing seemed like it was more on a personal level then a game thing to me. not sure how to take it and it's already done and over with. wish there was more to go on with that.

the whole "thank you" situation made me want to think there was a scum alliance or PR involvement, but with pir gone that seems less likely since he turned up innocent. although i might want to keep an eye on jp and chill. not sure yet.

as for the whole random thing with rich... i can see wanting to out rich early if he is indeed scum. he has a tendency of sticking around till the end and almost coming out of the woodwork to be a power player in the final stages. as for seeing a D1 vote as anything but random... idk about that one.

but to clear things up about how random things can be... i vote to lynch the whomever posts the very next post after this one.

Please explain how me saying "Thanks" is an indication of me and Chill communicating within the thread and why Pir flipping innocent had any involvement.

While I agree that the list of who I would not turn would be much shorter than who I would turn. For me exclusion with this list of players would be based soley on a player's propensity to UD. Voting a player based on this would be scummy and lazy. Naming suspects this way though I don't have a problem with. I'll comment more after I quote Kash.

I know you don't like speculation Kash. I also know it's a fundmentall differnce between us that causes me to suspect you at times. This is the worse kind of speculation in that almost everybody's list would be slightly differnt.

I don't believe you really think this list of players need pointers or would even take pointers from the town. I also don't like that you shut it down as those lists could have been useful when one of the list makers rolled scum.

Personally, I'm not so worried about scum looking at lists because they're going to do what they think is best for their team...but that's why I think the lists are a dead end. Even if one of those people flip scum there are enough people in this game to create a list of innocents. Should we lynch our way through that list in case they maybe put a teammate on there? I could possibly be something to consider if it comes down to choosing between two players and one is more turn-worthy than the other.

By naming those people as your suspects you are creating a bias in your thinking, and if those people all happen to be innocent then you are hurting the town.

The thread started to get rolling then AAF derails it with a conversation about "ennie meanie minie mo" and who says it correctly, doesn't 'seem very progressive.


DD points out that FF isn't around, seemed to me to be a subtle way to draw attention to FF.




It's hard to say how i feel about this, either you are just a new player ( I don't remember if this is your second or third game ) or if you are new scum trying to deflect what you did possibly slip up on.





Zaffy was defending Pir not Neph.



Thank you :
The whole thank you think kinda sticks with me, it could have been D1 humor/sarcasm or it could be some sort of alliance. I’m not sure there are any players that would let roles slip by a simple statement like that, but on the other hand there are players bold enough to do it.

Rich and the Randoms (kinda sounds like a band name huh?)
Rich is a silent force in the beginnings of the games then making himself known as a very strong player the last few days of the game, to which he is very good at making.
Zaffy pointed out that Rich’s vote wasn’t random as he stated, Zaffy then posted a reasoned vote. It appeared he tried to make a mountain out of a molehill, but it’s Zaffy, who ever know with that guy...Rich is a good player that I can see the scum wanting out of their way.

I'd like to know why, after everything that has been discussed, the "Thanks" still sticks out to you. Talk about making a mountain out of a molehill...

 

[jpappy789]

Be careful. Last time I did a copy/paste I was ripped to shreds. I wonder if anyone will draw the same conclusion about your copy/paste that they did from mine.

My current line of thinking is that there are some mountains here that are really molehills. Most of the connections being made (or even spitballed) aren't really sticking with me. We'll see how it plays out.

Are there any connections being made then that are really sticking with you?

 

[Nepherael]

Are there any connections being made then that are really sticking with you?

Eh nothing very big. There's little things here and there but most of the players in this game are master manipulators. I can't be sure yet. I'll do some rereading and maybe I'll be able to do a multi quote and show you guys any lines I'm drawing.

 

[jpappy789]

my random vote is subject to future changes at my discretion.

Dun, as Zaffy said your vote isn't random...but what was the point of trying to place a random vote anyways?

 

[dundadundun]

Please explain how me saying "Thanks" is an indication of me and Chill communicating within the thread and why Pir flipping innocent had any involvement.

you're a good player. it might mean something, it might be irrelevant. however, if i had an explanation worth regurgitating at this time, rest assured i'd be "positive" you were scum and i'd have voted for you by now.

P.S. this as far as i've read through so far. i'm catching up again.

 

[dundadundun]

Dun, as Zaffy said your vote isn't random...but what was the point of trying to place a random vote anyways?

well so much for the "disclaimer". looks like it didn't take long to read through everything.

i've been pretty busy and distracted lately. thought my time would have cleared up better before the game, but it did not. plus the kids just started back at school. daughters in kindergarten so everything's new to her and she's having her adjustment period.

so essentially, i have no idea when my time will be monopolized. hence the "random" vote. if i had a solid line on someone that i thought was solid my vote would not be so "random".

 

[Rbishop]

my head hurts..going to take another read to even see anything that makes sense to me..still early in the game with this many players. Hate to see pir go, but he did seem to be off on the personal tangent..just my opinion.

 

[allaboutfish]

Did you do the turning?


The fact that the game seemed to take a more serious, intense turn, then AAF wanders in talking about eenie, meenie, miney moe to choose a vote. It's like he didn't even bother to read the thread. Why wouldn't he read the thread if he is trying to help the town?

where did i say i didnt read the thread? i personally thought it was too early to tell if kash or pir were innocent or scum. ive seen kash do that kind of kicking the bush before and i havent played many games with pir so i dont know his normal game play.

The thread started to get rolling then AAF derails it with a conversation about "ennie meanie minie mo" and who says it correctly, doesn't 'seem very progressive.


DD points out that FF isn't around, seemed to me to be a subtle way to draw attention to FF.




It's hard to say how i feel about this, either you are just a new player ( I don't remember if this is your second or third game ) or if you are new scum trying to deflect what you did possibly slip up on.





Zaffy was defending Pir not Neph.



Thank you :
The whole thank you think kinda sticks with me, it could have been D1 humor/sarcasm or it could be some sort of alliance. I’m not sure there are any players that would let roles slip by a simple statement like that, but on the other hand there are players bold enough to do it.

Rich and the Randoms (kinda sounds like a band name huh?)
Rich is a silent force in the beginnings of the games then making himself known as a very strong player the last few days of the game, to which he is very good at making.
Zaffy pointed out that Rich’s vote wasn’t random as he stated, Zaffy then posted a reasoned vote. It appeared he tried to make a mountain out of a molehill, but it’s Zaffy, who ever know with that guy...Rich is a good player that I can see the scum wanting out of their way.

how would me saying that my vote was from eenie meanie minie mow derail the thread? if that were true wouldnt any other vote that was random derail the thread?

 

[Kashta]

Hate this phone. Surprised no one has asked yet... Dun, if you got back in time yesterday, where would you have voted?


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

 

[Rbishop]

good question kash