Algae Chemicals?

7itanium

AC Members
Jan 31, 2009
1,794
0
0
39
Spokane, WA
I found some stuff at petco that claims it will get rid of algae.. it also claims it is safe for plants

has anyone ever used these type of chemicals?

Do They Work?
Are they safe in planted tank?
Are they safe for fish?
Should I continue Dosing Ferts while using?
 
Never used them and probably never will. One thing I will advise is that chemicals will not always solve the root of the problem. So in a sense you are only masking the underlying issue, which may keep popping up later on.

I prefer to either 1) decrease lighting if possible 2) control nutrient supply by either feeding less or tweaking my dosing schedule or 3) getting my Co2 to be more consistent. Your choice though.
 
well I already know the root of the problem... so this isnt an attempt to solve the problem-- its just to keep my tank looking presentable untill I can get a better CO2 system
 
Using chemicals to destroy algae isn't the best method out there. It's a temporary fix, if it even works.
Most, if not all, of them are safe for fish. Some are safe for plants too, although they're rarely safe for inverts. So if you have shrimp/snails, they'll probably die off.

If you decide to use them however, dosing ferts will depend on what algae you have. If your algae is due to excessive fertilization, then don't dose ferts or reduce dosage. Most of the time, algae is due to not enough co2 and too much ferts. If you dose XX amount of ferts for XX amount of gallons, as recommended in some dosing sites, then you need the proper amount of co2 to help plants absorb all those nutrients dosed. If you don't have enough co2 to help the plants process the light, that helps them take in nutrients, then you're looking at a lot of nutrients in the water column going unused and algae ends up taking advantage of it.


In any case, dosing chemicals to remove the algae can potentially kill off the algae for the time being but if no tweaks and changes are made, they will just grow back in a matter of time.

I would suggest you identify the algae you have, find the source of its growth (whether it's lack of co2, too much light, lack of nutrient, whatnot). Then tackle it that way by correcting what you're lacking or having too much of. This will help you out in the long run by eliminating that algae from your tank forever (or until an imbalance occurs again). It will also protect your inhabitants from being exposed to chemicals.

Going the "All Natural" way is always the best ;-)

To eliminate the current algae, use flourish excel. Inject it at the algae sites to kill them off. It should help you "restart" the war as you fix the problem.
 
greeeat... sure wish I had read this 5 minutes ago before I dosed my tank...

there is snails in there!

guess im doing a 90% water change tonight...
 
well I already know the root of the problem... so this isnt an attempt to solve the problem-- its just to keep my tank looking presentable untill I can get a better CO2 system
What type of algae?

If it's removable by elbow grease I would continue to do just that, personally.
 
What type of algae?

If it's removable by elbow grease I would continue to do just that, personally.

pretty sure its mostly blue-green algae

it is removable on the glass... I have been scrubbing it daily-- but it is very difficult to get it all off... and it is also covering some of my leaves and substrate
 
Gravel vac as much as you can, increase the flow in those areas via powerhead or canister filter outflow directing that area or even HOB flow will work (if it's strong that is). Increase nitrate levels to 20-25 and it should go away. Just make sure to keep up the manual removal too. It'll stop growing if you keep the flow + nitrate levels up and manual removal will help you eradicate the remaining survivors.
 
do you have any idea how hard it is to keep nitrate levels up in a heavily planted tank...

my water seldom even shows signs of ammonia, let alone nitrate lol
 
That's why you need to dose more nitrates ;-)

My tanks are VERY planted too, so you're not the only one who needs to keep nitrates up for them.
 
AquariaCentral.com