MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[joander123]

it might work like that, if i was a mafia.....

 

[jpappy789]

I agree judge! I am anxious to see your list for this game! I hope it will cause some controversy like last game.

 

[judgemax]

are you telling me to jump head first in front of a moving bus this game?..lmao..I will try and keep things interesting from my pov, however, I would hope that rb would have shared the(magic) information, to make the mafia a little more challenging at this point...lol, it was fun to try and defend what I believed wholeheartedly to be the truth, esp, without giving up how,. This is also why, i like the idea of the pms from RB, about mystery statements, .. def be fun, ..to try and make up reasons..!

 

[jpappy789]

I really want to know how you did it. Although its hard to trust what people say this game, like you said, with the whole random post thing.

My top 3
1. Joander123-the CL of Mafia 5
2. Coler- mostly beacuse of weird post at the beginning
3. Nobody

 

[clown-lover]

i like the idea of the pms from RB, about mystery statements, .. def be fun, ..to try and make up reasons..!

Man I had completely forgotten about that...

 

[judgemax]

I will have to admit, thats the first thing that caught my attention, ..lol, you can't tell what hes going to make anyone say..can't wait at the end of the game to find out whats "true" and what he has made some one say!

I CAN NOT GET OVER HOW FAST THIS HAS STARTED, GOOD SIGN!

 

[Coler]

Some analysis :

Sploke :

Sweeeeeeet I can actually post this time around, instead of just watching them. Hey, there's only 4 of them now, this should only take what, 2 nights? And for what its worth (probably not too much at this point) I am also an innocent.

Something didn't ring true for me here but that's just high paranoia up to a point

Ok, time for some analysis. But holy paranoia, batman.

First off, I agree that Jo's posting patterns are erratic and nonsensical at best. However, I was at least partially responsible in getting him to sign up, and it was kind of a "hey its fun, try it out and you'll figure it out along the way" kind of thing. Now, I realize that if it seems like I'm protecting him now and hes mafia, then I'm digging myself a hole, but I just wanted to throw it out there as a line of thought.

JM's posting patterns seem relatively different form how she started the game last time, but it may be a schedule thing like she said. Although, there were several times I noticed she would state that she would be gone/busy/inactive for periods yet keep posting throughout those times if attacked. I don't know if that means anything right now.

On one hand I want to vote just to prove that I'm as willing to take a wild guess as anyone else. However, if I vote for an innocent, will I look like mafia? If I wait and vote after everyone else, will I look like mafia trying to blend in? If I jump on a train with everyone else, does that make me look guilty? I'm not going to cast a vote right now just for the sake of having a vote out there. I want to read some more posts before even thinking about making a decision. Its about time for water changes..right after some character development

Defence of Joanders, attack on judgemax, no suggestion of a vote

At dusk in ACville, the sun is still hot from the day, and dust blows on the wind through the quiet town. In the distance, a long shadow approaches the town square; a new face. A black horse, dusty and sweaty, slowly carries its rider, who appears practically asleep from the day's ride but is ever wary of his surroundings. Two things are immediately evident about this newcomer, to the neighbors who peer through their blinds: His slow, deliberate motions that indicate many day spent in saddle, and the .45 strapped to the cowboy's belt. He walks his horse to the front grass of a newly purchased house, drops the reins to let him graze for a bit, and wearily lays down under the shade of a tree and drops off to sleep, thinking about the many eyes watching him from behind shrouded windows.

Now the role playing

Conclusion : inconsistent

Joander :

haha this game is really confusing me already !!??

Classic newbie mafia player type of quote, as is this one :

maybe im a mafia!

as is this one (yes you can btw I did, as a way of seeing who would jump on it)

can i vote to lynch myself haha?

which you did (jump on it)

no, i say we get rid of that coler guy... lol who just jumps out and is like IM INNOCENT! <<< NO YOUR NOT YOU LIAR!

and again here (quoting my first post you said, hanging it out there) :

seems fishy... anyone else?

Then you also have a little tickle at judge, who has also voted for you

lol im a he 8).

Now, i may be wrong, but judgemax as the first one to cast a REAL vote, doesnt that make him suspicious himself?

and plus, where did i claim mafia in that post?

Finally you vote for me

my idea is still coler, why would he vote for himself, he has to know that voting for himself gives him a disadvantage, and he probably thinks when others see that, they wont vote for him as well.

I Vote Coler


!!!!!!!!

Conclusion : either bad mafia, or just new to the game. Lot of panicky defences in there as well

Jpappy :

This post rang my mafia bell. When I was mafia I was too darn lazy to read the thread. I find townies more likely to parse the information :

Would it be effective to have a limit to how many posts per person each "day?" I mean look at last game. So many posts were either completely unrelated to the game, people going on huge rants about nothing (*cough* neon julie *cough*), and then people taking things waaay to personally. It might take away from the game. Less to analyze but still we already have 13 pages! People don't want to read all that! Simple lists of suspicions and why is sufficent and then when the time comes a post about who you want to vote for. I don't know it's just an idea...

And you ran away from it pretty quickly when that was pointed out :

Haha, wow did I post that?! Dumb idea:wall:

When joander voted for me, saying my wierd post at the start was the reason :

I think it was a joke. That can't seriously be your reason to vote for him.

And yet coler makes the list according to jpappy

I really want to know how you did it. Although its hard to trust what people say this game, like you said, with the whole random post thing.

My top 3
1. Joander123-the CL of Mafia 5
2. Coler- mostly beacuse of weird post at the beginning
3. Nobody

Conclusion : a little bit dodgy

Ice : can't detect anything suspicious beyond the usual suspicion just yet

Judgemax : playing soooo differently from last time, makes me suspicious.

Jensons : no read yet, but I think I lean towards an innocent here.

There ya go...something to talk about

 

[judgemax]

Ice : can't detect anything suspicious beyond the usual suspicion just yet

Judgemax : playing soooo differently from last time, makes me suspicious.

Jensons : no read yet, but I think I lean towards an innocent here.

There ya go...something to talk about

I have to ask, several of you have said i am playing different?..i don't see how?..And, they are very good observations coler, (obviously about every one but me, ..but its good to see you not standing on the soap box, ..)LOL, i might add, your throwing me for a loop, your playing more game 3, than 4...so, at least I can have less suspicion of you at this point...lol

 

[joander123]

coler just singles me out, because i voted for him.

Did it ever occur that maybe i am just a newbie?

 

[Coler]

Conclusion : either bad mafia, or just new to the game. Lot of panicky defences in there as well

Singled out in a post mentioning six players ??