i think that when one says to use one method and someone agrees then it tends to lean toward that disition. i just can't believe that someone would even recomend to do something like that. i know from my own experience that it's very difficult to make right chices when you are new and allow someone unexpirienced to think of doing something like that is pushing an issue too far. it was bad idea and no one should have mentioned it. you need to get bio-spira to help your system. do a water change for now, it's possible that it won't get worse. add some Prime to keep everything less toxic. if your tank smells bad then rock is curing , which is not good. you don't have that many kritters or fish, so setting up another tank with few pieces of cured rock would be great. i'm done here. you guys got her into it, so get her out of it. good luck