AC's Herp ID Game :)

Plethodon cinereus
 
Lol, these guys are the most common species around where I live. I bet I can find one in my backyard right now if I flip over a stone or two. I'll wait for GER to confirm it.


Edit: Sweet, I'm up. :D
 
You're on the right track. It's definitely a turtle.
 
Geoclemmys hamiltoni?
 
AquariaCentral.com