Mafia 107 - Tank of Terror!

[plantling]

In response to Jpappy's post about nightfall, I've decided that votes will freeze at 8pm. I may not be able to hold nightfall until the next day though, I work late tonight.

Vote Count:

Dawg(1) - Neph(142)
Plantling(1) - Ice(149)
Neph(2) - Rich(150), Dawg(158)
Rich(2) - Pappy(157), Plantling(160)

Not yet voted:
None

too late

 

[IceH2O]

I have Plant/Rich tied

Dawg - Neph
Plant- Ice, JP
Neph- Rich
Rich- Plant, Dawg

 

[dirtydawg10]

Yup...me too

 

[dirtydawg10]

My point is that voting Rich doesn't prove anything even if he is scum. I don't think Plant gets it either.

If plant flips scum we know that Ice is telling the truth.

If Ice flips scum we know that Plant is telling the truth AND Rich is scum.

If Rich flips scum we know nothing tomorrow. Plant could just as well be Rich's teammate as could Ice.

IF YOU THINK ICE IS LYING THEN VOTING HIM WOULD BE IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE TOWN

If Rich is the Convict Ice is scum. If Plant was scum I don't think she would give up the convict and lose the hits. The scum need hits to win this game now.

 

[jpappy789]

Great...

 

[IceH2O]

Well if I survive the hit, the invest is on Neph.

 

[rich311k]

Interesting, I am not the convict so I guess Plant is a lying scum fish.

 

[dirtydawg10]

It's all over but the waiting...I'm out for now.

 

[plantling]

Interesting, I am not the convict so I guess Plant is a lying scum fish.

Scummy SCUM

 

[jpappy789]

If Rich is the Convict Ice is scum. If Plant was scum I don't think she would give up the convict and lose the hits. The scum need hits to win this game now.

The problem is you based you vote off of Plant being correct. If you two had voted Ice I would have been WAY more inclined to believe Plant/you because at least that plan absolutely guarantees getting both scum. Yes, someone would have been hit tonight but we would still be playing and the last scum (Rich) would have been unanimously voted by the remaining innocents tomorrow.

The scum can survive without hits, it's not easy, but not impossible. If Plant was telling the truth she should/would have told us to vote for Ice, all but proving she is the Cory, and then have us vote Rich tomorrow to guarantee the win. All we needed was a scum gone tonight, we did NOT need to get of the convict.