The boss got feeder goldfish for the concrete pond outside in the patio at our workplace. Most are now about 2 years old (some more, some less) and all +4" long. They are slender but maybe an inch wide; they look firm and healthy. They started out variations of carrot colored, and some had black-tipped fins or even black spots. The blacks eventually turned all carrot-colored. One carrot turned whitish (I thought it was ill, but it has been that way since the spring, so...) and now the white one is getting a yellow head. Another carrot is blotchy white; maybe it wants to be all white, too. Some have taken on black-tipped fins, and some are deep carrot colored, others lighter. I think they are just happy in their algae- & minnow-infested water in the middle of Albuquerque and they change color as nature dictates. Soon winter will hit and they'll be in the shade & under ice on & off for several months. Hope they survive again; it's supposed to be a hard winter, and the filter/fountain isn't working as well as it did last winter...