Sand?

Astramorgaine

AC Members
Feb 6, 2007
218
0
0
Southern Indiana
I have a 20 gal high that I'm going to set up soon,(have to get a hood and filter) and I'm still not decided on a freshwater or marine set up... I was curious if I make a fish only tank, is play sand and gravel a wise choice for saltwater? If not, what would be the best substrate for a fish only saltwater set up?
 
You have such a small footprint that I would suggest paying for marine sand. It is relatively inexpencive and will do much better for you.
 
do NOT use play sand!!
there are only a few types that are really safe for a saltwater tank such as oldcastle and southdown. yardright too. but they are still not the best as far as buffering goes like an argonite sand. most play sands are not actualy sand at all, but it is just mined. therefore, they contain all sorts of other minerals that you do not want in your tank such as silicates, phosphates, and even some heavy metals.
i also would not recomend gravel or crushed coral because it is really easy for debris to be trapped in it. even if you were to vaccum constantly, unlike a simple freshwater tank, a marine tank contains much more rock on top of the substrate (generaly) so you would only be able to vaccume a small portion anyways.
 
do NOT use play sand!!
there are only a few types that are really safe for a saltwater tank such as oldcastle and southdown. yardright too. but they are still not the best as far as buffering goes like an argonite sand. most play sands are not actualy sand at all, but it is just mined. therefore, they contain all sorts of other minerals that you do not want in your tank such as silicates, phosphates, and even some heavy metals.
i also would not recomend gravel or crushed coral because it is really easy for debris to be trapped in it. even if you were to vaccum constantly, unlike a simple freshwater tank, a marine tank contains much more rock on top of the substrate (generaly) so you would only be able to vaccume a small portion anyways.

yes yes and yes!
 
yea the bacteria which makes it live can only benifit you. its what eats up the fish poop and waste products and converts it to safe biproducts.
Ok, I think I get it now! I was under the impression you could only use live sand in a reef set up... Boy, do I have some homework to do!
 
AquariaCentral.com