Betta tank, which is better?

oooh environmental considerations! Well in that case you should use the 5 gallon to house the work hamsters who will create the power with their wheels. then there is the feed considerations, though you could hydroponically grow the hamster's food in the tank, and use the dried plants for hamster straw to sleep in. The old tank water would go into the worm farm set-up, to give the fish a varied diet.

Human convenience is fish convenience...it is easier for me to do less waster changes...if done on a filtered tank, the fish too would be happy. If done in the unfiltered tank, it would soon parish.

Finantial considerations are also in the fishes best interest. If you are paying too much on your hamster care to run the power filter/heater, you might as well have tanken the other option. I don't think the GOVT. offers finantial support to fish keepers who have exceeded their budget, despite how much I think they should.

Now if you worked those to out to your preference, then you'd be more likely to be motivated to take care of your fish. if the set up was a burden, it would potentially suffer neglect.

There was another point I thought of before. Unfortunately I just learned a new fact, and apparently it pushed the old point out of my head. I'll have to get back to you.

So holly, does the winner get the betta and a heated tank?
 
Thanks guys... Very FUNNY :laugh: !! I'm sure my husband would love it if I told him I needed to get "work hampsters" to run the tank in a more environmentally conscious way!! I wish there was a right answer, I am really just looking for opinions on either in case there is something I am overlooking.

Basically I have a 2.5g set-up with a filter and a heater. I had my betta in it a while ago and then I came across a couple of very cheap 10g tanks, which looked better on my kithchen counter, so Mr. betta got an upgrade....
I want to get a second betta for my sons room (due in December :D ) and have always liked the look of bettas in large decorative vases without all the filters/wires etc. So, I was/am considering getting a very large vase sort of structure (at least 5g, maybe more) for him. On such a small tank, the water changes are not an issue, it only takes a couple of minutes, and I too worry a great deal about my fish, so I would make sure he was not living in bad water.

Personally, I think I would rather have more room, but I might be missing something. I guess if it does not work out, I always have the 2.5g
 
ah kasakato, you're no fun!!

No work hamsters, huh? I heard they're unionizing anyway, too many legal issue there. then you'd need a Lizard Lawyer and I don't think you have an appropriate set-up for that!

On topic: more info now! since you don't care about cost, and more about the fish, I'd do what you said....get the one you think looks cool, that you want to try out, and have the 2.5 to fall back on. I thought that 5g is the perfect size for a betta. lots of room, but not obscenely huge for just one creature. It also presents options for adding more plants or fauna.

I am very lazy at times, usually the time when I am supposed to do a water change, if they are so frequent. Hence picking the filtered option.
 
I'm one of those horrible people who thinks that a betta in a decarative vase with some plantage hanging out of it looks really cool. And I'm going to swear that the bettas don't really mind so long as they have a good house cleaning service and a delivery from the local 5 star restaurant.

And forget the hampsters. I saw them throwing hampster balls at anyone crossing the picket line ...
 
jaylin said:
I'm one of those horrible people who thinks that a betta in a decarative vase with some plantage hanging out of it looks really cool..

I agree, and in many cases, that is when they are mistreated, or left to starve to death by being forced to eat roots :sad: But, I think with frequent water changes and a stable temp. it would be ok

P.S. I went over the hampster idea with the family, the cats are very interested in the proposal :rolleyes:
 
AquariaCentral.com