c02 off and on

eaglesandfish

AC Members
Nov 12, 2007
79
0
0
Porter TX
I have recently been considering a diy co2 for my tank. It is moderately planted. My question is.. Can co2 injection be an additive when my plants need a little boost or is it something that once started, it needs to be continued.
I had a planted community tank a few years ago and I only used ferts once every several months. Can I do the same thing with DIY co2.:help:
 
I have recently been considering a diy co2 for my tank. It is moderately planted. My question is.. Can co2 injection be an additive when my plants need a little boost or is it something that once started, it needs to be continued.
I had a planted community tank a few years ago and I only used ferts once every several months. Can I do the same thing with DIY co2.:help:

Only if you want a lush coatine of black beard algae killing off your plants.

It's best to be consistent. If that's a real problem, try Flourish Excel.
 
yes. I am talking about my 60. Ive got a medium amazon sword, two small oz..? swords, some java moss, and some micro sword. ( micro sword not doing as well as I want)
 
What squawkbert means is that with fluctuating levels of co2, you'll be encouraging algae growth.

As for turning off/on diy co2:


jmhart said:
Here's the situation with turning on/off your DIY co2. It is not bad for your plants to be exposed to CO2 at night, they just don't use it. In fact, plants will convert co2 into malic acid at night, storing it for use the next day, so if anything, it's good for them. However, it's not that much better for them than turning off the co2 at night. The bottom line is, leaving your co2 on at night wastes co2. Now, for a pressurized co2 system(i.e. out of a gas cylinder) you can just stop the co2 and it's just cut off, no problem, saves money.

With DIY CO2, when you "turn off" the 2L bottles, the yeast keep producing, and the pressure just builds inside your bottles. People will say this is "dangerous." It's not. As long as your aren't using glass bottles(average glass can withstand up to 5 psig of pressure, i.e. not a lot) you won't build enough pressure in a single night to bust your plastic 2L bottles. However, what happens is, the next day, when you "turn on" your co2, it doesn't just trickle out, it "explodes" out, sending all that co2 up to the surface where it is wasted.

On top of that, because you turned off your co2, now your co2 level in the tank is very low(co2 in tank been diffusing out at the surface all night), so it has to build back up to a useful level.

Point is, with DIY CO2, better to leave it on at night.
 
Thanks Jmhart, for the info. To clairify, I was thinking about setting up a diy co2 and letting it run its course. Then remove the system and redo every few months as needed. I was not talking about stopping and starting the flow of C02 form the bottle. That could get messy.
I just was not sure I wanted to start dosing with C02 if I was then stuck with remixing every couple of weeks.
 
Thanks everyone, I believe you have made up my mind. No C02 for me. (at least for now) I appreciate everyones thoughts.
 
AquariaCentral.com