Emergency Ick Help, Which option to choose?

Herndo

AC Members
Apr 2, 2004
44
0
0
46
Visit site
Ok guys here's the story. I brought in a Harlequin tusk from an LFS about 2 months ago. Long story short, he died of ick and took two clowns and a chromis with him.

Bought a Q tank, (I know a little too late!) I waited for 1 month with my temp in the tank and no fish in the tank. All of my remaining fish went to Q tank and I treated them with copper. 1 month later, no sign of Ick. Fish go back to big tank (55 gallon, wet/dry, 60lbs LR, Protien Skimmer) waited 2 more weeks, ordered another Tusk and an Equisite Wrasse (small). Quaranteened them for 1 more month, a small ick outbreak during first week, treated with copper, all gone.

Finally put them in big tank, first 3 weeks, everything is great. All eating well, happy & getting along. All of a sudden Wrasse gets spots all other fish fine. I immediately read the boards, test the water and do a 20% water change, order meds and treat with garlic. Water parameters were fine. No Amonia, no Nitrite, 15-20 nitrates. Now two clowns, the wrasse and the tusk have spots. The Tusk has lots of white dust looking stuff on him and this all came on overnight.

I cranked my Q tank back up just in case of emergency , but I would like to treat w/o using copper. I used my first treatment today of the Probiotic Marine Formula and the Kent Marine Rx*P from Doctors Foster and Smith. Both claim to be reef safe. I've also been soakin all food in Seachem Garlic Guard.

Again, this is the first day of treatment with the two meds, but the garlic's been gong since Wed. and things have only gotten worse. I fear that the tusk is getting bad and it's affecting his behavior. I think he may have started rubbing against the rocks. Should I keep the treatment going or risk stressing him even more by catching him and moving him to the Q tank to be treated with Copper. Or is it already too late?
 
In my opinion, since you do have a qt. tank. Definetely quarantine all of your fish (to be on the safe side). All the medication that are reef safe arn't nearly as strong as a copper treatment. The strongest reef safe med. that i know of is greenx, but the company went out of business.
Again, my advice.....qt. asap.....maybe even a freshwater dip once you have them in the net. Also keep treaten the main tank with the meds that you have (as prescribed) just to make sure you kill the already free floating parasites.
Good Luck
 
One of the better choices, if you don't want to use copper (as many people don't because it can weaken the fish further), is a hyposalinity quarantine. This is done by lowering the salinity slowly to 1.009. This is too low a salinity for most varieties of ich to survive the trophant stage, meaning that your fish's outbreak will be made less severe. After six weeks of hyposalinity quarantine, ich will usually die out. However, if it's in the main tank, you might as well just wait until the fish pretty well recovers and try moving it back. (And right back into hyposalinity if it immediately gets sick again.)

Other tricks involve soaking food in garlic and trying a cleaner shrimp or cleaner goby. These won't cure the fish of ich, but they may help the fish strengthen it's own immune response.

There are also a variety of products that claim to be effective and reef safe, but many seem to only work sometimes.
 
AquariaCentral.com