Added cories to new tank, fish appeared to go into shock, improved after removal...

RamenAficianado

Registered Member
Jan 7, 2009
3
0
0
42
Hey, all. I'm new here.. apologies for the mammoth post and lack of an intro, but I am having something of an emergency.



A couple of hours ago, I came across some young long-finned albino cories at our local Wal-Mart. I bought them all (7). I happened to have an empty 10 gallon set up (has been sitting for 3 weeks with aeration but no filtration) in anticipation of some albino cories I nicked from my parents’ last spawn. (The fry still aren’t big enough for this tank yet.) I decided to put these guys in there for now.

There was a thin film on top of the water, but increasing the aeration and setting up the backfilter took care of this, and the water quality appeared to be OK, so (after 20 minutes of floating the bag) I added the fish. They appeared to be doing great for the first 15 minutes or so.. active, feeding, all that good stuff. Half an hour later, I returned to find several of the fish inactive, three of them laying on their backs.

The water temperature is 74 degrees (tends to vary from 72-76 depending on the time of day), and the test strip reads

Nitrite: 0
Nitrate: 0
Total Hardness (GH): soft (~75).
Alkalinity (KH): reads somewhere in between ideal and high.. appears closer to high (300).
pH: ~8-ish.

Could a pH/GH/KH change have shocked the fish? I hadn’t considered that our water could be problematic because the fry have been doing so well.. though I suppose they’ve spent their entire lives in it, and these guys haven’t acclimated to it yet.

My other concern is that the 10 gallon is currently residing in the bathroom.. I’m wondering if the various soaps and sprays that have been used in there might be toxic to the fish.. could these have accumulated in the water over the past few weeks? I don’t use much in the way of products.. but I’ve never had a tank in the bathroom before. Perhaps this was a bad idea.

They are doing well at the moment in a small container of water taken from the fry tank.. but this water is of the very same quality as the stuff in the 10 gallon.. and it’s not plausible to keep them in said container for any length of time, because I have no way of heating or aerating it. They will not do well sans heat, as my house is fairly cold in the winter- the goldfish tank (unheated) is somewhere in the neighborhood of 63 right now.

I would prefer not to put them in the fry tank, as it is far too small for so many fish, and the fry are still small enough that I fear they may be injured by the larger cories.

Any thoughts on how to best handle the situation?


Much thanks!!
 
Get the tank out of the bathroom, empty it, wash it out with water and distilled white vinegar, rinse THOROUGHLY. The film on the surface was evidently from the soaps/sprays. The tank shouldn't be in the bathroom.
 
Much thanks!

This is what I was afraid of.. when I added the fish, I had figured the film was due to a lack of filtration/low aeration in the tank. It didn't occur to me until after the fish started crashing that something else might be at play.

I've rigged up a temporary setup using water from the fry tank, and everyone seems to have recovered.. I'll clean the tank out in the morning, move it elsewhere, and hopefully we'll have better luck this time.
 
Unfortunately, the new test strips I bought don't test for ammonia.. thought they were pretty much all-inclusive, but I guess not. I will have to pick up some new ones today. All the cories are doing well as of this morning, so I am going to keep them in the temp setup for the day, as I have to run out for a few hours, and I don't want to leave them in the tank unattended in case there's a problem while I'm gone. I plan to set up the tank later today.

If I am starting out fresh with a newly cleaned tank, would it be beneficial to add a little water from an established tank?
 
Water will do nothing to help you cycle. There's very little free floating bacteria in it. You would be best off to put some filter media from one of your existing tanks in a media bag and put it into the cleaned 10g. That would give you the most bang for your buck.

As for as the test strips go, they're wildly innacurate. If I were you, I'd get the API master freshwater liquid drop test kit. It's much more accurate and will give you more of a piece of mind since you really seem to want to do what's best for your fish :)
 
Corydoras are hardy fish so they should be alright in the tank.But you might lose some.
 
Water from an established tank wont do anything as all the bacteria that are beneficial are in the filter media. U need to start from scratch..get the tank out of the bathroom and cycle using media from an established tank. All those cories will die if that tank isnt cycled u wont just be "sacrificing" a few.
 
AquariaCentral.com