MAFIA #5 The Play.....

you really only mentioned 3.... the bottom ones are junk.
 
jo, your just digging yourself a hole!and :eek3: calling us junk...lol
 
I don't know how reliable it is to base suspicions on previous games played. One of the great things about this game is that it gives people a chance to learn and grow, in terms of creating personas and analyzing information. I think that anyone who played a role before this will have learned what worked, and what didn't for all the roles. Not changing/adapting learning, and thus, modifying gameplay would be silly. Now, I'm not saying that it is completely irrelevnat, but I truly feel that it is not the be all, end all of analysis. Just something to keep in mind. :) ~brandy
 
I'm going to agree with Coler on his list for the most part, top 3 look good to me and have also perked my mafia meter.

I'm not willing to take a chance on Joander just being a newbie.I think it was a major mistake on their part as it was with Cory Lover.

I vote to lynch Joander

Subject to change of course but unless someone shows something more it stands.
 
sigh... your all making a mistake...
 
little bit more, from what I can tell :

Zsandman - nothing to go on yet

DD - 2 posts :

This one, kinda fair enough :

Dangerdoll said:
I think out of those who have posted so far, my alert goes right to Coler and Joander. Jo for being so..... wacky posting, and coler, why the claim of innocence so soon and why the conversation of Jo's vote.... I dunno.... the whole thing looks fishy.
Click to expand...

I'm not crazy about this post though - throwing out a hook, Malbri's comment is very innocuous...would be really bad mafia play to start defending me, when there is no real case made out :

Malbri says "coler is strange doesn't mean he's mafia" DD says :

Dangerdoll said:
hmmm.... why not.... do you know something we don't know, Mal?
Click to expand...

Clownlover : lot of posts, I'm not crazy with the few suggestions that assignments of positions last game are anything to go by. But to try and persuade people of your list based on this would also be fairly bad mafia play.

Ice -posting away...nothing to go on yet...I know I made his list too - fair enough.
 
Coler said:
little bit more, from what I can tell :

Zsandman - nothing to go on yet

DD - 2 posts :

This one, kinda fair enough :



I'm not crazy about this post though - throwing out a hook, Malbri's comment is very innocuous...would be really bad mafia play to start defending me, when there is no real case made out :

Malbri says "coler is strange doesn't mean he's mafia" DD says :



Clownlover : lot of posts, I'm not crazy with the few suggestions that assignments of positions last game are anything to go by. But to try and persuade people of your list based on this would also be fairly bad mafia play.very true...

Ice -posting away...nothing to go on yet...I know I made his list too - fair enough.
Click to expand...

:grinyes:
 
Coler said:
joander123...piece of advice...show us the mafia, we'll vote for them.
Click to expand...

sorry, i had to, this is just way to funny!
 
finally, Ogre - posting a lot, saying pretty much nothing. No conclusions here yet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom