Columnaris or Fungus?

kreesdqban

Miami Aquarist
Jan 30, 2009
293
0
16
Miami
Today I woke up and saw that my angelfish had some white cottony growth on its long lower fins. I have pictures and wanted to know if this was a fungal infection or columnaris. Ive seen many different discussions about this on the forum and wanted to make sure. I just did a water change and my params are 0-0-5. You can see my tank info at the bottom. Should I put salt and go buy some Melafix? I have to go to Petsmart anyways so I just want a quick answer if somebody can help...:help2:

PC120242.jpg
 
Could you try to post some pictures that are a bit more clear? I'm having trouble seeing it, but I'd guess it may be bacterial and it could be Columnaris.

Quick response is very important in treating Columnaris successfully. I would take the temperature of the tank down to 76 slowly, and add salt, bringing the salinity slowly up to 2% and even 3% is better if the fish don't seem to be having any difficulties with 2%.

If it's fungus the salt in the water won't do any harm, and if it's Columnaris the salinity can have a dramatic effect in preventing the spread of the disease and the mortality of any infected fish.

This is a first action based on your description, but when we have better pictures then we can know for sure if it's Columnaris or fungal (probably not) and treat accordingly.

A few questions: Have you had any new additions to the tank? Has there been any unusual stress, such as fluctuating temperatures or spikes in ammonia or nitrite?

If it's Columnaris I don't think Melafix will be sufficient to treat it. Please try to get some more pictures posted asap.

http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=134928

The above link is an exceptional thread discussing Columnaris, posted by one of our fish Gurus, Flaringshutter. Please read this and also try to post more pics when you can, in the meantime bring your water temperature down and try to do the salt.
Table salt is fine, you don't need to spend money on Aquarium salt. The iodine and anti-caking ingredients are in trace amounts and will be no problem.
 
Well I added salt and rose the water temp a bit and the fungus seemed to go away. I researched a bit on columnaris and don't think this is what it is. My angelfish is the only one this happens to and now it is back. Should I maybe treat the tank with some med like Pimafix or Melafix? I don't like the fact that it keeps coming back, and only on the angelfish...
 
bump
 
It wouldnt hurt to treat the tank. Some of my fish had columnaris and Melafix treated them just fine if that is what they had. I still dont know for sure.
 
I don't think its columnaris. Its always a cotton ball on the angelfish's "barbels" i guess you could call them. It seems to go away and come back...
 
It's not fungal either by the look of it. Try ensuring pristine water conditions at all times.
 
WTC?
 
AquariaCentral.com