Mafia Game #4 The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
See my last post. I'm exploring just like you guys are. It's called phishing. It looks like I've gotten a bite or two.
Ogre and Ice are high on my mafia list.
DD and NJ I was just using you two as bait. No hard feelings I hope.
Vote change: Lynch Ice Remove vote for CL
Ogre and Ice are high on my mafia list.
DD and NJ I was just using you two as bait. No hard feelings I hope.
Vote change: Lynch Ice Remove vote for CL
Last edited:
Some people have changed their votes. Rb has asked if retracting a vote to post it in bold along with your new vote.
Nola, I'm keeping my vote the same because I'm pretty sure CL is mafia. But you do make a great argument to put you up for the next vote.
Nola, I'm keeping my vote the same because I'm pretty sure CL is mafia. But you do make a great argument to put you up for the next vote.
I vote to lynch Cory Lover
All the posts talk about being "innocent" no actual logic at all. A red flag for me. Should have known that it would look suspicious.
All the posts talk about being "innocent" no actual logic at all. A red flag for me. Should have known that it would look suspicious.
I can't really try to defend myself other than what I said earlier that I've never had a run in with Jon Q. Law. Despite my surly appearance I'm just a big kid. You know what they say, "The only difference between men and boys is the size of their toys."
Do you really think I was trying to expose the mayor? If you look at it, I first say I'm suspect of Ogre then throw a line to see if he'll bite which he did. Why else would he jump up and vote to lynch me? He knows I'm on to him and he wants to get rid of me before people catch on.
Vote change: Lynch Ogre Remove vote for Ice
Do you really think I was trying to expose the mayor? If you look at it, I first say I'm suspect of Ogre then throw a line to see if he'll bite which he did. Why else would he jump up and vote to lynch me? He knows I'm on to him and he wants to get rid of me before people catch on.
Vote change: Lynch Ogre Remove vote for Ice
A couple of folks have also pointed out similar suspicions. Unfortunately, my 2 year-old daughter has strep throat at the moment, which has been taking quite a bit of our time.
Alot of posts here.....not close to voting for anyone, yet. I like some people's ideas (Ogre re: JudgeMax). One thing that got my attention was that NeonJ tossed her vote back at JudgeMax to 'cancel out JudgeMax's vote.' Any time someone tosses a 'get even' vote back at someone, it gets my attention......NJ tossing a vote at JMax doesn't cancel anything, Julie still has a lynch vote against her. So, when someone casts a 'get even' vote for no real reason, it tells me that they probably don't care who gets lynched ( just as long as they're an innocent). Definitely plays into the mafia's hands which makes it an anti-town move in my book. Not saying that Julie is mafia, maybe making an anti-town move, though.
My top 3 list is
Ice and Z tied for 1...because of the bantering back and forth to try and make them seem like they are pointing the finger at each other...(done in game 3 between 2 Mafia)
NolaPete for 2....having a conversation with NJ and calling her nosy...hhhmm
and GGF...acting the same way in all the other games....hhhmmm
major RED flags for all 4....but Ice and Z are on my main radar screen for sure hit Mafia....
I VOTE FOR ICE...:lipssealedsmilie: and if I am wrong and he isn't Mafia and he is lynched then I will hang my head in shame...and plant lots of flowers for him outside my Pastry Shop and name a new Pastry sandwich after him...
Ice and Z tied for 1...because of the bantering back and forth to try and make them seem like they are pointing the finger at each other...(done in game 3 between 2 Mafia)
NolaPete for 2....having a conversation with NJ and calling her nosy...hhhmm
and GGF...acting the same way in all the other games....hhhmmm
major RED flags for all 4....but Ice and Z are on my main radar screen for sure hit Mafia....
I VOTE FOR ICE...:lipssealedsmilie: and if I am wrong and he isn't Mafia and he is lynched then I will hang my head in shame...and plant lots of flowers for him outside my Pastry Shop and name a new Pastry sandwich after him...
Not following your logic here.....interesting that in the first quote listed you mention that you're sticking with your Cory Lover vote. Pretty funny that when fingered, though, you're jumping all over on the vote (ie, CL to Ice to Ogre).
As far as your little 'trap' for Ogre, maybe you could explain it for us... You call him 'maybe mayor'....he bites (according to you), and then you're hauling in mafia. IMO, you're very recent behavior (especially your panicky looking 'get even' voting) makes you my strongest candidate for mafia also.
Hello did not know we started the game. (you guy type to much) Anywho.
I am not going to start "late" in the game but I have had this one person in mind as to who stood out for being "innocent"(or wants to be now..) along with another person who complained about being innocent one too many times in the past. Not pointing names or jumping on badwagons or nothing crazy but if you can read between the lines you can figure out who my 2 suspects are. I have valid reasoning as well when I do cast my final vote.
Orge I can relate, I have a 3 week old who loves to be rocked in the computer chair thus making it hard to type with one hand I got lucky now as he is with his mother
I am not going to start "late" in the game but I have had this one person in mind as to who stood out for being "innocent"(or wants to be now..) along with another person who complained about being innocent one too many times in the past. Not pointing names or jumping on badwagons or nothing crazy but if you can read between the lines you can figure out who my 2 suspects are. I have valid reasoning as well when I do cast my final vote.
Orge I can relate, I have a 3 week old who loves to be rocked in the computer chair thus making it hard to type with one hand I got lucky now as he is with his mother
