Answer a question with a question game

Nope, never been evil....but you would know, wouldn't you?
 
Does one have to be evil, to be mafia?
 
Are you speaking to John or Old 3 Toes?
 
Why do they call him "old 3 toes" anyway?
 
Wasn't it an accident in his lumberjack days back in the 60s?
 
Don't you slam it on your toes until they fall off?
 
AquariaCentral.com