Best cannister filters and why?

Well, at least we can compare more easily. These are still larger than Dupla's and I suspect for W/D - emerse use. I don't know how much the 2.2 cm of Dupla vs. the 2.54 cm of Coralife is going to influence canister packing. The Coralife has more surface/ball 67 cm2 vs 39 cm2 for Dupla. They give quite similar water volumes supported - 0.15 gal/ball for Coralife, 0.185 gal/ball for Dupla - which is a bit strange as the Coralife is larger and has more surface. Coralife also requires a lot more room to pack - 1 gal for the balls, vs well less than 2 liters for Dupla.

There is a disconnect in Coralife's data - in the text they give 300 balls per gallon, in the product list they give 225 balls per gallon - big difference.

But they could work if you are planning on using large volume canisters for bio-

Don't hold me to the numbers, I ran through them fast - if you seriously consider these I re-do more carefully.
 
Spheres are a good packing configuration, but when you are packing them in cyclinders (many canisters) or rounded corner rectangular boxes with baskets (many other canisters) both of those being taller than they are wide, small increases in diameter can have large effects on the number of units which will be held in the use container (the canister).

The Dupla spheres pack theoretically at 120 units per liter, or about 454 per gallon. The Coralife pack theoretically (depending on which figure you use from their site) at 225 or 300 units per gallon. That theoretic packing should be in a spherical container, but the odds are it is not, but you can bet it is at least in a cube box (Dupla uses triangle boxes for selling - don't ask me why). The farther away the use container is from a sphere or cube, the greater the effect of the size of the individual units on packing. For the two units we looking at the smaller gets at least 50% more, perhaps twice the number of units in the same size container, with only a 15% increase in diameter from the smaller to the larger unit. This is not just the volume increases being a cubed function, so small changes in size are large changes in volume, but also how many will fit in the diameter inside the cylinder that is the canister.

Does that make sense? If you have kids, you can play with two marble sizes in highball glasses to see the effect of diameter restriction on packing. I used that with my son who was in secondary school at the time I was playing with this myself. He had a hard time seeing why I did not just use the same larger Dupla Biokaskade spheres I use in my W/Ds (where the towers are very nearly cubes BTW - good packing).
 
I love my XP3 fisltar. I is very quiet, the amount of media room is huge, and the configuration for the in/outputs is great. If you want to go cheap: I bought mine used off of ebay 55$, i came with course sponges fine sponges. i layered mine (in order of water flow0 blue White self cut fiter pad, 2 course, 1 fine, 1 1/2 cages of lava rock( from poshy home gardening store, small for indoor plants) and a fine spong on top ( in case anyt of the rock was small enough to ge sucked up. I know that this was a one time deal but you may be able to find something similar.

someone might not like my choice of lava rock but I have power cycled 2 canisters using this and there seems to be no detriment to flow. The bacteria load is phenomenal because i cycle these running in a 25 gal rubbermaid and seed with old gravel in a sock from another tank. After the initial cycle is over at 5ppmamm gone and trite spike is over , I increase load the tank with amm ttil it is way off the chart an is being cleared in 24 hrs. The whole process usually takes 2weeks. If the filter can handle that much ammonia and not have a decrease in flow, then my choice of media is sufficient.
 
I just bought a HOT (hang on tank) Magnum and found that as a purely mechanical filter it works excellent. Very easy to setup and clean. I run it every so often to clear up my tanks, especially after moving stuff around in the tank.
 
goldfish freak - I found a place in the US that will do mail order and does carry Dulpa's Minikaskade.

From an Email I recieved from Hawaiian Marine Imports, Inc.

Contact Tom Mars at Hydro Logix, Inc. @ 860-491-2700, mail order in Connecticut.

Thank you.

Hawaiian Marine Imports, Inc.

HTH
-Richer
 
Richer, Thanks. Just to make things clear are you saying that this place that you mentioned will sell and ship to Canada?

RTR, thank you again. Since the Coralife bioballs have approximately 40% more surface area per ball and since there are approximately twice as many Dupla bioballs than Coralife per gallon, then wouldn't a gallon of Coralife bioballs have close to the same amount of surface area as a gallon of Dupla bioballs? Coralife: 225x67cm2= 15075cm2, Dupla: 454x39cm2= 17706cm2. Or a I missing something here? I think I see what you are saying here, but do you think I would be able to fit half or more of the larger bioballs in the same amount of space?
 
Last edited:
AquariaCentral.com