In bio-only canister, I prefer using either ceramic noodles (I like Ehfimech) or bioballs. I don't like the rough noodles -- these are actually a sintered glass product (they used to be marketed as Siporax, but I think the name has changed).
Sintered glass does have greater surface area for colonization, but only for a limited time. After a while (6 months, a year perhaps) the micropores clog and cannot be recovered. You then have to replace it or live with the a surface area that approximates plain old ceramic noodles. Even worse, the rough surface tends to not slough off dead biofilm as easily as smooth noodles, so there is a need for more cleaning or colonizable surface will decrease.
Bioballs also tend to slough off dead biofilm and require less maintenance. I have a couple canisters that still have Siporax in them, and they require considerably more maintenance than the smooth noodles or bioballs.
Since I want my bio-only canisters to require as little maintenance as possible, I try to avoid using sintered glass media in them.
HTH,
Jim
Sintered glass does have greater surface area for colonization, but only for a limited time. After a while (6 months, a year perhaps) the micropores clog and cannot be recovered. You then have to replace it or live with the a surface area that approximates plain old ceramic noodles. Even worse, the rough surface tends to not slough off dead biofilm as easily as smooth noodles, so there is a need for more cleaning or colonizable surface will decrease.
Bioballs also tend to slough off dead biofilm and require less maintenance. I have a couple canisters that still have Siporax in them, and they require considerably more maintenance than the smooth noodles or bioballs.
Since I want my bio-only canisters to require as little maintenance as possible, I try to avoid using sintered glass media in them.
HTH,
Jim