Am I overstocked??

mclife

AC Members
Nov 2, 2004
42
0
0
I finished cycling my new 150 gallon and added my stock of fish. They are:

3 3in clown loaches
4 3in bala sharks
1 2in red pacu
1 5in tire track eel
1 4in clown knife

The tank is a tad bare right now, but I know these fish will grow where some may even outgrow the tank.

Any suggestions of some colorful or oddballs I could add that won't get HUGE and still get along with the guys in there? Or am I at my stocking limit, or beyond it already?
 
I would get rid of the pacu as soon as possible. Replace it with another clown loach. They just aren't meant for smaller tanks (and even a 150 gallon is a bit small for a pacu). Anything that doesn't get huge will probably hunted down by some of those guys so i wouldn't add anything else.

http://www.thetropicaltank.co.uk/Fishindx/pacu-red.htm
 
I think the clown knife will be fine in there for quite a while... I would keep it, then maybe sell it back to the LFS after it gets around 14-16 inches.
 
What's the shape of the tank?

The general rule is 1 inch of fish for 1 gallon. Less for large ciclids. You can house more fish in a short rectangular tank than in a tall "show tank". A little more accurate rule is to take the length and multiply by the width and devide by 12 (12 sq inch of surface area per inch of fish in a tropical tank). It's really all about surface area at the top where gas exhchange takes place. Filtration is another thing. A lot of people overcrowd, overfeed, over water change, and over filter. What I'm talking about is what is safe from an oxigen standpoint for your fish. If you follow this, normal maintenance and normal filtration will do as well. If your tank is 60X24X24, then you can have 60X24/12 = 120 inchs of fish. I would stay a little below this number for larger fish. After having your fish for a few years they would be about
3 6in clown loaches for 18in
4 6in bala sharks for 24in
1 18in red pacu for 18in
1 12in tire track eel for 12in
1 12in clown knife for 12in
for a total of 84 inchs of fish. So I would say you are cool as far as the rules go. But if this is only a 24in wide tank, it could become uncomfortable for the Paco. And they grow fast. I've seen 16 year old loaches that are only 4 inches and a 1 year old Paco that is 12. I'm with everyone else. I'd get rid of the Paco and Knife soon. I always thought that the biggest fish were the coolest, but it's funny - if you get like 30 Tetras, the way they school and swim around....I almost think of them as "1" fish. There's my Tetras, my loach, my shark, etc. Think of how many 3 inch fish you could keep if you had 120 inchs to play with. That would be around 40 fish....wouldn't that be cool. Or you could just have a really large Pacu.

Joe
 
Last edited:
I would agree that the pacu should go and keep an eye on the knife...some tin foil barbs are always nice, too. You could add another 4 or 5 clown loaches - I have 7 in a 75g tank and they are great - the more you have, the more active and goofy they are! You can never have too many clown loaches - just keep an eye out for ich. As earlier stated by another poster, 1 inch per gallon is a general rule, but you can cheat a bit if you over filter and do alot of water changes!
 
Last edited:
The clown knife will be fine.

Ditch the pacu.

Don't add anymore fish.

Your fish will get much bigger and grow out.
 
Last edited:
AquariaCentral.com