I am a big Oscar fan as well as Africans. The pro for Africans is you can keep more fish in a 55g usually but with an Oscar you really limited to 1. What is your first tank? I had a 29g community tank and quickly became bored and replaced the food, opps, I mean neons, with Africans who quickly ate the neons. Africans do have nice color but I just dont care for the tank set up for Africans if you want your tank to resemble their natural environment. Oscars are one of the fish with a "pet like" personality more than any other fish I have kept. The enjoy feeders as well. Flip a coin.